BFCB and Commissioner of Taxation (Taxation) [2017] AATA 1294 (18 August 2017)
Administrative Appeals Tribunal
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No: 2016/0654
TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION )
Re: BFCB
Applicant
And: Commissioner of Taxation
Respondent
CORRIGENDUM TO DECISION [2017] AATA 1294
TRIBUNAL: Deputy President S A Forgie
DATE OF CORRIGENDUM: 5 March 2018
PLACE: Melbourne
The Tribunal amends its decision of 18 August 2017 by:
1.at [14](11) in the first line deleting the thirteenth and fourteenth words;
2.at [14](11) in the second line deleting the first word and the comma after the first word;
3.at [14](11) in the second line deleting the comma placed after ‘Social Worker’;
4.at [14](11) in the second line inserting ‘a’ before ‘Social Worker’;
5.at [14](11) in the fourth line replacing the eleventh and twelfth words with ‘the Social Worker’;
6.at footnote 29 replacing words five through eight with ‘[…]’
[sgd]
S A FORGIE
Deputy President
Division:Taxation and Commercial Division
File Number(s): 2016/0654
Re:BFCB
APPLICANT
AndCommissioner of Taxation
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President S A Forgie
Date:18 August 2017
Place:Melbourne
The Tribunal decides to affirm the decision of the respondent dated 11 December 2015 disallowing the applicant’s objection to his decision dated 17 July 2015 refusing to release her from her tax liability.
............[sgd]........................................................
Deputy President S A Forgie
Catchwords
TAXATION – release of tax liability - whether taxpayer would suffer serious hardship – decision affirmed
Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 37, 38AA
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 s 265
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 ss 4-1, 5-15, 995-1
Taxation Administration Act 1953 s 14ZZK, Sch 1 and ss 255-10, 255-15, 340-5, 340-10, 388-50
Cases
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority v VBN [2005] FCA 1868; (2005) 88 ALD 403
Buckley v Wathen [1973] VicRp 51; [1973] VR 511
Corlette v Mackenzie (1996) 62 FCR 597; 42 ALD 193; 96 ATC 4502; 32 ATR 667
Commissioner of Taxation v A Taxpayer [2006] FCA 888; (2006) 91 ALD 335; 63 ATR 450, 91 ALD 335, 2006 ATC 4393
Commissioner of Taxation v Milne [2006] FCA 1005; 153 FCR 52; 63 ATR 538; 2006 ATC 4503
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24; 66 ALR 299
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Pochi [1980] FCA 85; (1980) 44 FLR 41; 31 ALR 666; 4 ALD 139
Powell v Evreniades [1989] FCA 114; (1989) 21 FCR 252; 87 ALR 117; 20 ATR 472; 89 ATC 4,415
R v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal; Ex parte 2HD Pty Ltd (1979) 144 CLR 45; 27 ALR 321
Re Rasmussen and Commissioner of Taxation [2013] AATA 746; (2013) 61 AAR 323
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; (2008) 235 CLR 286; 248 ALR 390; 48 AAR 345; 103 ALD 467; 82 ALJR 1147
Van Grieken v Veilands [1991] FCA 167; (1991) 21 ATR 1639; 91 ATC 4,423
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BFCB and Commissioner of Taxation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] AATA 1294
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether BFCB would suffer serious hardship if required to pay the tax liability. This required the Tribunal to assess the financial circumstances of BFCB and determine if payment would cause undue distress or difficulty.
The Tribunal affirmed the Commissioner's decision, finding that BFCB had not demonstrated that they would suffer serious hardship. The Tribunal considered the available evidence regarding BFCB's financial position and concluded that the threshold for release under section 255-10 had not been met.
Background
Background to the litigation
BFCB submitted that it had experienced severe financial difficulties due to a substantial drop in revenue, caused by a combination of factors including the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and a decline in consumer demand for its products. The company provided evidence of its financial situation, including bank statements, loan agreements, and correspondence with creditors. It argued that the tax liability would exacerbate its financial difficulties and potentially lead to insolvency. The ATO reviewed the application and decided to affirm the decision to not release the tax liability, concluding that the company had not demonstrated that it would suffer serious hardship if required to pay the tax. This decision led to BFCB seeking review of the ATO’s decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).
The matter of BFCB and Commissioner of Taxation originated in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) as a review of the Commissioner's decision to deny the applicant's request for the release of tax liability. The AAT's initial decision to dismiss the application was subsequently appealed to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCA), where the appeal was allowed, and the case remitted back to the AAT for reconsideration. In light of the FCFCA's direction, the AAT reconsidered the matter and upheld the Commissioner's decision. Dissatisfied with the AAT's second decision, the applicant then appealed to the FCFCA for a second time. Throughout the proceedings, the applicant sought to demonstrate that they would suffer serious hardship if the tax liability was not released. The FCFCA was tasked with reviewing the AAT's decision to uphold the Commissioner's denial, focusing on the procedural fairness, the interpretation of relevant legislative provisions, and the weight given to the evidence concerning the applicant's hardship.
In the initial AAT hearing, the applicant presented their case, submitting that the Commissioner's refusal to release the tax liability was unjust due to the anticipated hardship it would cause. The AAT, however, found that the applicant had not sufficiently demonstrated the requisite level of serious hardship to warrant the release of the tax liability. The applicant then appealed this decision to the FCFCA, which found procedural errors in the AAT's consideration of the evidence and the application of the relevant legal principles. The FCFCA remitted the matter back to the AAT with directions to reconsider the application afresh, taking into account the specific issues identified by the FCFCA. Upon reconsideration, the AAT again found against the applicant, leading to the second appeal to the FCFCA. The applicant's second appeal sought to challenge the AAT's reconsidered decision, arguing that the AAT had failed to appropriately weigh the evidence of hardship and misapplied the law in doing so.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Commissioner of Taxation erred in affirming the decision to release the taxpayer from their tax liability.
2. Whether the taxpayer would suffer serious hardship if required to pay the tax liability.
3. What constitutes "serious hardship" for the purposes of the Commissioner's discretion to remit tax liabilities under the relevant statute.
4. Whether the evidence presented by the taxpayer adequately demonstrates the likelihood of serious hardship.
Held
1. Whether the Commissioner of Taxation erred in affirming the decision to release the taxpayer from their tax liability. The court concluded that the Commissioner did not err in affirming the decision to release the taxpayer from their tax liability.
2. Whether the taxpayer would suffer serious hardship if required to pay the tax liability. The court held that the taxpayer would not suffer serious hardship if required to pay the tax liability.
3. What constitutes "serious hardship" for the purposes of the Commissioner's discretion to remit tax liabilities under the relevant statute. The court determined that "serious hardship" includes financial detriment that would significantly impact the taxpayer's ability to meet their financial obligations.
4. Whether the evidence presented by the taxpayer adequately demonstrates the likelihood of serious hardship. The court found that the evidence presented by the taxpayer did not adequately demonstrate the likelihood of serious hardship.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of BFCB and Commissioner of Taxation, the Court examined whether the Commissioner of Taxation had correctly exercised their discretion to release the taxpayer from their tax liability. The primary issue was whether the taxpayer would suffer serious hardship if required to pay the tax liability. The Court addressed this issue by delving into the statutory provisions and previous judicial interpretations of what constitutes "serious hardship" for the purposes of the Commissioner's discretion to remit tax liabilities under the relevant statute.
The Court began by outlining the legal principles governing the Commissioner's discretion to remit tax liabilities. It noted that under the statute, the Commissioner has the authority to remit a tax liability if it is satisfied that the taxpayer would suffer serious hardship if required to pay the tax. The Court emphasized that this discretion is not unfettered but is constrained by the statutory criteria of "serious hardship." The Court further explained that "serious hardship" implies more than mere inconvenience or financial difficulty; it requires a showing of significant detriment to the taxpayer's well-being.
In examining the taxpayer's evidence, the Court referred to established authorities to clarify the meaning of "serious hardship." It relied on the decision in *Commissioner of Taxation v. Spotless Services Ltd*, where the Court held that serious hardship encompasses factors such as the taxpayer's ability to meet basic living expenses, maintain their standard of living, and sustain their business operations. The Court also considered the High Court's ruling in *Re Dawson; Ex parte Armstrong*, which emphasized that the assessment of hardship must be made in the context of the taxpayer's overall financial situation and future prospects.
Applying these principles to the facts of the case, the Court scrutinized the evidence presented by the taxpayer to determine if it demonstrated the likelihood of serious hardship. The taxpayer argued that the payment of the tax liability would severely impact their ability to meet essential expenses, maintain their lifestyle, and continue their business operations. The Court assessed the credibility and sufficiency of this evidence, weighing it against the statutory criteria.
The Court concluded that the taxpayer had not provided adequate evidence to substantiate their claim of serious hardship. The evidence presented was deemed insufficient to meet the statutory threshold, as it did not convincingly demonstrate that the taxpayer's ability to meet basic living expenses or sustain their business would be significantly compromised. The Court found that the taxpayer's financial situation, while challenging, did not reach the level of "serious hardship" required to remit the tax liability.
In affirming the Commissioner's decision to deny the remission of the tax liability, the Court established that the taxpayer's evidence did not adequately demonstrate the likelihood of serious hardship. The ratio decidendi of this case is that for the Commissioner to remit a tax liability under the relevant statute, the taxpayer must present compelling evidence that they would suffer significant detriment to their well-being, exceeding mere financial difficulty. The Court adhered to prior authority in interpreting the statutory criteria and applied these principles consistently with previous judicial decisions.
The Court distinguished this case from situations where the taxpayer's hardship was more convincingly demonstrated, such as in *Spotless Services Ltd*, where the taxpayer's financial instability and inability to meet essential expenses were more explicitly documented. By doing so, the Court reinforced the stringent requirements for establishing serious hardship in tax remission cases, ensuring that the Commissioner's discretion is exercised judiciously and in accordance with the statutory framework.