Birks v The State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   BIRKS -v- THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2007] WASCA 29

CORAM:   STEYTLER P

PULLIN JA
BUSS JA

HEARD:   15 SEPTEMBER 2006

DELIVERED          :   7 FEBRUARY 2007

FILE NO/S:   CACR 64 of 2005

BETWEEN:   DOUGLAS BIRKS

Appellant

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :SIMMONDS J

File No  :INS 121 of 2004

Catchwords:

Criminal law - Appeal against arson and murder convictions - Evidence - Admissibility of experiments and tests - Admissibility of video showing "demonstration burn" - Whether miscarriage of justice occurred - Disputed admissions on video records of interview - Whether trial Judge failed properly to direct the jury or give a "McKinney" direction - Whether trial Judge erred in failing to direct the jury as to the availability of s 24 Criminal Code (WA) defence - New evidence - Whether, having regard to the new evidence, a miscarriage of justice occurred - Where new evidence was inconsistent with the appellant's case at trial

Legislation:

Criminal Appeals Act 2004 (WA), s 30(3), s 30(4)
Criminal Code (WA), s 24, s 266, s 279(2), s 282, s 444, s 570D
Sentencing Act 1995 (WA), s 90(1)

Result:

Appeal dismissed

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant:     Ms H E Prince

Respondent:     Mr S Van Dongen

Solicitors:

Appellant:     Andree Horrigan

Respondent:     State Director of Public Prosecutions

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Aubertin v The State of Western Australia [2006] WASCA 229

Chamberlain v The Queen [No 2] (1984) 153 CLR 514

G J Coles & Co Ltd v Goldsworthy [1985] WAR 183

Georgiadis (2002) 133 A Crim R 152

In Re Van Beelen (1974) 9 SASR 163

Lawless v The Queen (1979) 142 CLR 659

McKinney v The Queen (1991) 171 CLR 468

Pacino (1998) 105 A Crim R 309

R v Baker [1989] 3 NZLR 635

R v Ireland (No 2) [1971] SASR 6

R v Kypri (2002) 5 VR 610

R v Neilan [1992] 1 VR 57

R v Soma (2003) 212 CLR 299

Shepherd v State (1931) 51 Okl Cr 209; 300 Pac 421

Suresh v The Queen (1998) 72 ALJR 769

Thompson v The Queen (1986) 13 FCR 165

  1. STEYTLER P:  I agree with Buss JA.

  2. PULLIN JA:  I agree with Buss JA.  The following additional observations relate to ground 2.

  3. Detective Senior Constable Tilley was called to express expert opinion about the likelihood of a lighted cigarette having caused the fire.  He formed an opinion, on his review of literature on the subject, that it was difficult, but not impossible, for a burning cigarette to start a fire in a bed.  The "demonstration burn" or experiment which he conducted led him to express the opinion in evidence‑in‑chief that "as you would have seen from the tests it is quite impossible to create a fire with a cigarette butt".  The relevant passages in cross‑examination which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Birks v The State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASCA 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Birks v The State of Western Australia involved an appeal against the appellant's conviction for arson and murder. The appeal raised several significant legal issues, including the admissibility of certain evidence, the reliability of a video showing a "demonstration burn," and the potential for a miscarriage of justice due to the introduction of new evidence. The appellant also contested the trial judge's directions to the jury and the failure to consider a specific defence under section 24 of the Criminal Code (WA). The Court of Appeal had to determine whether the trial judge erred in the admission of evidence, the interpretation of the evidence, and whether there was a miscarriage of justice due to the introduction of new evidence post-trial.

The Court of Appeal carefully examined the evidence presented by the appellant, particularly the report by Mr John Marshall, who had expertise in forensic investigation of fires. The court scrutinised Mr Marshall's views on the possible causes of the fire, the reliability of the police "demonstration burn," and the probability of a lit cigarette butt igniting bedding material. The court found that Mr Marshall's opinions challenged the police evidence and suggested that the fire could have been caused by an undetermined cause rather than being deliberately lit. However, the court also noted that Mr Marshall's report was prepared post-trial and was not available at the time of the original trial. The court had to weigh the reliability and relevance of this new evidence against the evidence presented at the trial.

In its judgment, the Court of Appeal concluded that the new evidence, while potentially significant, did not undermine the safety and satisfaction of the jury's verdict. The court held that the trial judge had properly directed the jury and that there was no miscarriage of justice. The court found that the trial judge had not erred in failing to give a specific direction regarding the availability of the section 24 defence, as the evidence did not support such a direction. The Court of Appeal thus upheld the convictions and rejected the appeal.

The Court of Appeal also refused the appellant's application to add a further ground of appeal and to adduce new evidence. The court found that the new evidence did not warrant a reconsideration of the trial's outcome and that the appellant's application was not supported by sufficient justification. The Court of Appeal's decision was grounded in the principle that new evidence should not lightly be admitted in an appeal if it could have been discovered at the time of the original trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the hearing of the appeal, the appellant sought leave to add a further ground of appeal. The proposed further ground was:"1.There was a miscarriage of justice in that the verdict of the jury in respect of the conviction was unsafe and unsatisfactory having regard to the new evidence that has emerged since the hearing of the trial, which evidence was not known, disclosed or available at the time of the trial or could [sic] reasonably have been discovered.Particulars of New EvidenceEvidence of John Marshall set out in his report dated 31 August 2006 annexed to the affidavit of Andree Marie Horrigan sworn 5 September 2006 in relation to the possible causes of the fire, the reliability of the 're‑enactment' performed by police on 17 February 2004 and the probability of a lit cigarette butt igniting bedding material." The appellant also applied for leave to adduce new evidence. The application, which is dated 5 September 2006, provides:"The applicant applies for ‑ •leave to adduce new evidence either by affidavit or orally in support of grounds 2 and 5 of the appeal pursuant to section 40 of Criminal Appeals Act 2004; the summary of evidence contained in the report of Mr John Marshall dated 31 August 2006 annexed to the affidavit of Andree Marie Horrigan filed herewith." The solicitor for the appellant swore an affidavit in support of the application for leave to adduce new evidence. The affidavit states, relevantly, that:"2.Mr Patrick Hogan was briefed as counsel for the appellant at the trial.3.I have spoken to Mr Hogan of counsel and confirm on the basis of my discussion with him that it was not for tactical reasons that an expert was not engaged to assess the State's evidence in relation to the cause of the fire prior to the trial." After hearing the parties' submissions in relation to these issues, leave to add the further ground of appeal, and leave to adduce new evidence, were refused, with reasons to be published later. My reasons are set out below. Mr Marshall has tertiary qualifications in engineering and business administration. He has professional experience in the forensic investigation of fires and explosions, metallurgical failures, motor vehicle accidents and thefts, and materials related matters. In his report dated 31 August 2006, relevantly:(a)After referring to Mr Watson's evidence in relation to a possible electrical fault, Mr Marshall said:"It would be the writer's view that in this instance there may well have been no physical evidence of an electrical ignition mechanism, however, the possibility that an electrical fault did cause the fire could not be ruled out due to the inability to fully examine the electrical installation given the severity of the fire."(b)After referring to the evidence of Detective Senior Constable Tilley, Mr Marshall said:" … there is no objective basis for determining from the physical evidence the location of the fire seat given the very severe and extensive damage in the compartment. It is noted typically, steel bed frames in compartment fires that develop to the free burning stage (as was the case in room twenty five) will bow or sag mid‑span. Such sagging is simply the unavoidable response of the softened steel members to the influence of gravity. That is to say, if the fire in a compartment is severe enough, any bed frame present will inevitably sag irrespective of where the fire started.It is the writer's view that the extent of the damage in room twenty five precludes any reliable determination of the origin of the fire. To assign the proximate fire seat to one end of the bed or the other is in the writer's view guesswork or at best, a somewhat arbitrary estimate.Detective Tilley went on to conclude his written report by stating (at 18.3) that he determined the fire to be deliberately lit due to his inability to 'locate any accidental causes'. Detective Tilley also concluded (at 18.2) that he could not 'determine the exact ignition mechanism'. Implicit in this conclusion is an absence of any evidence of a deliberate ignition mechanism although this is not stated by Detective Tilley.It is [the] writer[']s view that in terms of the forensic or physical evidence, the absence of evidence of any accidental causes is not a proper basis for concluding a fire has been deliberately lit. In the absence of physical evidence of the fire cause it would not be unreasonable in the writer's opinion to classify the fire as 'cause undetermined'."(c)As to the "demonstration burn", Mr Marshall said:" … the test arrangement depicted in the video fails to in any sense closely duplicate the actual conditions present at the time of the subject fire. ……The writer notes with concern Detective Tilley's evidence in relation to the reconstruction where at page 218 he states, 'as you have seen from the tests, it is quite impossible to create a fire with a cigarette butt'. The writer strongly rejects the proposition. It is widely acknowledged that smoking in bed is … very dangerous because of the possibility of falling asleep and the risk of the cigarette igniting the bedding. …"Mr Marshall then refers to various publications (including statistical data) in relation to fires caused by smoking materials igniting bedding or mattresses. He says that the conclusions drawn by Detective Tilley as to the possibility of a "cigarette butt ignition" were plainly incorrect.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established