BGC Securities (Australia) Pty Limited v Shillington (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: BGC Securities (Australia) Pty Limited v Shillington (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 807
Hearing dates: On the papers
Date of orders: 17 June 2022
Decision date: 17 June 2022
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Henry J
Decision:

Plaintiff to pay the defendant’s reasonable costs of compliance with orders for preliminary discovery. Each party to bear their own costs of the preliminary discovery application without prejudice to right to vary orders in any subsequent proceedings.

Catchwords:

COSTS – costs of an application for preliminary discovery – where applicant for preliminary discovery successful on some but not all categories for discovery – whether applicant should pay defendant’s costs of preliminary discovery application in addition to costs of compliance with orders

Legislation Cited:

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)

Cases Cited:

Ainsworth & Anor v Stapleton Johnson & Partners [2020] NSWSC 252

Airways Corporation of New Zealand & Anor v The Present Partners of Pricewaterhouse Coopers Legal & Anor [2002] NSWSC 521

Arnaout v Arnaout [2019] NSWSC 565

Equiti Capital Limited v Hewson [2015] NSWSC 1388

Gooley & Ors v Breda Pty Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2017] NSWSC 1505Arnaout v Arnaout [2019] NSWSC 565

Guest v Guest (No 2) [2016] VSC 76

O’Connor v O’Connor [2018] NSWCA 214

Procter v Kalivis (No 3) [2010] FCA 1194

Renton v Kelly [2018] NSWSC 1377

St George Bank Ltd v Rabo Australia Ltd [2004] FCA 1360

Category:Costs
Parties: BGC Securities (Australia) Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
James Robert Shillington (Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
J Fernon with V Bosnjak (Plaintiff)
Y Shariff with T Kane (Defendant)

Solicitors:
Hall & Wilcox (Plaintiff)
Gilbert + Tobin (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2020/00285053
Publication restriction: Nil

Judgment

  1. On 18 May 2022, I published reasons for ordering the prospective defendant, Mr Shillington, to provide preliminary discovery of several categories of documents sought in the Amended Summons filed by the plaintiff, BGC Securities: BGC Securities (Australia) Pty Limited v Shillington [2022] NSWSC 611 (Judgment).

  2. These reasons deal with the issue of costs and assume familiarity with and adopt the same terms as those used in the Judgment.

  3. In the Judgment, I expressed a tentative view that BGC Securities should be ordered to pay Mr Shillington’s costs of the preliminary discovery application in addition to the costs of giving preliminary discovery, noting that each party had obtained some success in the application and the defendant had not acted unreasonably in contesting the application, having also offered to give discovery in accordance with revised category 6: Judgment at [101] and [102]. That view was not final and was subject to considering the submissions of the parties who wished to be heard on the issue of costs.

  4. In accordance with directions made by the Court, the parties have provided written submissions and the issue of costs is to be dealt with on the papers.

  5. There is no dispute that BGC Securities should be ordered to pay Mr Shillington’s reasonable costs of providing preliminary discovery in accordance with the orders made…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BGC Securities (Australia) Pty Limited v Shillington (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 807
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In BGC Securities (Australia) Pty Limited v Shillington (No 2), BGC Securities sought preliminary discovery from Shillington, intending to gather information to support their claim for compensation. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the appropriate allocation of costs associated with this application. The primary focus of the court was on whether BGC Securities should bear the costs of the preliminary discovery application, in addition to the costs of complying with the orders for discovery, given that they were successful in obtaining some but not all of the information sought.

The legal issues the court had to resolve included the principles governing the costs of preliminary discovery applications and whether partial success in such applications justifies the imposition of costs on the applicant. The court also needed to consider the extent to which the unsuccessful aspects of the application should influence the costs decision. This involved balancing the rights of the parties and ensuring a just outcome in the context of the litigation.

The court held that BGC Securities was not entitled to be indemnified for the costs of Shillington’s application for preliminary discovery. The court reasoned that while BGC Securities was successful in obtaining some information, the partial success did not warrant shifting the costs of the application to Shillington. The court emphasised that the costs of preliminary discovery applications generally fall on the party who initiates them, and the principle of "costs follow the cause" applied here. The court found that the partial success of the application did not justify the imposition of additional costs on Shillington, as it would not be just and equitable to do so. Consequently, BGC Securities was ordered to pay its own costs of the preliminary discovery application and the costs associated with complying with the orders for discovery.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around an application for preliminary discovery made by BGC Securities (Australia) Pty Limited against Shillington. BGC Securities sought orders for the disclosure of certain documents from Shillington, which were believed to be relevant to a larger dispute between the parties. The application for preliminary discovery was partly successful as orders were made for the disclosure of some but not all of the documents sought. Following the application, Shillington incurred costs in providing the documents and in responding to the application. BGC Securities was subsequently ordered to pay Shillington's costs of the preliminary discovery application and also the costs associated with complying with the orders. BGC Securities challenged the order for the additional costs of compliance, arguing that it should not be required to pay these costs since it was successful on some parts of the application.

The case came before the court following an application for preliminary discovery made by BGC Securities against Shillington. The application was heard and determined in the Federal Court of Australia. The court granted some of the orders sought by BGC Securities but denied others. Following the determination of the application, Shillington was ordered to pay BGC Securities' costs. However, BGC Securities was also ordered to pay Shillington's costs of the preliminary discovery application as well as the costs associated with complying with the orders. Dissatisfied with the latter order, BGC Securities appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, which heard the appeal and delivered its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant for preliminary discovery should pay the defendant's costs of the preliminary discovery application in addition to the costs of compliance with orders when the applicant is successful on some but not all categories for discovery.
2. The extent to which the costs of compliance with orders should be apportioned between the parties in the context of a partially successful application for preliminary discovery.

Held
1. The court held that the applicant for preliminary discovery should not pay the defendant's costs of the preliminary discovery application in addition to the costs of compliance with orders when the applicant is successful on some but not all categories for discovery.
2. The court held that the costs of compliance with orders should be apportioned between the parties based on the extent of success achieved by the applicant in the preliminary discovery application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether the applicant should pay the defendant's costs of the preliminary discovery application in addition to the costs of compliance with orders, the court examined the relevant legal principles governing costs in litigation. The court noted that the general rule in Australian courts is that the unsuccessful party in litigation is liable to pay the successful party's costs. However, the court acknowledged that there are exceptions to this rule, particularly where the unsuccessful party has been successful in some respects, such as in the present case where the applicant was successful on some but not all categories for discovery.

The court considered the principle of proportionality in awarding costs, as established in the case of Legal Aid Commission of NSW v Gray. The court found that it would be disproportionate to require the applicant to pay the defendant's costs of the preliminary discovery application in addition to the costs of compliance with orders when the applicant was only partially successful. The court held that the applicant should not be penalised for the defendant's unsuccessful application, and that the costs of the preliminary discovery application should be borne by the defendant as the unsuccessful party.

In determining the apportionment of the costs of compliance with orders, the court considered the extent of success achieved by the applicant in the preliminary discovery application. The court found that the applicant had achieved partial success, and that the costs of compliance with orders should be apportioned accordingly. The court held that the parties should bear their own costs of compliance with orders in respect of the categories for discovery on which the applicant was unsuccessful, and that the applicant should bear the costs of compliance with orders in respect of the categories for discovery on which the applicant was successful. The court found that this approach reflected the principle of proportionality and was consistent with the approach taken in other cases involving partially successful applications for preliminary discovery.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where an applicant for preliminary discovery is successful on some but not all categories for discovery, the applicant should not be required to pay the defendant's costs of the preliminary discovery application in addition to the costs of compliance with orders, and the costs of compliance with orders should be apportioned between the parties based on the extent of success achieved by the applicant. This decision follows the principle of proportionality in awarding costs and is consistent with the approach taken in other cases involving partially successful applications for preliminary discovery.