SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
REGISTRY: BRISBANE
NUMBER: 6499 of 1998
[2000]QSC 264
Plaintiff: ELIZABETH MARY CAROL BEVERLEY
AND
First Defendant: NORWICH UNION LIFE AUSTRALIA LTD ACN 006 783 295
AND
Second Defendant: PETER NESS
Plaintiff: NORWICH UNION LIFE AUSTRALIA LTD ACN 006 783 295
AND
First Defendant: ELIZABETH MARY CAROL BEVERLEY
AND
Second defendant: VINCENT GORDON BEVERLEY
BY FIRST COUNTER CLAIM
Plaintiff: VINCENT GORDON BEVERLEY
AND
First Defendant: NORWICH UNION LIFE AUSTRALIA LTD ACN 006 783 295
AND
Second Defendant: PETER NESS
BY SECOND COUNTER CLAIM
JUDGMENT
Williams J
Delivered the 29th day of June 2000
Consequent upon the answers made by the jury to the questions submitted for their consideration, senior counsel for the plaintiffs, Elizabeth Mary Carol Beverley and Vincent Gordon Beverley, moved for judgment against the defendants Norwich Union Life Australia Ltd (“Norwich”) and Peter Ness in the sum of $190,000.
It should be noted that the jury was not asked to apportion liability as between Norwich and Ness, but apparently because of the wording of questions 9 and 10 they considered they were expected to do so. The supplementary answer (exhibit 23) makes it clear that the jury determined that the Beverleys were entitled to recover 20% of $950,000 namely $190,000. In consequence the jury’s purported apportionment of that amount as between Norwich and Ness can be ignored for purposes of the judgment.
Senior counsel for Norwich also moved for judgment, in the form of a declaration that Norwich had validly avoided the insurance policy in question.
In those circumstances it is necessary to recount briefly the history of the matter and in particular the pleadings to see what orders are called for in the light of the findings of the jury.
On 27 September 1995 the relevant proposal for insurance was completed by the Beverleys in the presence of Ness, and Norwich issued policy 7322744 in consequence in October 1995. Mrs Beverley was the owner of the policy and the life insured was that of Mr Beverley. By letter dated 5 February 1998 Norwich communicated to the Beverleys the fact that it had terminated that policy on the ground, inter alia, of non-disclosure of material facts. The response of the Beverleys was a letter of 5 March 1998 asserting that Mr Beverley was suffering “no pre-existing medical condition”, thereby impliedly contending that there was no non-disclosure. Norwich maintained that it had validly terminated the policy.
The action was commenced by writ issued 16 July 1998; Mrs Beverley was the only plaintiff and Norwich the only defendant. The statement of claim in the action so constituted was delivered on 12 October 1998. The principal relief claimed was a declaration that the subject policy remained in full force and effect.
The defence of Norwich was delivered on 6 November 1998; it included a counter-claim against both Mr and Mrs Beverley for a declaration that it had “validly avoided a policy of insurance being policy No 7322744 between the defendant on the one hand and Vincent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Beverley v Norwich Union Life Australia Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] QSC 264
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues in the case were whether Norwich was entitled to terminate the insurance policy due to non-disclosure and whether Ness was negligent in the completion of the insurance proposal. Additionally, the court had to determine the appropriate allocation of costs and interest in the case.
The court found that the jury's answers established that there was a non-disclosure of material facts, justifying Norwich's termination of the policy. The jury also found Ness to be negligent in his handling of the insurance proposal. Consequently, the court granted Norwich a declaration that it had validly avoided the insurance policy. The Beverleys were awarded damages against both Norwich and Ness, amounting to $190,000, plus interest from the date of the proposal to the date of satisfaction of the judgment. The court ordered Norwich to bear the costs of its successful claim and the Beverleys to bear the costs of their successful claim for damages. Additionally, Norwich was granted a declaration of entitlement to be indemnified by Ness for any amount paid to the Beverleys.
In summary, the court ruled that Norwich was justified in terminating the insurance policy, but the Beverleys were entitled to damages for the negligence of Norwich's agent. The judgment included a declaration of indemnity in favor of Norwich against Ness, and the allocation of costs and interest in accordance with the findings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi