Birla Mt Gordon Pty Ltd v Calton Hills Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Birla Mt Gordon Pty Ltd v Calton Hills Pty Ltd [2015] QLC 2
PARTIES: Birla Mt Gordon Pty Ltd
(applicant)
v

Calton Hills Pty Ltd
(respondent)

FILE NOS:
MRA 283-09 MRA 289-09 MRA 295-09 MRA301-09
MRA 284-09 MRA 290-09 MRA 296-09 MRA302-09
MRA 285-09 MRA 291-09 MRA 297-09 MRA303-09
MRA 286-09 MRA 292-09 MRA 298-09 MRA304-09
MRA 287-09 MRA 293-09 MRA 299-09
MRA 288-09 MRA 294-09 MRA 300-09
DIVISION: General Division
PROCEEDINGS: Determination of compensation payable for renewal of mining leases
DELIVERED ON: 30 January 2015
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD ON: Submissions closed 17 October 2014
HEARD AT: Heard on the papers
PRESIDENT:

CAC MacDonald

ORDERS:
  1. In the case of ML 5489 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  2. In the case of ML 5467 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  3. In the case of ML 5420 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  4. In the case of ML 5459 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  5. In the case of ML 5412 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  6. In the case of ML 5407 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  7. In the case of ML 5413 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  8. In the case of ML 5418 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  9. In the case of ML 5442 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  10. In the case of ML 5419 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  11. In the case of ML 5429 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  12. In the case of ML 5430 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  13. In the case of ML 5441 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  14. In the case of ML 5443 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  15. In the case of ML 5444 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  16. In the case of ML 5485 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  17. In the case of ML 5451 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  18. In the case of ML 5486 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  19. In the case of ML 5454 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  20. In the case of ML 5549 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  21. In the case of ML 5500 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).
  22. In the case of ML 5457 compensation is determined in the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Birla Mt Gordon Pty Ltd v Calton Hills Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QLC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Birla Mt Gordon Pty Ltd, the applicant, sought compensation for the renewal of a series of mining leases, against Calton Hills Pty Ltd, the respondent. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The applicant argued that the renewal of the mining leases should not result in compensation being payable by the applicant to the respondent. The respondent, however, contended that compensation should be paid, and the applicant’s refusal to pay amounted to a breach of the mining lease agreements.

The court was required to determine whether compensation was payable for the renewal of the mining leases. The court considered the statutory provisions governing the renewal of mining leases and the terms of the agreements between the parties. The court noted that the statutory provisions did not explicitly provide for compensation on the renewal of mining leases, but the agreements between the parties contained clauses that required the payment of compensation on renewal. The court held that the agreements were valid and enforceable, and that the clauses requiring the payment of compensation on renewal were binding on the parties.

The court found that the agreements between the parties were clear and unambiguous, and that the parties had intended to require the payment of compensation on the renewal of the mining leases. The court held that the applicant was liable to pay the respondent compensation in accordance with the terms of the agreements. The court determined the amount of compensation payable by reference to uncontradicted expert evidence.

The court ordered that the applicant was to pay the respondent compensation in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000) for each of the mining leases listed in the orders, within 60 days of the date of renewal of the relevant tenures.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In the case of ML 5489 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

2. In the case of ML 5467 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

3. In the case of ML 5420 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

4. In the case of ML 5459 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

5. In the case of ML 5412 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

6. In the case of ML 5407 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

7. In the case of ML 5413 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

8. In the case of ML 5418 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

9. In the case of ML 5442 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

10. In the case of ML 5419 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

11. In the case of ML 5429 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

12. In the case of ML 5430 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

13. In the case of ML 5441 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

14. In the case of ML 5443 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

15. In the case of ML 5444 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

16. In the case of ML 5485 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

17. In the case of ML 5451 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

18. In the case of ML 5486 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

19. In the case of ML 5454 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

20. In the case of ML 5549 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

21. In the case of ML 5500 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

22. In the case of ML 5457 compensation is determined in the total sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5000).

23. The applicant miner is to pay the respondent landowner the amounts in Orders 1 to 22 within 60 days of the date of renewal of the relevant tenures.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established