Bird v Hawkesbury City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Bird v Hawkesbury City Council [2000] NSWLEC 4
PARTIES:

APPLICANT:
Howard Bird

RESPONDENT:
Hawkesbury City Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 10989 of 1999
CORAM: Talbot J
KEY ISSUES: Construction & Interpretation :- whether a brothel is commercial premises as an office
LEGISLATION CITED:
CASES CITED: Londish v Knox Grammar School and Ors (1997) 97 LGERA 1;
Collector of Customs v Agfa-Gevaert Limited (1996) 186 CLR 389
DATES OF HEARING: 19/01/2000
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
01/24/2000
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT:
Mr D P Wilson (Barrister)
SOLICITORS:
Malcolm McDonald & Co

RESPONDENT:
Mr P D McClellan QC
With
Mr J E Robson (Barrister)
SOLICITORS:
Abbott Tout

JUDGMENT:

    IN THE LAND AND Matter No. 10989 of 1999
    ENVIRONMENT COURT Coram: Talbot J
    OF NEW SOUTH WALES Decision Date: 24 January 2000

    Howard Bird
    Applicant
    v
    Hawkesbury City Council

    Respondent

    REASONS FOR JUDGMENT


    1. The applicant is seeking development consent to use premises in zone (4a) Industrial General for the purpose of a brothel.

    2. The council has made an application for the Court to determine the following question as a preliminary issue:-
          Whether a brothel is prohibited development in zone (4a) Industrial General under Hawkesbury LEP 1989?

    3. Commercial premises are defined in the LEP as follows:-
          “commercial premises” means a building or place used as an office, but does not include a building or place elsewhere specifically defined in this clause or a building or place used for a purpose elsewhere specifically defined in this clause


    4. Commercial premises are prohibited development in the zone.

    5. The Registrar agreed to refer a question in a slightly different form to a Judge for determination as a preliminary issue, presumably on the basis that the answer has the potential to resolve the appeal. Although a question of law is not necessarily raised, I agree it is nevertheless expedient to abide the Registrar’s direction. No facts relevant to the question raised are in dispute.

    6. The focus of the council’s argument is on the meaning to be attributed to an office in the context of the definition of commercial premises.

    7. The council relies on the meaning of “professional and commercial chambers” defined in the LEP to support a broad construction of the dictionary definition for an office which, it says, encompasses a brothel. Prima facie the council’s proposition, at first, appeared to be untenable. Nevertheless, predictably Mr McClellan QC has skilfully managed to develop a plausible argument.

    The council’s argument

    8. Mr McClellan places particular emphasis on the primary meaning of “office” taken from the Macquarie Dictionary as follows:-
          a room or place for the transaction of business, the discharge of professional duties, or the like

    9. He referred to the draftsperson’s expressed intention to distinguish an office use from the specific purposes referred to in Schedule 2 incorporated in the LEP definition of professional and commercial chambers as follows:-

          “professional and commercial chambers” means a room or number of rooms or chambers being part of a dwelling-house…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bird v Hawkesbury City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWLEC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Land and Environment Court of New South Wales heard a case between Howard Bird and Hawkesbury City Council. Bird sought development consent for premises in an industrial zone to be used as a brothel. The council argued that such use constituted prohibited development, contending that a brothel qualified as a commercial premise under the Local Environment Plan (LEP). The court was tasked with determining whether a brothel could be classified as a commercial premise, specifically an office, under the LEP.

The central legal issue revolved around the interpretation of the term "office" within the definition of "commercial premises" as outlined in the LEP. The council argued that the term should be broadly interpreted to include any business transaction, which would encompass a brothel. Bird, on the other hand, maintained that the term should be understood in its ordinary sense, focusing on clerical or administrative work, and thus excluding a brothel.

The court examined various dictionary definitions and the context in which the term "office" was used within the LEP. It noted that while the council's argument for a broad interpretation was plausible, it was not supported by the ordinary English usage of the term. The court concluded that a brothel did not fit the common understanding of an office and, therefore, did not qualify as a commercial premise under the LEP. Consequently, a brothel was deemed an innominate use, not explicitly prohibited, and thus permissible with consent.

In summary, the court ruled that a brothel did not constitute a commercial premise as defined in the Hawkesbury LEP, allowing Bird's application for development consent to proceed.