IN THE COURT OF APPEAL 99.136 SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND Appeal No. 4488 of 1998
Brisbane
[Bird v McShea & Suncorp]
BETWEEN:
TRISTAN JAMES BIRD
(Plaintiff) Appellant
AND:
SARAH LOUISE McSHEA and
SUNCORP INSURANCE AND FINANCE
(Defendants) Respondents McMurdo P
Pincus JA
Fryberg J
Judgment delivered 20 April 1999
Joint reasons for judgment of McMurdo P and Pincus JA, separate reasons of Fryberg J concurring as to the orders made.
APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS.
CATCHWORDS:
TORTS - NEGLIGENCE - ROAD ACCIDENT CASE - intoxicated pedestrian steps in front of vehicle - duty owed by drivers to pedestrians - whether negligence established on part of driver - whether driver ought to have foreseen appellant’s action -whether irrational or foolish behaviour foreseeable in light of appellant’s known intoxication - whether negligent for driver to fail to take precautions against foolish behaviour.
Nosworthy v Berg (1991) 14 MVR 105
Kilminster v Rule (1983) 32 SASR 39
Johns v Cosgrove (1997) 27 MVR 110Counsel: Mr D Fraser QC with him Mr R Trotter for the appellant.
Mr B Hoare for the respondents.Solicitors: Watling Roche Lawyers for the appellant.
Bradley & Co for the respondents.Hearing Date: 8 April 1999 IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
Appeal No. 4488 of 1998
Brisbane
Before McMurdo P
Pincus JA
Fryberg J[Bird v McShea & Suncorp]
BETWEEN:
TRISTAN JAMES BIRD
(Plaintiff) Appellant
AND:
SARAH LOUISE McSHEA and
SUNCORP INSURANCE AND FINANCE
(Defendants) Respondents
JOINT REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - McMURDO P AND PINCUS JA
Judgment delivered 20 April 1999
This is an appeal from a District Court judgment dismissing the appellant's claim for damages
for personal injuries suffered in a motor vehicle accident.
The appellant, his sister, a friend Skye Houlihan, and Sarah McShea ("the respondent")
were drinking at the respondent's mother's home at Shea Street, Scarborough during the early
evening. At about 10 p.m., the respondent's mother came home and noticed that her daughter and
friends were affected by alcohol. She had no doubt that the respondent and friends were aware
that the friends were no longer welcome in her home. The appellant and friends left on foot. The respondent took her mother's car keys and drove her mother's car along Shea Street turning left into
Scarborough Road. She drove along Scarborough Road in a northerly direction. The appellant
and friends were walking north along the footpath on the left hand side of Scarborough Road which
intersected with Peterson Street on the right hand side, shortly after Shea Street intersected on the
left. The evidence of the respondent as to what then took place differed from that given by the
appellant and his witnesses.
The learned trial judge found that the appellant was drunk and the respondent was also
affected by alcohol with a blood alcohol reading of 115mg per 100ml of blood. His Honour noted:
"Neither the [appellant] nor the [respondent] nor the other two teenage…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bird v McShea and Suncorp Insurance and Finance and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] QCA 136
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether McShea owed Bird a duty of care, whether McShea's negligence in failing to take precautions against Bird's known intoxication was established, and whether the driver could have reasonably foreseen Bird's irrational or foolish behaviour in light of their known intoxication. The court had to consider whether it was negligent for McShea to fail to take precautions against Bird's foolish behaviour, given the circumstances.
The court found that McShea did owe Bird a duty of care, as pedestrians are owed a reasonable standard of care by drivers. However, the court also found that McShea's negligence in failing to take precautions against Bird's known intoxication was not established. The court held that it was not reasonable to expect McShea to foresee Bird's irrational or foolish behaviour, given the circumstances, and therefore, McShea could not be held liable for the accident. The court also noted that Bird's own intoxication contributed to the accident, and as such, Bird's damages were reduced accordingly.
The court dismissed Bird's claim for damages against McShea and Suncorp Insurance and Finance, finding that McShea's negligence was not established. Bird's damages were reduced in light of their own contributory negligence.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi