Bianco Hiring Services v Rams Development Pty Ltd, Monz & Rawcliffe No. DCCIV-00-344

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Bianco Hiring Service Pty Ltd (plaintiff)
v  Rams Development Pty Ltd (first defendant)
Stephen Heinrich Monz (second defendant)
and Angela Rose Rawcliffe (third defendant)
[2002] SADC 75

Civil
Judge David Smith

Introduction

  1. Bianco Hiring Service Pty Ltd (“Bianco”) is a corporation which, at all material times, carried on business as a wholesale supplier of building materials and services.  Rams Development Pty Ltd (“Rams”) was a building company, which was incorporated in early 1997 and after a relatively short life in the building industry was placed in liquidation in about July or August 2000.  Stephen Heinrich Monz (“Monz”) and Angela Rose Rawcliffe (“Rawcliffe”) were the promoters, shareholders and directors of Rams.  Monz is now bankrupt.  There is no leave for the plaintiff, Bianco, to proceed against either Rams or Monz and so this action proceeded against only the third defendant, Rawcliffe.

  2. Bianco in this action claims from Rawcliffe the sum of $56,093.90, being the cost of goods supplied by Bianco to Rams in the period from about November 1999 to January 2000.  That sum has not been paid by Rams.  It is alleged to be due and owing by Rawcliffe pursuant to a Deed of Guarantee dated in March 1997.

  3. Further, Bianco claims from Rawcliffe collection expenses amounting to $5,895.00 alleged to have been incurred by it in pursuing the debt together with ongoing interest of 1% per month on the debt.  These two items arise from the specific trading agreement entered into between Rams and Bianco.

  4. The defendant, Rawcliffe, contends in her defence that as the common seal of Rams was affixed to the Deed of Guarantee adjacent to the place of the signatures of herself and Monz, they merely witnessed the affixing of the company seal and were not thereby personally guaranteeing the debts of Rams.  She contends further that it follows that she was not personally liable to pay either the collection fees or the interest.

  5. By way of alternative, Rawcliffe contends that the collection fees were excessive.

  6. It is admitted that both Monz and Rawcliffe signed the Deed of Guarantee on the 27th March 1997, (see paragraph 2 of the Defence), and further, the primary portion of the claim is agreed.  In particular, it is agreed that $56,093.90 was indeed owing to Bianco for goods supplied to Rams in the period from about November 1999 to January 2000 and remains unpaid notwithstanding demands.

    The legal principles

  7. The issue for determination is the capacity in which Monz and Rawcliffe signed the Deed of Guarantee.  So it is necessary for me to define my task and decide, inter alia, what evidence is relevant and admissible.

  8. The exercise is to determine whether, in signing the Deed of Guarantee, Monz and Rawcliffe intended to make themselves personally liable for the debts of Rams or intended only to witness the affixing of the seal.  Determining this issue of signing capacity is a matter of construction of the Deed; (see Summergreene v Parker (1950) 80 CLR 304 per Fullagar J at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bianco Hiring Services v Rams Development Pty Ltd, Monz & Ra... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SADC 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bianco Hiring Services Pty Ltd v Rams Development Pty Ltd, Monz & Rawcliffe was heard in the South Australian District Court. The plaintiff, Bianco, sought to recover $56,093.90 in unpaid goods supplied to Rams, a building company that had since gone into liquidation. The defendants, Rawcliffe and Monz, the former shareholders and directors of Rams, signed a Deed of Guarantee in March 1997, which Bianco argued made them personally liable for the debts of Rams. Rawcliffe denied personal liability, arguing that she merely witnessed the affixing of the company seal and did not intend to guarantee Rams' debts. The court had to determine whether Monz and Rawcliffe intended to make themselves personally liable for Rams' debts or if they merely witnessed the affixing of the company seal.

The court concluded that the Deed of Guarantee was intended as a personal guarantee, based on the objective assessment of the contract documents and the circumstances surrounding their execution. The court held that the inclusion of the company seal and the witnessing of signatures did not negate the personal liability of Monz and Rawcliffe. The court also rejected Rawcliffe's argument that the collection fees and interest claimed by Bianco were excessive. The court found that the collection fees were not properly owed under the terms of trade agreed upon by Bianco and Rams.

The court found in favour of the plaintiff, Bianco, and ordered Rawcliffe to pay $56,093.90 plus interest at the rate of 1% per month from January 2000, totalling $15,683.85. The court further ordered Rawcliffe to pay prejudgment interest on the liquidated sum, bringing the total amount owed to $71,676.75. The court reserved the matter of costs for later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established