Bester v Mirror Trading International (Pty) Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bester v Mirror Trading International (Pty) Ltd (in liq) [2023] FCA 1194

File number(s): VID 674 of 2023
Judgment of: BUTTON J
Date of judgment: 6 October 2023
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – Cross-border insolvency – application for recognition of foreign proceeding as foreign main proceeding under Art 17 of Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law being Sch 1 to the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) – where defendant is a company registered in the Republic of South Africa – where defendant placed in liquidation by the High Court of South Africa – where presumption of centre of main interests not rebutted – where nature of foreign proceeding analogous to liquidation under Part 5.4B of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Ch 5, Pt 5.4B

Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) s 16, Sch 1 (Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law) Art 2, 15, 16, 17, 20, 21

Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) r 15A.7

Cases cited:

Laverty v Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (in administration), in the matter of Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (in administration) [2023] FCA 721

Tai-Soo Suk v Hanjin Shipping Co Ltd [2016] FCA 1404

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 25
Date of hearing: 6 October 2023
Counsel for the Plaintiffs: M McKillop
Solicitor for the Plaintiffs: Hicks Oakley Chessell Williams

ORDERS

VID 674 of 2023
BETWEEN:

HERMAN BESTER N.O.

First Plaintiff

ADRIAAN WILLEM VAN ROOYEN N.O.

Second Plaintiff

CHRISTOPHER JAMES ROOS N.O.

Third Plaintiff

JACOLIEN FRIEDA BERNARD N.O.

Fourth Plaintiff

DEIDRE BASSON N.O.

Fifth Plaintiff

CHAVONNES BADENHORST ST CLAIRE COOPER N.O.

Sixth Plaintiff

DANIEL SANDILE NDLOVU N.O.

Seventh Plaintiff

KEVIN TITUS N.O.

Eight Plaintiff

AND:

MIRROR TRADING INTERNATIONAL (PTY) LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)

Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

BUTTON J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 OCTOBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to Art 17(1) of the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (Model Law) and s 6 of the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) (Cross-Border Insolvency Act), the proceedings in the High Court of South Africa (Master’s Ref. C000906/2020) (RSA Proceeding) be recognised in relation to the Defendant, Mirror Trading International (Pty) Ltd (in liquidation) (Company) as a foreign proceeding.

2.Pursuant to Art 17(2)(a) of the Model Law, the RSA Proceeding be recognised as a foreign main proceeding within the meaning of Art 2(b) of the Model Law.

3.Pursuant to Art 17(1)(b) of the Model Law, the Plaintiffs, Herman Bester N.O., Adriaan Willem Van Rooyen N.O., Christopher James Roos N.O., Jacolien Frieda Bernard N.O., Deidre Basson N.O., Chavonnes Badenhorst St Claire Cooper N.O., Daniel Sandile Ndlovu N.O. and Kevin Titus N.O. be recognised as the foreign representatives of the Company.

4.For the purposes of Art 20(2) of the Model Law and s 16…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bester v Mirror Trading International (Pty) Ltd (in liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1194
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Bester and others brought a case against Mirror Trading International (Pty) Ltd, a South African company that had been placed into liquidation. The plaintiffs sought recognition of the South African liquidation as a foreign main proceeding under the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency and the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth). They also sought orders aligning the scope and terms of the stay and suspension of legal actions against the company in Australia with those that would apply under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) if the company were undergoing liquidation in Australia. Furthermore, they sought to entrust the administration and realisation of any Australian assets of the company to them as foreign representatives.

The court had to determine whether the South African liquidation proceeding could be recognised as a foreign main proceeding and whether the scope of the stay and suspension of legal actions in Australia should mirror that under Australian insolvency law. The court also needed to decide whether the plaintiffs should be entrusted with the administration and realisation of any Australian assets of the company. The court examined the nature of the South African proceeding and compared it to Australian insolvency proceedings to determine the appropriate stay and suspension terms. The court also considered the potential existence of Australian assets and the plaintiffs' capacity to manage them.

The court held that the South African liquidation proceeding was analogous to Australian insolvency proceedings and, therefore, the stay and suspension terms should mirror those under Australian law. The court found it appropriate to entrust the plaintiffs with the administration and realisation of any Australian assets of the company. The court recognised the South African liquidation as a foreign main proceeding and recognised the plaintiffs as foreign representatives. It also granted the plaintiffs the capacity to administer and realise any Australian assets of the company and ordered them to publish notices to Australian creditors.

The court ordered the recognition of the South African liquidation as a foreign main proceeding and the plaintiffs as foreign representatives. It aligned the scope and terms of the stay and suspension of legal actions in Australia with those that would apply under Australian insolvency law. The court also entrusted the plaintiffs with the administration and realisation of any Australian assets of the company and ordered them to publish notices to Australian creditors. The plaintiffs were granted their costs of the originating process. Any party affected by these orders could apply for relief within five business days' notice.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to Art 17(1) of the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (Model Law) and s 6 of the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) (Cross-Border Insolvency Act), the proceedings in the High Court of South Africa (Master’s Ref. C000906/2020) (RSA Proceeding) be recognised in relation to the Defendant, Mirror Trading International (Pty) Ltd (in liquidation) (Company) as a foreign proceeding.

2. Pursuant to Art 17(2)(a) of the Model Law, the RSA Proceeding be recognised as a foreign main proceeding within the meaning of Art 2(b) of the Model Law.

3. Pursuant to Art 17(1)(b) of the Model Law, the Plaintiffs, Herman Bester N.O., Adriaan Willem Van Rooyen N.O., Christopher James Roos N.O., Jacolien Frieda Bernard N.O., Deidre Basson N.O., Chavonnes Badenhorst St Claire Cooper N.O., Daniel Sandile Ndlovu N.O. and Kevin Titus N.O. be recognised as the foreign representatives of the Company.

4. For the purposes of Art 20(2) of the Model Law and s 16 of the Cross-Border Insolvency Act, the scope, and the modification or termination, of the stay and suspension referred to in Art 20(1) of the Model Law with respect to the Company be the same as would apply if the stay or suspension arose under Pt 5.4B in Ch 5 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act), and as if:

(a) Pt 5.4B of the Corporations Act applied to the Company (as a company subject to liquidation proceedings under that Part); and

(b) references in Pt 5.4B of the Corporations Act to the consent of the company’s liquidators are taken to be references to the consent of the Plaintiffs as foreign representatives.

5. Pursuant to Art 21(1)(e) of the Model Law, the administration and realisation of the Company’s assets located in Australia be entrusted to the Plaintiffs as foreign representatives.

6. The requirements of r 15A.7(1) of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) (Rules) be dispensed with and in lieu thereof:

(a) within 20 business days of the making of these orders, the Plaintiffs publish a notice in accordance with Form 21 prescribed by the Rules (Notice), in The Australian and the Australian Financial Review newspapers; and

(b) within 20 business days of the making of these orders, the Plaintiffs give the Notice to each Australian creditor of the Company known to the Plaintiffs by sending a copy of the Notice to the email address of the person or to the email address of their legal representatives.

7. Any party affected by these orders is at liberty to apply upon five business days’ notice.

8. The Plaintiffs’ costs of the Originating Process are its costs in the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The plaintiffs sought further orders providing that, for the purposes of Art 20(2) of the Model Law and s 16 of the Act, the scope, and the modification or termination, of the stay and suspension referred to in Art 20(1) of the Model Law be the same as would apply if the stay or suspension arose under Pt 5.4B in Ch 5 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) and as if Pt 5.4B applied to MTI as a company subject to liquidation proceedings under that Part, and on the basis that references in Pt 5.4B to the consent of the company’s liquidators are to be references to the consent of the plaintiffs as foreign representatives. While the effect of s 16 of the Act is to impose a stay automatically upon recognition, it is the usual practice to make an order giving explicit effect to Art 20 of the Model Law and s 16 of the Act: Laverty v Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (in administration), in the matter of Greensill Capital (UK) Limited (in administration) [2023] FCA 721 at [44] (Halley J). In Tai-Soo Suk v Hanjin Shipping Co Ltd [2016] FCA 1404, Jagot J (as her Honour then was) said as follows at [22] and [24]:I accept that, by the relevant provisions, the Court is required to determine what the “case requires”. In context, this means that it is for the Court to identify which of the Parts of the Corporations Act would apply to the foreign proceedings if they were taking place under that Act. If it had been intended that the Court select the stays and suspensions from the nominated Parts of the Corporations Act on a discretionary basis then another criterion, not “as the case requires”, would have been used. ...The stay which “should apply” is the stay the “case requires” which is determined by the nature of the foreign proceedings compared to the nature of proceedings under the relevant Parts of the Corporations Act. The plaintiffs’ originating process seeks relief that identifies Pt 5.4B of the Corporations Act as the applicable part. Pt 5.4B of the Corporations Act is concerned with winding up in insolvency or by the court. As such, it is the part that most closely resembles the nature of the South African proceeding and is the appropriate part to be referred to in orders confirming the nature and application of the stay in these circumstances. The plaintiffs sought further relief pursuant to Art 21(1)(e) of the Model Law entrusting the administration and realisation of MTI’s assets in Australia to the plaintiffs. Article 21(1)(e) provides that:1.Upon recognition of a foreign proceeding, whether main or non-main, where necessary to protect the assets of the debtor or the interests of the creditors, the court may, at the request of the foreign representative, grant any appropriate relief, including:...(e) Entrusting the administration or realization of all or part of the debtor’s assets located in this State to the foreign representative or another person designated by the court; … The plaintiffs are the duly appointed liquidators of MTI. The evidence does not disclose what, if any, assets MTI has in Australia. That said, potential recoveries from early investors who did receive proceeds funded by later investors may constitute an asset. The court was informed from the Bar table that some investors in this class are based in Australia, making it likely that there are at least some Australian assets. To the extent that MTI does have assets in Australia, it is appropriate that the liquidators have the capacity to realise those assets and deal with them in the liquidation for the benefit of MTI’s creditors. The evidence discloses that the plaintiffs are, through their solicitors, aware of a large group of creditors located in Australia, and are already engaged in the process of accepting claims from Australian-based creditors. It is appropriate that orders be made authorising the plaintiffs to deal with any Australian assets of MTI.