Bevillesta Pty Ltd v Parramatta City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Bevillesta Pty Ltd v Parramatta City Council [1988] NSWLEC 124
PARTIES:

APPICANT
Bevillesta Ply Ltd

RESPONDANT
Parramatta City Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 10602 of 1987
CORAM: Bignold J
KEY ISSUES: :-
LEGISLATION CITED:
CASES CITED: E.S. Turnbull Pty. Limited v. Wollongong City Council
DATES OF HEARING: 17/12/1987, 23/12/1987
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
06/21/1988
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:
APPLICANT
Mr. Molloy
RESPONDENT
Mr. Neustein
Mr. Laffer
Mr. Hassall
Mr. Tillott


JUDGMENT:

Bignold J.: The Respondent seeks an order for costs in respect of class 1 proceedings which it was defending and which proceedings were terminated on 11th April, 1988 when the Applicant, without prior notice, withdrew its appeal at the commencement of the hearing.

The hearing had been specially fixed for 11th-13th April, 1988 at a call-over conducted by the Registrar on 18th March, 1988. In fact this was the second occasion that the proceedings had been specially fixed for hearing. At the first call-over conducted on 17th December, 1987 (following the lodging of the appeal on 2nd December, 1987) the Registrar specially fixed the hearing for 22nd and 23rd February, 1987. At that call-over the Applicant had indicated that it would be calling two experts being an architect and an expert with special skills in building sun-screen applications and the Respondent had indicated that it would be calling a Building Consultant (Mr. Hassall) and one of its employed Town Planners (Mr. Tillott).

On 17th February, 1988 the Applicant filed a Notice of Motion seeking the vacation of the hearing fixed for 22nd and 23rd February, 1988.

On 19th February, 1988 the Duty Judge vacated the hearing and ordered the Applicant to pay the Respondent's costs incurred by virtue of the vacation of the hearing.

On that occasion the basis for seeking the vacation of the hearing was the fact that the parties were actively negotiating and seeking to resolve the dispute without the necessity for litigation. Although the Respondent did not oppose the Motion it sought its costs thrown away. The Applicant opposed any order for costs on the basis that the Respondent had not complied with the Court's Practice Direction in relation to the filing and exchange of expert reports. As I have noted the Duty Judge ordered costs against the Applicant.

Although the Court's policy or practice is not to award costs in class 1 or 2 proceedings save in exceptional circumstances different considerations apply where an appeal is belatedly withdrawn or discontinued. In such circumstances where the non-withdrawing party has come to Court prepared to defend the appeal, as has the Respondent in the present case, it is usual for the Court to award it the costs thrown away by the belated withdrawal.

In the present case the Applicant resists the usual costs order solely on the ground of the Respondent's non-compliance with the Court's Practice Direction in respect of the filing and exchange before the hearing, of expert reports. The Practice Direction is in the following terms:-

"Where expert evidence is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bevillesta Pty Ltd v Parramatta City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1988] NSWLEC 124
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, the case of Bevillesta Pty Ltd v Parramatta City Council involved the applicant, Bevillesta Pty Ltd, and the respondent, Parramatta City Council. The dispute arose from the applicant's appeal against a decision of the respondent, which the applicant subsequently withdrew without notice at the commencement of the hearing. The respondent sought an order for costs in respect of the proceedings which the applicant had defended. The central legal issue the court had to decide was whether the respondent, despite not fully complying with the court's Practice Direction regarding the filing and exchange of expert reports, was entitled to costs thrown away by the applicant's withdrawal of the appeal.

The court considered the established practice of awarding costs to the non-withdrawing party in cases where an appeal is withdrawn or discontinued late. The court noted that different considerations applied in such circumstances, particularly when the non-withdrawing party had come to court prepared to defend the appeal. However, the applicant argued that the respondent's non-compliance with the Practice Direction disentitled it to an order for costs. The court examined the Practice Direction, which required that expert evidence in written form be filed and delivered no later than 14 days prior to the listed hearing date. While the respondent had filed and delivered one expert report in accordance with this direction, additional reports were delivered belatedly.

The court acknowledged the difficulties that could arise from the application of the Practice Direction, especially when breached by either party. It highlighted that non-compliance did not necessarily preclude a party from receiving costs. The court concluded that the respondent was entitled to most of its costs thrown away by the applicant's withdrawal of the appeal. However, considering the respondent's non-compliance with the Practice Direction as an element of misconduct in the litigation, the court decided to exclude costs associated with the expert reports and proposed testimony of two of the respondents' experts, Mr. Neustein and Mr. Laffer, from the costs order.

Ultimately, the court ordered the applicant to pay the respondent's costs thrown away by the applicant's withdrawal of the appeal, excluding costs referable to the expert reports prepared by Mr. Neustein and Mr. Laffer and to their attendance as witnesses. This decision reflected the court's view that while the respondent's non-compliance was serious, it did not entirely deprive the respondent of its entitlement to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established