Billgate Pty Ltd v Woollahra Municipal Council

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Billgate Pty Ltd v Woollahra Municipal Council [2007] NSWLEC 399
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
Billgate Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT
Woollahra Municipal Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 10898 of 2006
CORAM: Tuor C
KEY ISSUES: Development Application :- Residential Flat Building
SEPP 1 Objection - Site frontage
Consistency with the desired future character
Impact on adjoining heritage item and conservation area
LEGISLATION CITED: Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
Land and Environment Court Act 1979
State Environmental Planning Policy No 1 - Development Standards
Woollahra Local Environmental Plan 1995
CASES CITED: Billgate Pty Limited v Woollahra Municipal Council and Anor [2005] NSWLEC 61;
Segal & Anor v Waverley Council [2005] NSWCA 310;
Billgate Pty Ltd v Woollahra Municipal Council (2004) NSWLEC 436;
Project Venture Developments v Pittwater Council [2005] NSWLEC 191 ;
Seaside Property Developments Pty Ltd v Wyong Shire Council [2004] NSWLEC 117
DATES OF HEARING: 20, 21 & 22 February 2007
 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 

3 July 2007
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES: APPLICANT
Mr T Hale SC
SOLICITORS
Colin Biggers & Paisley


RESPONDENT
Mr P Rigg
SOLICITORS
Deacons



JUDGMENT:

      THE LAND AND
      ENVIRONMENT COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES

      Tuor C

      3 July 2007

      10898 of 2006 Billgate Pty Ltd v Woollahra Municipal Council

      JUDGMENT

1 COMMISSIONER: This is an appeal against the deemed refusal by Woollahra Municipal Council (the council) of a development application (DA352/2006) under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (the Act) to demolish an existing house and construct a new residential flat building comprising three attached dwellings at 20 Roslyndale Avenue, Woollahra (the site).

2 For the reasons set out in this judgment I have concluded that the appeal should be dismissed and development consent refused.

The site and its context

3 The site is a hatchet shaped allotment on the eastern side of Roslyndale Avenue, to the south of Edgecliff Road. The frontage of the access handle to Roslyndale is a splayed width of 8.01m, the width of the access handle itself is about 7.6m with a maximum length of about 32.3m along its northern side. The main part of the site has a width of about 27m and a maximum depth of about 54m. The site area including the access handle is 1,582.2sqm (1348.8sqm without the access handle). The site has a fall from the street to the rear eastern boundary of 19.55m, measured along the southern boundary. The site is developed with a two storey house with an elevated swimming pool and deck. There are a number of large canopy trees on the site.

4 Adjoining the site to the north is Struan Lodge (14 Roslyndale Avenue), a detached dwelling with extensive gardens which adjoins another dwelling, Hawthornden (6 Roslyndale Avenue). Both these houses are identified as heritage items in Woollahra Local Environmental Plan 1995 (LEP 1995). A duplex (16-18 Roslyndale Avenue) is located to the north of the access handle and shares its eastern boundary with the main portion of the site. To the south, the site…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Billgate Pty Ltd v Woollahra Municipal Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWLEC 399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Billgate Pty Ltd v Woollahra Municipal Council, the Land and Environment Court dismissed an appeal against the deemed refusal by Woollahra Municipal Council of a development application to demolish an existing house and construct a new residential flat building comprising three attached dwellings at 20 Roslyndale Avenue, Woollahra. The applicant argued that the site frontage standard in clause 10B of the Woollahra Local Environmental Plan 1995 should not apply to the site as it was a battle axe site with a narrow access handle. The applicant submitted that the intent of Clauses 10A and 10B was directed to long narrow sites which have sufficient area but do not meet the objectives of Clause 10A due to their narrowness. The court rejected this submission and held that site frontage is to be measured at the street alignment and the proposal is prohibited unless the SEPP 1 objection is upheld. The court found that the proposal does not comply with the site frontage standard and the objectives of the standard include compatibility between the scale, density, bulk and landscape character of buildings and allotment size. The proposal concentrates development at the rear of the site which is a direct result of it being a battle axe site with insufficient width at the front to accommodate any part of the development other than the driveway. Consequently, the relationship of building to building and building to open space which is characteristic of the area is not replicated by this development. The proposal complies with the minimum rear setback control, however, a site with a street frontage that complied with the control in cl 10B(1) would require a rear setback in the order of 20m. This would reduce the impact of the proposal on the properties in Wallaroy Road and 22 Roslyndale Avenue. The court found that the SEPP 1 objection is not well founded and the granting of consent to the development application would not be consistent with the aims of SEPP 1. The application must therefore fail. The court also found that the proposal is not consistent with the desired future character for the Wallaroy Precinct envisaged in DCP 2003. The proposal does not provide a transition between the larger buildings on the ridge and those on the slopes. The proposal is for three attached dwellings, which while broken up by courtyards, changes in level, and materials will be clearly visible from parts of Wallaroy Road and the surrounding area. The proposal will read as a large building in comparison to other buildings in the area. The landscaping will assist in screening and softening the development, however, opportunities for substantial landscaping and canopy trees are generally around the perimeter of the site. The landscaping between the buildings and on the terraces will do little to screen the building or to reduce the appreciation of its mass. The difference of opinion of the heritage experts is summarised in their joint report as follows: Mr Oultram considers that the proposal introduces a greater bulk and scale than the current house closer to the rear terrace of Struan Lodge that will have an adverse impact on the heritage significance of the item and increase the sense of enclosure affecting the planned amenity of the terrace and Struan Lodge. He also considers that the introduction of stepped, two to three storey buildings in the garden of the subject site will have an adverse impact on the setting of Struan Lodge and will introduce an uncharacteristic element into the landscape slope from Roslyndale Avenue to Wallaroy Road and is an overdevelopment of the site. This will also result in an adverse impact on the setting of the Rosemont Precinct of the Woollahra Heritage Conservation Area. Mr Staas considers that the bulk of the proposal at its closest point to Struan Lodge is similar to the existing house and is compatible with the allowable development potential of the site given the setbacks achieved from the boundary and the landscape treatment of the edge of the site. In his opinion development of the site as proposed will have a minimal impact on the setting of Struan Lodge and will not effect its identified heritage significance as a local heritage item. Mr Staas is of the opinion that the development proposed is what would reasonably be envisaged by the planning controls for this site and does not have a significant adverse impact on the wider setting of the heritage item and will have no impact on the heritage significance of the Rosemont Precinct of the Woollahra Local Environmental Plan……. Mr Tanner is of the opinion that the proposed buildings do not appear to have been designed with the protection of Struan Lodge’s heritage significance and setting as the primary objective. Analysis of the proposed development readily reveals a change of the Struan Lodge setting from a secluded setting to one in which the new development is highly intrusive. This would compromise any future appreciation of Struan Lodge. In his opinion any residential development at 20 Roslyndale Avenue must be withdrawn (by at least five or six metres) from the northern boundary, clearly reveal the “Edgecliff” and retain the landscape qualities of this site including deep planting in a wide belt of at least 3 metres along each boundary. The court found that the key disagreement between the heritage experts is the extent of impact on the setting of the item. The proposal and Struan Lodge will be able to be viewed together only from a limited vantage point in Wallaroy Road and from distant views. The impact of the proposal of the setting of Struan Lodge from these view points and the public domain is acceptable. The impact on the setting of Struan Lodge when viewed from within the property itself is also a relevant consideration. The full extent of the development along the common boundary will not be visible from any one location in the gardens of Struan Lodge. The proposal is setback from the boundary at the lower garden levels of Struan Lodge. These have been altered over time and are not part of the significance of the item. The impact on the setting of Struan Lodge from these lower levels is acceptable. The main impact of the proposal results from Dwelling 1 when viewed from the terrace and upper garden level of Struan Lodge. This impact will be greater than that of the existing house as the extent of the two storey component that is visible from Struan Lodge is increased. This will adversely affect the setting and amenity of Struan Lodge. The setback of Dwelling 1 at ground level ranges from about 1.9m to 3.3m from the common boundary. However, part of this setback area is a pathway that is raised above ground level, which limits landscaping to narrow triangular areas. The view of Dwelling 1 will therefore be softened but not screened by landscaping. While the impact of the proposal on the setting of Struan Lodge would individually not warrant refusal of the application, it is a negative aspect of the proposal that combined with the other impacts renders the proposal unacceptable. A proposal that increased the setbacks adjacent to the terrace and upper garden level would better respect the setting and significance of Struan Lodge. The impact of the proposal on the Rosemont Precinct of the Woollahra Conservation Area is acceptable would also not warrant refusal of the application. The court dismissed the appeal and refused the development application.