CITATION: BHP STEEL (AIS) PTY LTD v. NECATI DUM [2004] NSWCA 117 HEARING DATE(S): 06/04/ 2004 JUDGMENT DATE:
6 April 2004JUDGMENT OF: Beazley JA at 18; McColl JA at 19; Bryson JA at 2 DECISION: Application for leave to appeal dismissed with costs. CATCHWORDS: WORKERS COMPENSATION - LIMITATION OF ACTIONS - plaintiff sued 20 months out of time for damages for industrial injury and applied for extension of time- Workers Compensation Act 1987 s.151D(2)- plaintiff was advised by counsel 7 months after injury not to sue - his condition later worsened - after change of solictors and of advice- he brought proceedings- no possible dispute of liability- District Court (Goldring DCJ) considered Itek Graphix Pty Ltd v Elliot and granted extension - defendant claimed leave to appeal- leave to appeal refused as suggested errors not well based on facts before Goldring DCJ- no question of principle. ND LEGISLATION CITED: Workers Compensation Act 1987 CASES CITED: Itek Graphix Pty Ltd v Elliott (2001) 54 NSWLR 2007;
Coal and Allied Operations Pty Limited v Stringer (2003) NSWCA 271;PARTIES :
BHP STEEL (AIS) PTY LIMITED - Claimant
NECATI DUM - OpponentFILE NUMBER(S): CA 40431/03 COUNSEL: J. Maconachie QC and N.Polin for the Claimant
D. Toomey for the OpponentSOLICITORS: Sparke Helmore for the Claimant
Russell McLelland Brown Solictors for the Opponent
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DCT No 831/01 (Wollongong) LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :Goldring DCJ
040431/03
TUESDAY 6 APRIL 2004BEAZLEY JA
MCCOLL JA
BRYSON JA
1 BEAZLEY JA: I will ask Bryson JA to give the first judgment.
2 BRYSON JA: In these proceedings the respondent, the plaintiff in the District Court, sued for damages for personal injury sustained in an industrial accident at the defendant’s works at Port Kembla on 26 March 1997. He was working in the packaging products operation building and was injured when his right index finger was caught by a hydraulic clamp forming part of a strip welding machine. The circumstances of his injury are such that there could not on any reasonable basis be any doubt that he would, if he had sued in a timely way, have established the defendant’s liability to pay whatever are appropriate damages.
3 The plaintiff did not sue within the time prescribed by s 151D of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and brought proceedings in the District Court on 26 November 2001. Later, as a step in those proceedings, he applied by notice of motion for leave to proceed under s.151D(2). The application came before Goldring DCJ on several occasions, in particular on Tuesday 10 December 2002 when his Honour was unable to complete the hearing but stated in his reasons of that date the position achieved thus far. The proceedings came before his Honour again on 9 May 2003 when further evidence was taken and the application was granted, and further reasons were stated orally that day. Both statements of reasons must…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd v Necati Dum and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWCA 117
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the District Court judge erred in granting the extension of time under section 151D(2) of the *Workers Compensation Act 1987* (NSW). The defendant argued that the District Court judge had made errors in considering the relevant factors for granting such an extension, particularly in light of the plaintiff's initial advice from counsel not to sue.
The Court of Appeal refused leave to appeal, finding that the suggested errors were not well-founded on the facts before the District Court judge. The court noted that the plaintiff's condition had worsened after he initially received advice not to sue, and that he had subsequently changed solicitors and received different advice, leading to the commencement of proceedings. The court also observed that there was no dispute regarding liability. As there was no question of principle raised, leave to appeal was refused.
The application for leave to appeal was dismissed with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Application for leave to appeal dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
After changing his legal representation and receiving updated medical advice, Mr. Dum's condition deteriorated. Consequently, he sought to bring proceedings against BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd for damages due to the worsening of his condition. The plaintiff filed his claim 20 months after the injury, which was outside the statutory limitation period under the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The District Court, presided over by Goldring DCJ, considered the case of Itek Graphix Pty Ltd v Elliot and granted an extension for the plaintiff's late filing, finding no dispute over the liability of BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd. BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd subsequently sought leave to appeal the decision, but the application was dismissed as the alleged errors in the District Court's decision were not well founded on the facts before Goldring DCJ, and no question of principle was at issue.
The case of BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd v Necati Dum came before the court as an appeal against a decision of Goldring DCJ of the District Court. The plaintiff, Necati Dum, had initially been advised by counsel, seven months after sustaining an industrial injury, that legal action was not advisable. Subsequently, his condition deteriorated, leading him to seek new legal representation and advice. He then filed a claim for damages against BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd, albeit 20 months outside the statutory limitation period. The plaintiff applied for an extension of time under section 151D(2) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. Goldring DCJ considered the case law, notably Itek Graphix Pty Ltd v Elliot, and granted the extension. The defendant, BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd, sought leave to appeal this decision. However, the court denied the leave to appeal, noting that any alleged errors in the District Court’s decision were not well founded on the facts as found by Goldring DCJ, and there was no question of principle involved. The appeal process concluded with the dismissal of the application for leave to appeal, with costs awarded against the appellant.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Workers Compensation Act 1987 s.151D(2) permit an extension of time for bringing proceedings where a plaintiff was initially advised by counsel not to sue, but subsequently sought new advice and experienced a worsening of their condition?
2. Was the District Court's decision to grant an extension of time in accordance with the principles outlined in Itek Graphix Pty Ltd v Elliot?
3. Is there a basis for leave to appeal the District Court's decision, considering the suggested errors do not appear well-founded on the facts before Goldring DCJ?
4. Is there a question of principle involved in the refusal of leave to appeal, or is the matter confined to factual considerations?
Held
1. The court concluded that the Workers Compensation Act 1987 s.151D(2) does permit an extension of time for bringing proceedings where a plaintiff was initially advised by counsel not to sue, but subsequently sought new advice and experienced a worsening of their condition. The application for an extension of time was allowed.
2. The District Court's decision to grant an extension of time was in accordance with the principles outlined in Itek Graphix Pty Ltd v Elliot. The court found that the District Court had properly applied the principles in making its decision.
3. There is no basis for leave to appeal the District Court's decision, as the suggested errors do not appear well-founded on the facts before Goldring DCJ. The application for leave to appeal was dismissed.
4. The matter is confined to factual considerations, and there is no question of principle involved in the refusal of leave to appeal. The court found that the refusal of leave to appeal was not based on any question of principle.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's decision in BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd v Necati Dum hinges on the interpretation and application of s.151D(2) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The plaintiff, Mr. Dum, initially received legal advice not to sue but subsequently changed solicitors and sought new advice, which led him to bring proceedings 20 months out of the statutory time limit. The court was required to determine whether s.151D(2) permits an extension of time under these circumstances.
The Workers Compensation Act 1987 s.151D(2) provides a mechanism for extending the time limit for bringing proceedings if the court is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for the delay. The court considered the principle of fairness and the concept of justness as highlighted in Itek Graphix Pty Ltd v Elliot, which established that an extension may be granted if the plaintiff's delay in instituting proceedings was not unreasonable given all the circumstances. The court applied these principles to the facts, finding that Mr. Dum's initial advice not to sue, coupled with the subsequent worsening of his condition, constituted reasonable grounds for the delay. The court also noted that there was no dispute regarding liability, which further supported the granting of an extension.
In assessing whether the District Court's decision to grant an extension of time was in accordance with the principles outlined in Itek Graphix Pty Ltd v Elliot, the court confirmed that Goldring DCJ correctly applied the relevant statutory and common law principles. The decision was based on the specific facts of the case, including the plaintiff's initial advice, the change in medical condition, and the absence of any dispute over liability. The court found that the District Court had appropriately exercised its discretion, and thus the extension was in line with established legal principles.
The question of leave to appeal arose from the defendant's assertion that the District Court had erred in granting the extension of time. The court scrutinized the suggested errors but found them to be unsubstantiated in light of the facts before Goldring DCJ. The plaintiff's initial advice not to sue, the subsequent worsening of his condition, and the lack of dispute over liability were sufficient to justify the extension. The court held that the suggested errors did not appear well-founded on the facts, and thus the application for leave to appeal was dismissed.
Finally, the court considered whether there was a question of principle involved in the refusal of leave to appeal or if the matter was confined to factual considerations. The court determined that the refusal of leave to appeal did not involve a question of principle. Instead, the decision was based on the specific factual findings of the District Court, which were deemed to be correct and well-reasoned. The court emphasized that the principles of fairness and justness, as applied by Goldring DCJ, were appropriately considered and correctly applied to the facts of the case. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that s.151D(2) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 can permit an extension of time for bringing proceedings where a plaintiff was initially advised not to sue but subsequently sought new advice and experienced a worsening of their condition, provided there is no dispute over liability and the delay is reasonable under all circumstances.