BIRCH v POLICE
[2003] SASC 354Magistrates Appeal (Criminal)
BLEBY J: The appellant was originally charged with six offences as follows:
1. Damaging property;
2. Behaving in a disorderly manner in a public place;
3. Using offensive language in a public place;
4. Resisting a member of the police force in the execution of his duty;
5. Assaulting a member of the police force in the execution of his duty; and
6. Giving a false name and address to a member of the police force.
At pre-trial conferences he had indicated an intention to plead guilty to counts 2 to 6 inclusive but not guilty to count 1. On the day of his trial, 22 August 2003, count 1 was withdrawn and the plea of guilty was duly entered to the other counts. On those counts he was sentenced to five months imprisonment, the sentence being suspended upon the appellant entering into a bond in the sum of $50 to be of good behaviour for a period of two years. He now appeals against that sentence.
The charges to which the appellant pleaded guilty arose out of a course of conduct which occurred at about 1.10 am on Saturday, 8 March 2003. Police attended at a disturbance at Teusner Drive, Morphett Vale. The appellant was in a group of people. He was grossly intoxicated and was behaving in a loud and abusive manner waving his arms about and stumbling. That was the essence of count 2.
The appellant was heard to say, “What the fuck do you want that for?”, “I don’t have to tell you shit”, and “Fuck off cunt.” That was the basis of the charge of offensive language, count 3.
The appellant was then arrested by the police and was restrained by them. He began to resist the efforts of the police to restrain him, trying to free his arms and jumping up and down in an effort to free himself. That was the basis of count 4, resisting the police.
During the ensuing struggle the appellant spat saliva out of his mouth. Some of that came into contact with the police with whom he was struggling. That formed the basis of count 5, assaulting a member of the police force. Nevertheless, it was accepted by the prosecution that there was no deliberate attempt to spit at police. It was accepted that the appellant was recklessly indifferent as to whether saliva would come into contact with the police during the struggle.
The appellant was eventually conveyed to the Christies Beach Police Station having previously given a false name and address to the police. He gave his correct name and address at the police station. The giving of the false name and address forms the basis of count 6.
On the appellant’s behalf it was put that he had attended a social gathering at a friend’s house on Teusner Drive. He had consumed a substantial quantity of alcohol. He was suffering from depression for which he was prescribed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Birch v Police No. Scciv-03-1264 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] SASC 354
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Bleby J concluded that personal deterrence was a significant factor in this case, and that the appellant needed a strong incentive and constant reminder that his anti-social behavior was unacceptable and would not be tolerated in the future. The judge found that a fine would not be an adequate reminder, and that the appellant needed a strong incentive over a period of time not to reoffend. Bleby J allowed the appeal, setting aside the original sentence and imposing a new bond of good behavior for one year, ten months, and fifteen days, with a condition that the appellant appear for sentence if he fails to comply with the bond. The bond was set at $500, with the condition that if the appellant breaches the bond, he will be liable for sentence for these offences and will forfeit a significant sum.
The court's decision highlights the importance of considering both general and personal deterrence in sentencing, as well as the need to take into account the individual circumstances of the offender when imposing a sentence. The judge's decision to impose a bond of good behavior, rather than a fine, demonstrates the court's belief that the appellant needed a strong incentive and constant reminder that his behavior was unacceptable and would not be tolerated in the future. This case serves as a reminder to practitioners that when considering sentencing options, it is important to take into account both the gravity of the offence and the individual circumstances of the offender, and to impose a sentence that is appropriate in all the circumstances.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant had consumed a substantial amount of alcohol and was taking prescribed medication for depression, which exacerbated his level of intoxication. His defence was that his behaviour was a direct result of his intoxication and that he did not deliberately spit at the police or cause them harm. The Magistrate accepted that the appellant's intoxication was due to a combination of alcohol and medication and that he did not deliberately spit at the police. The Magistrate imposed a suspended sentence of five months imprisonment, conditional upon the appellant entering a bond of good behaviour for two years. The appellant appealed against the sentence, arguing that it was excessive and that the Magistrate failed to consider relevant sentencing criteria.
The appellant was 19 years old at the time of the incident and had a good employment record, having been employed as a metal spinner for four years. He lived with his parents and younger sister and had limited prior criminal history, with only one previous adult court appearance and a conviction for resisting police as a youth. The Magistrate considered the appellant's previous offending history and his behaviour on this occasion when imposing the sentence, but the appellant argued that the sentence was too severe, given his age and personal circumstances. He also argued that the Magistrate failed to consider relevant sentencing criteria under the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988.
The appellant in Birch v Police was initially charged with six offences, but count 1 was withdrawn on the day of his trial. He pleaded guilty to counts 2 to 6 and was sentenced to five months imprisonment, suspended on the condition that he enter a bond of $50 for good behaviour over two years. The appellant appealed against the sentence. The matter came before the Supreme Court of South Australia as an appeal from the Magistrates Court. The appeal focused on whether the sentence was manifestly excessive, particularly in light of the appellant's age, employment status, and the mitigating factor of his level of intoxication. The appellant argued that the Magistrate did not adequately consider section 11 of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988, which outlines circumstances under which imprisonment may be imposed. The Court noted that while the criteria of section 11 were met, a suspended sentence of five months imprisonment was excessive given the appellant's personal circumstances and the nature of the offences. The appeal was allowed, and the sentence was set aside, with a new bond of $500 imposed for a period of one year, 10 months, and 15 days, with the condition that the appellant be of good behaviour.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Magistrate properly considered section 11 of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 in imposing the sentence.
2. Whether the sentence of five months imprisonment, suspended upon the entry of a bond, was excessive given the appellant's age and personal circumstances.
3. Whether a sentence of imprisonment was appropriate in all the circumstances, considering the appellant's previous offences, his age, employment status, and family support.
4. Whether personal deterrence was a significant factor in sentencing and if so, how it should be achieved.
5. Whether a fine would be an adequate reminder for the appellant to refrain from re-offending.
6. Whether a bond to be of good behaviour for a specified period is an appropriate sentence to achieve personal deterrence and what the appropriate conditions and duration of the bond should be.
Held
1. The court concluded that it was not necessary to determine whether the Magistrate properly considered section 11 of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988, as the criteria in the section did not preclude a sentence of imprisonment.
2. The court found that a sentence of five months imprisonment, suspended upon the entry of a bond, was manifestly excessive given the appellant's age and personal circumstances. The appeal was allowed on this basis.
3. The court concluded that a sentence of imprisonment was not appropriate in all the circumstances, considering the appellant's age, employment status, family support, and the nature of the offences.
4. The court held that personal deterrence was a significant factor in sentencing and that the appellant needed a strong incentive and a constant reminder that such behaviour was unacceptable.
5. The court determined that a fine would not be an adequate reminder for the appellant to refrain from re-offending.
6. The court concluded that a bond to be of good behaviour was an appropriate sentence to achieve personal deterrence. The court set a bond of $500 for a period of one year, 10 months, and 15 days, with the condition that the appellant must appear before the Magistrates Court for sentence if he fails to comply with the bond.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began its analysis by examining whether the Magistrate properly considered section 11 of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988. This statute stipulates that imprisonment may only be imposed if the defendant has shown a tendency to violence, is likely to commit a serious offence if at large, has been previously convicted of an offence punishable by imprisonment, or if any other sentence would be inappropriate given the circumstances and gravity of the offence. The court found that there was no explicit indication in the record that the Magistrate had considered this section, although it was possible that the Magistrate had done so implicitly. Nevertheless, the court concluded that even if the criteria of section 11 were met, it did not necessarily mean that a sentence of imprisonment was appropriate in all circumstances, especially considering the appellant’s age and personal circumstances.
The court then considered whether the sentence of five months imprisonment, suspended upon the entry of a bond, was excessive given the appellant’s age and personal circumstances. The appellant was 19 years old at the time of the offence, employed full-time, and living with his supportive family. The court highlighted that the appellant’s behaviour appeared to have been exacerbated by a combination of prescription medication and alcohol, leading to a high level of intoxication. While the appellant’s behaviour was reckless and foolish, the court acknowledged that the assault on the police was not intentional. The court found that the sentence imposed, even though suspended, was manifestly excessive and not justified by way of personal deterrence.
Next, the court assessed whether a sentence of imprisonment was appropriate in all circumstances, taking into account the appellant’s previous offences, age, employment status, and family support. The court noted that personal deterrence was a much more significant factor than general deterrence in this case. The appellant’s previous offending and his behaviour on this occasion should make him realise the trouble he can get into by drinking excessive amounts of alcohol, especially while on medication. The court concluded that the appellant needed a strong incentive and constant reminder that such behaviour is unacceptable and will not be tolerated.
The court also considered whether personal deterrence was a significant factor in sentencing and, if so, how it should be achieved. The court rejected the idea that a once-off fine would be an adequate reminder for the appellant to refrain from re-offending. Instead, it was deemed necessary to place the appellant on a bond to be of good behaviour for a period of time, with the understanding that any re-offending would result in a potential period of imprisonment. The court believed that such a bond would serve as a strong reminder that anti-social behaviour of that nature would not be tolerated in the future.
Furthermore, the court examined whether a bond to be of good behaviour for a specified period was an appropriate sentence to achieve personal deterrence and what the appropriate conditions and duration of the bond should be. The court found that such a bond was appropriate, but it needed to be carefully structured to serve as a strong deterrent. The court modified the bond to run for one year, ten months, and fifteen days, with the condition that the appellant must be of good behaviour and appear before the Magistrates Court for sentence if he breaches the bond. The bond was set at $500, a significant sum intended to serve as a deterrent against future offending.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that while the criteria of section 11 of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 may justify a sentence of imprisonment, other factors such as the appellant’s age, personal circumstances, and the need for personal deterrence must also be considered. The court found that a suspended sentence of five months imprisonment was excessive and that a bond to be of good behaviour for a period of time, with appropriate conditions and sum, was a more suitable sentence to achieve personal deterrence.