Bird v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

BIRD v Commissioner of Police [2021] QDC 49

PARTIES:

ALLAN DAVID BIRD

Appellant

v

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

Respondent

FILE NO:

2293 /20

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against sentence s. 222(2)(c) Justices Act 1886

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Sandgate

DELIVERED ON:

26th March 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17th March 2021

JUDGE:

East QC  DCJ

ORDER:

1. Appeal against sentence allowed.

2. Set aside the sentences of 9 months imprisonment imposed with respect to the Public Nuisance offences committed on 6,7 and 20 April 2020 and the term of 6 months imprisonment imposed on the Public Nuisance offence committed on 3 April 2020.

3. Instead order that the appellant be sentenced as follows:-

(a)      3 April 2020 – three months’ imprisonment

(b)      6th April 2020 – four months’ imprisonment

(c)      7 April 2020- three months’ imprisonment

(d)      20 April 2020 – Convicted Not further punished

4. Set aside the orders of nine months’ imprisonment imposed with respect to the two charges of Stealing committed on 20 April 2020.

5. Instead order that the appellant be sentenced to one month’ imprisonment on each offence.

6. All substituted sentences of imprisonment be served concurrently with each other and concurrent with the sentences of 12 months’ imprisonment imposed on the charges of Wilful Damage.

7. Set aside the order that the activated one month suspended term of imprisonment be served cumulative to the other sentences of imprisonment imposed 20 July 2020.

8. Instead order that the activated one month suspended term of imprisonment be served concurrently with the sentences imposed on 20 July 2020.

9. All other sentences affirmed.

10. Declare 91 days pre-sentence custody from 20 April to 20 July 2020 inclusive to be imprisonment already served under all of the sentences imposed.

11. I direct the Registrar of the District Court Brisbane inform the Chief Executive Officer of the Corrective Services Commission of this declaration.

CATCHWORDS:

Public nuisance – sentences exceeded maximum penalty – breach suspended sentence – whether order ought to be cumulative or concurrent.

LEGISLATION:

Summary Offences Act 2005 (Qld) s 56 (1)(b)

Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) s 9, s 148, s 159A

CASES:

Kentwell v R (2014) 252 CLR 601

Perry v Commissioner of Police [2015] QDC 21

R v Baker [2011] QCA 104

Q v KAX [2020] QCA 218

R v Rose [2020] QCA 234

COUNSEL:

Appellant: Self represented

Respondent: Mr. N Dagan

SOLICITORS:

Appellant: Self represented

Respondent Director of Public Prosecutions

Introduction

  1. On 15 July 2020 in the Sandgate Magistrates Court the appellant pleaded guilty to 15 offences.

  2. On 20 July 2020 the appellant was sentenced to various terms of imprisonment resulting in a head sentence of 12 months. A suspended sentence of one month imprisonment was activated and ordered to be served cumulatively, making a total period of imprisonment of 13 months. A parole release date of 18 September 2020 was set (about 1/3).

    Appellant’s antecedents

  3. The appellant’s previous offending commenced in 1995 and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bird v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QDC 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant in Bird v Commissioner of Police challenged the sentences imposed by the District Court for various offences, including public nuisance and theft. The court had to determine whether the sentences were correctly imposed, particularly in light of the maximum penalties prescribed by law and the impact of COVID-19 restrictions on the appellant's time in custody. The appellant also argued that the sentences should be reduced because of the hardship he experienced in prison due to the pandemic.

The court examined the legal issues concerning the maximum penalties for the offences and whether the sentences imposed exceeded these limits. It also considered whether the sentences should have been reduced due to the appellant's time in custody under COVID-19 restrictions and whether the Magistrate had adequately considered the appellant's pleas of guilty. The court found that the sentences for the public nuisance offences exceeded the prescribed maximum penalties and needed to be reduced. The court also determined that the Magistrate's failure to explicitly mention the pleas of guilty did not invalidate the sentences.

The court ruled that the sentences imposed were excessive and required adjustment. The maximum penalty for the public nuisance offences was nine months, but the court found that the appellant should have been given credit for the 91 days he had already served in custody. The court noted that the Magistrate's order should have accounted for all sentences, not just the four offences on 20 April 2020. The court rejected the argument that the sentences should be reduced due to the hardship of COVID-19 restrictions, finding that the Magistrate had already taken the appellant's circumstances into account. The court found that the appellant's reoffending after his release further undermined his argument for a reduced sentence.

The court allowed the appeal against the sentence, set aside the sentences for the public nuisance and theft offences, and imposed new sentences. The court ordered that the appellant serve three months' imprisonment for the public nuisance offence on 3 April 2020, four months for the offence on 6 April 2020, three months for the offence on 7 April 2020, and no further punishment for the offence on 20 April 2020. For the theft offences on 20 April 2020, the court ordered one month's imprisonment for each offence. All sentences were to be served concurrently, and the court declared the 91 days of pre-sentence custody to be time already served under all sentences. The court also ordered that the one-month suspended term of imprisonment be served concurrently with the sentences imposed on 20 July 2020.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal against sentence allowed.

2. Set aside the sentences of 9 months imprisonment imposed with respect to the Public Nuisance offences committed on 6,7 and 20 April 2020 and the term of 6 months imprisonment imposed on the Public Nuisance offence committed on 3 April 2020.

3. Instead order that the appellant be sentenced as follows:-

(a) 3 April 2020 – three months’ imprisonment

(b) 6th April 2020 – four months’ imprisonment

(c) 7 April 2020- three months’ imprisonment

(d) 20 April 2020 – Convicted Not further punished

4. Set aside the orders of nine months’ imprisonment imposed with respect to the two charges of Stealing committed on 20 April 2020.

5. Instead order that the appellant be sentenced to one month’ imprisonment on each offence.

6. All substituted sentences of imprisonment be served concurrently with each other and concurrent with the sentences of 12 months’ imprisonment imposed on the charges of Wilful Damage.

7. Set aside the order that the activated one month suspended term of imprisonment be served cumulative to the other sentences of imprisonment imposed 20 July 2020.

8. Instead order that the activated one month suspended term of imprisonment be served concurrently with the sentences imposed on 20 July 2020.

9. All other sentences affirmed.

10. Declare 91 days pre-sentence custody from 20 April to 20 July 2020 inclusive to be imprisonment already served under all of the sentences imposed.

11. I direct the Registrar of the District Court Brisbane inform the Chief Executive Officer of the Corrective Services Commission of this declaration.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 159A (4)(b) retains the words “and for no other reason”. However, it is abundantly clear that the appellant was not in custody for reasons unconnected to all of the offences, for example, because he was serving a sentence on an unrelated matter. A reading of section 159A makes clear that the appellant should have been given a declaration of 91 days with respect to all of the sentences of imprisonment not just the four offences occurring on 20 April 2020. The Magistrate’s order requires amendment in that respect.COVID-19 considerations The appellant contended that the sentences should have been ameliorated because of the hardship endured in custody as a consequence of the pandemic restrictions imposed on prisoners. There have been a number of single judge decisions recognising that factor although precisely how the deduction or allowance is made seems to be a matter of instinctive synthesis rather than mathematical calculation. This difficulty was identified in R v KAX [2020] QCA 218 at [31] Mullins JA. In R v Rose [2020] QCA 234, Sofronoff P at [8] considered the COVID-19 circumstance did not render a sentence severe because no reduction was made. In any event, the sentencing Magistrate indicated that she had “taken into account … all of those matters that have been placed before me by … Ms Bruxner on your behalf”. His lawyer had referred to his hardship in prison in submissions. It is also somewhat ironic that the appellant had been thrice convicted of disobeying COVID-19 restrictions before he went into prison, yet he contends that the hardship caused by the restrictions in prison justifies a further reduction of sentence. There is nothing in this ground.The pleas of guilty The learned Magistrate made no specific reference that would comply with the requirements of Section 13 (3) of the Penalties and Sentences Act. However it is clear Her Honour must have taken it into account in setting the parole release date. The failure to mention the plea of guilty has been considered in this appeal, however the head sentence is not invalid by reason of that failure.Events subsequent to this sentence The appellant was released from custody on 18 September 2020 in accordance with the parole release date set. Within a short time of his release he committed an offence of stealing (Chapter 70) and was returned to custody on 28th September 2020. His parole was suspended indefinitely. On the subsequent stealing offence he was sentenced to 3 months imprisonment to be served cumulatively on the sentence the subject of this appeal. That sentence is also subject to a separate appeal. In those circumstances there is no utility in making a further parole release date, so that the provisions of the Corrective Services Act concerning parole will take effect. I make the following orders:-