Bich-Chuong Doan and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

[2014] AATA 66

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Numbers

2013/1102, 2013/1104 and 2013/1373

Re

Bich-Chuong Doan

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

G. D. Friedman, Senior Member

Date 12 February 2014
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decisions under review in Applications 2013/1102, 2013/1104 and 2013/1373 and substitutes the following decision:

1.          (a)       From 4 January 2013 to the present date and at the present date Ms Doan continued to suffer incapacity at her normal level as a result of injury to the chronic lateral and medial epicondylitis of the right and left elbow/arm and right shoulder tendonitis which give rise to entitlement to compensation pursuant to the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act).

(b) From 4 January 2013 to the present date and at the present date Ms Doan is entitled to compensation pursuant to s 16 of the SRC Act.

(c) Ms Doan is particularly entitled to compensation pursuant to s 16 of the SRC Act for the costs of autologous blood injections for the treatment of epicondylitis proposed by Dr Andrianakis in his letter of 31 August 2012.

(d) From 4 January 2013 to the present date and at the present date Ms Doan is entitled to compensation in respect of incapacity for work pursuant to s 19 of the SRC Act in respect of all periods when her actual earning were less than the normal weekly earnings.

2.          The respondent shall pay Ms Doan’s reasonable legal costs and disbursements of the proceedings to be agreed, or taxed in default of agreement, in accordance with the latest Practice Direction of the Tribunal.

........................[sgd]................................................

G. D. Friedman, Senior Member

COMPENSATION – right shoulder and right and left elbow injuries – previously accepted conditions – whether liability has ceased – autologous blood injections – whether liability for medical treatment 

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 s 16, 19

REASONS FOR DECISION

G. D. Friedman, Senior Member

12 February 2014

  1. Bich-Chuong Doan has worked for the respondent since 2003 as a postal delivery officer and in 2009 she suffered an injury to her left and right arms while sorting mail.  The respondent accepted liability for mild medial epicondylitis at both elbows.  In 2011 the respondent accepted liability to pay compensation for diffuse soft tissue injury of the right and left elbow/arm instead of the earlier condition.  On 30 January 2013 the respondent made a reviewable decision that there was no liability at 4 January 2013 or to date for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment for the elbow condition (Application 2013/1102).

  2. In 2010 Ms Doan suffered an injury to her right shoulder.  In 2011 the respondent accepted liability for right shoulder bursitis.   On 18 March 2013 the respondent made a reviewable decision that there was no liability at 4 January 2013 to the present date for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment for right shoulder injury that was sustained on 28 April 2010 (Application 2013/1373).

  3. On 31 August 2012…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bich-Chuong Doan and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bich-Chuong Doan, a postal delivery officer for the Australian Postal Corporation, lodged an application for review of several decisions made by the respondent in relation to her entitlement to compensation for injuries she suffered in 2009 and 2010. The respondent had accepted liability for her injuries but later ceased to pay compensation on the basis that she no longer suffered incapacity. The primary issues for the Tribunal were whether Ms Doan continued to suffer incapacity and whether the respondent had liability for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment. The Tribunal found that Ms Doan continued to suffer from injuries to her elbows and right shoulder, and that the respondent had liability for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment.

The Tribunal found that the evidence of several medical experts supported Ms Doan's claims of continuing incapacity. In particular, the evidence of Dr Sutcliffe and Mr Reid, supported by Mr Melamed, Dr Andrianakis and Mr Grossbard, was preferred over that of Mr Haig and Dr Fraser. Dr Sutcliffe and Mr Reid both diagnosed medial and lateral epicondylitis in both of Ms Doan's elbows, while Mr Haig and Dr Fraser did not support this diagnosis. The Tribunal found that Ms Doan also continued to suffer from right shoulder tendonitis. The Tribunal further found that the respondent had liability for the costs of autologous blood injections as a reasonable treatment option for Ms Doan's epicondylitis. The Tribunal set aside the respondent's decisions and substituted its own decision that Ms Doan was entitled to compensation for incapacity and medical treatment from 4 January 2013 to the present date. The respondent was ordered to pay Ms Doan's reasonable legal costs and disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bich-Chuong Doan, a postal delivery officer for the Australian Postal Corporation, suffered injuries to her left and right arms in 2009 while sorting mail. The respondent accepted liability for mild medial epicondylitis at both elbows. In 2011, the respondent accepted liability for diffuse soft tissue injury of the right and left elbow/arm instead of the earlier condition. On 30 January 2013, the respondent decided there was no liability at 4 January 2013 or to date for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment for the elbow condition. In 2010, Ms Doan suffered an injury to her right shoulder, and in 2011 the respondent accepted liability for right shoulder bursitis. On 18 March 2013, the respondent decided there was no liability at 4 January 2013 to the present date for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment for the right shoulder injury. On 31 August 2012, Ms Doan’s general practitioner recommended to the respondent that Ms Doan receive autologous blood injections for her elbow injuries. On 15 January 2013, the respondent decided there was no liability for medical costs associated with the provision of this treatment.

Ms Doan sought review of the respondent's decisions, and the matter was heard by G. D. Friedman, Senior Member, in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal from 3 to 5 February 2014. The Tribunal set aside the respondent's decisions and substituted its own decision in favour of Ms Doan.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Ms Doan presently suffer from the effects of the injury to her elbows?
2. Does the respondent have present liability for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment for right shoulder injury?
3. Does the respondent have liability for medical costs associated with the provision of autologous blood injections?

Held
1. Does Ms Doan presently suffer from the effects of the injury to her elbows?
The Tribunal found that Ms Doan continued to suffer from medial and lateral epicondylitis in both elbows as at 4 January 2013 and to the present date.
2. Does the respondent have present liability for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment for right shoulder injury?
The Tribunal found that Ms Doan suffered from right shoulder tendonitis as at 4 January 2013 and to the present date.
3. Does the respondent have liability for medical costs associated with the provision of autologous blood injections?
The Tribunal found that autologous blood injections represent a reasonable medical treatment that meets the criteria in s 16 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 for the payment of compensation in respect of medical expenses.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined the evidence from various medical experts to determine whether Ms Doan continued to suffer from the effects of her injuries to her elbows and right shoulder, and whether the respondent had liability for compensation for incapacity and medical treatment. For the elbow injuries, the Tribunal placed significant weight on the evidence of Dr Sutcliffe, Mr Reid and Mr Grossbard who diagnosed ongoing medial and lateral epicondylitis in both elbows. The Tribunal placed less weight on the evidence of Mr Haig and Dr Fraser who did not find evidence of ongoing injury. For the right shoulder injury, the Tribunal preferred the evidence of Dr Sutcliffe, Mr Reid and Mr Grossbard who diagnosed right shoulder tendonitis. The Tribunal placed less weight on the evidence of Mr Haig and Dr Fraser who did not find evidence of ongoing injury. The Tribunal found that autologous blood injections represented a reasonable form of medical treatment for Ms Doan's epicondylitis, based on the evidence of Dr Sutcliffe, Mr Reid and Dr Andrianakis. The Tribunal rejected the evidence of Mr Haig who considered the treatment experimental. The binding legal principle established is that compensation may be payable for ongoing injury and reasonable medical treatment where the evidence supports a finding of continuing incapacity or need for treatment.