Berthun v Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Berthun v Queensland Police Service – Weapons Licensing [2018] QCAT 413

PARTIES:

ANTHONY WILLIAM BERTHUN
(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE – WEAPONS LICENSING
(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR232-17 and GAR434-18

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

4 December 2018

HEARING DATE:

21 February 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Fitzpatrick

ORDERS:

1.   The application by Anthony William Berthun for an extension of time to review the decision of the Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing made 10 January 2017 is granted.

2.   Review of the decision made 10 January 2017 will remain a separate proceeding to be heard together with application GAR232-17.

3.   Evidence and submissions in one proceeding will be evidence and submissions in the other proceeding.

4.   Application GAR232-17 is dismissed.

5.   The decision to reject the application by Anthony William Berthun for a Weapons Licence made
10 January 2017 is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where application made for extension of time to review a decision – where application to review a decision to reject an application for a weapon licence – where review application brought out of time – whether extension of time warranted

FIRE, EXPLOSIVES AND FIREARMS – FIREARMS – LICENSING AND REGISTRATION – OTHER MATTERS – where domestic violence order made but subsequently revoked on reopening application – where no appeal – status of domestic violence order – significance of traffic history

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20
Weapons Act 1990 (Qld), s 10, s 10B, s 15(6), s 34AA
Domestic Family Violence Protection Act 1999 (Qld),
s 23(2), s 44, s 96, s 97, s 143, s 164, s 165, s 169, s 187
Justices Act 1886 (Qld), s 142(1)(a), s 142(2)(a), s 142(6), s 142(7)

Commissioner of Police Service v Ryle Rockhampton District Court D23/2004
Crime and Misconduct Commission v Chapman & Anor [2011] QCAT 229
Goodwin v Phillips (1908) 7 CLR 1
Peacock v Crowley (Unreported, District Court Appeal 1573/98, McGill DCJ, 20 May 1998)
Roesch v Queensland Police Service, Weapons Licensing Branch [2013] QCAT 717
Urquhart v Queensland Police Weapons Licensing Branch [2011] QCAT 023

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Mr R M Galloway instructed by Anne Murray and Co, Solicitors

Respondent:

Acting Senior Sergeant C Bradford, Queensland Police Service

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Three matters are before me for determination:

    (a)Application to review a decision of Senior Sergeant AT Cavanagh dated 7 July 2017, rejecting an application by the applicant for a Firearms Licence made 17 April 2017. That is referred to as the Second Decision. The Application was filed on 4 August 2017 and is part of Proceeding GAR232-17;

    (b)Application by the respondent to dismiss or strike out the application to review the decision of 7 July 2017, filed 12 December 2017;

    (c)Application for an order extending time for the applicant to seek a review of the decision of the respondent dated 10 January 2017 to reject an application for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Berthun v Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 413
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Berthun v Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing, the applicant, Anthony William Berthun, sought an extension of time to review the decision of the Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing, which had rejected his application for a weapon licence. The dispute arose from the interpretation of the significance of a domestic violence order made in 2015, which was subsequently revoked, and its impact on Berthun's eligibility for a firearm licence under the Weapons Act. The legal issues before the court involved whether an extension of time for the review application was warranted and the effect of the domestic violence order on Berthun's eligibility for a licence.

The court examined the statutory provisions and previous case law to determine the effect of the domestic violence order on Berthun's eligibility for a weapon licence. The respondent argued that the order, made in 2015, remained effective for the purposes of deeming Berthun not a fit and proper person to hold a licence under section 10B(2)(b) of the Weapons Act, despite its revocation later that year. The court considered the principles that a domestic violence order deprives a person of the right to hold a weapon licence and that the order's effectivity is not contingent on the outcome of any appeal. The court also noted that the absence of an appeal meant the order retained its effect, thereby deeming Berthun unfit to hold a licence.

Ultimately, the court granted the application for an extension of time to review the decision, confirming that the review would proceed separately from another application. The court also confirmed the decision to reject Berthun's application for a weapon licence, emphasising that the domestic violence order, despite its revocation, had the legal effect of deeming him unfit to hold a licence under the Weapons Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application by Anthony William Berthun for an extension of time to review the decision of the Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing made 10 January 2017 is granted.

2. Review of the decision made 10 January 2017 will remain a separate proceeding to be heard together with application GAR232-17.

3. Evidence and submissions in one proceeding will be evidence and submissions in the other proceeding.

4. Application GAR232-17 is dismissed.

5. The decision to reject the application by Anthony William Berthun for a Weapons Licence made

10 January 2017 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

If the First Decision is not overturned and I find that the 20 May 2015 order did enliven s 10B(2)(b), it would then be appropriate to dismiss the application on the grounds submitted by the respondent.Application to Review the First DecisionWhat is the status and effect of the Protection Order made 20 May 2015?Respondent’s submissions The respondent submits that the 20 May 2015 order had effect, for the purposes of s 10B(2)(b) of the Weapons Act, at all relevant times, including in April 2017. Revocation of the order on 31 August 2015 is said not to impact on the operation of s 10B(2)(b) of the Weapons Act. The respondent’s position is that the only means by which the 20 May 2015 order can be deprived of force for the purposes of s 10B(2)(b) is if the order is successfully appealed and discharged in accordance with s 34AA of the Weapons Act and s 169 of the DVFP Act. As there was no appeal, the order enlivened the deeming provision of s 10B(2)(b) resulting in Mr Berthun being held not to be a fit and proper person to hold a firearms’ licence. That was the reason for the First Decision, now being reviewed. The respondent refers to the following principles and statutory provisions:(a)when a domestic violence order is made, a person no longer has the right to hold a weapons licence;[3](b)once a person is deemed not a fit and proper person there is no discretion in the authorised officer to issue a licence;[4](c)an order is effective as soon as it is pronounced in open court. If a Magistrate made an error within his jurisdiction, in the absence of any appeal the order made takes effect according to its terms;[5](d)by s 96 of the DFVP Act a domestic violence order takes effect on the day it is made;(e)the Justices Act provides for proceedings to be reopened and orders rectified in specified circumstances, but it contains no provision which affects the validity of an order previously made until it is set aside and does not entitle a Magistrate to declare the original order invalid or void. The DFVP Act does not contain a provision that non-compliance with the requirement for service of notification of a hearing date will render the order invalid or a nullity;[6](f)by s 187 of the DFVP Act failure to comply with notice requirements in relation to an adjourned hearing does not invalidate or otherwise affect a domestic violence order.[3]Urquhart v Queensland Police Weapons Licensing Branch [2011] QCAT 023, [21].[4]Commissioner of Police Service v Ryle Rockhampton District Court D23/2004 at para 18 and 19; Winters v Cavanagh delivered 20 December 2004 at p. 6.[5]Peacock v Crowley (Unreported, District Court Appeal 1573/98, McGill DCJ, 20 May 1998), p 8 and p10; Roesch v Queensland Police Service, Weapons Licensing Branch [2013] QCAT 717, [15]-[17].[6]Roesch v Queensland Police Service, Weapons Licensing Branch [2013] QCAT 717, [20]. The respondent submits:(a)the 20 May 2015 order was made as a full, not temporary order. Any subsequent orders are separate to the original order;(b)the Magistrates court regardless of the intent, simply revoked the protection order. The DFVP Act does not provide any ability under the legislation to render an order void or to retrospectively consider that the order is temporary for the purposes of the Weapons Act;(c)review of the decision is not the forum for determination as to the appropriateness of the 20 May 2015 order, that is a matter for the appellate court;(d)s 142 of the Justices Act has no application to the issue of a protection order. The DFVP Act clearly provides the court with ability to hear and make orders in the absence of the respondent. There are no provisions for delaying the making of an order or holding the effect of an order until the respondent attends court;(e)S 142 of the Justices Act is inconsistent with s 39 and s 187 of the DFVP Act in relation to ex parte hearings. By s 143 of the DFVP Act, that Act takes precedence;(f)there is no evidence that the Magistrate intended to rescind any orders so as to affect the deeming provisions of the Weapons Act;(g)the subsequent revocation of the order in August 2015 has no effect on the deeming effect of the original order as the applicant has failed to have the order discharged pursuant to s 34AA of the Weapons Act;(h)there is no power within either the DFVP Act or the Justices Act which allows the Court to act retrospectively in relation to a protection order.Applicant’s submissions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.