Berthelsen v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Berthelsen & Anor v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2018] QCAT 400

PARTIES:

KAILEN BERTHELSEN
(first applicant)
IDC DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
(second applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR110-15

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

26 November 2018

HEARING DATE:

24 October 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Howe

ORDERS:

The decisions of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission of 13 July 2015 to cancel the licences of the applicants are set aside.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS – LICENCES AND REGISTRATION – OTHER MATTERS – where licensee made false declarations about prior criminal convictions – where individual and corporate licences cancelled – where application for review dismissed but set aside on appeal – where second review proceedings – where 10 year criminal rehabilitation period occurred prior to second review – where making false declarations remain relevant however – where contractor’s carelessness raised as an issue of concern – where additional issues raised about the contractor’s fitness from material relied on by contractor – where late payment of suppliers and other contractors – where late payment of insurance premiums – where contractor completed Commissioner for Declarations course

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 31, s 32(1)(g), s 32AA(1)(d), s 48(1)
Criminal Law (Rehabilitation Of Offenders) Act 1986 (Qld), s 9

Alford v Auctioneers and Agents Committee [2002] QDC 130
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond [1990] HCA 33; (1990) 170 CLR 321
Hughes & Vale Pty Ltd v New South Wales (No 2) [1955] HCA 28; (1955) 93 CLR 127
Laidlaw v Queensland Building Services Authority [2010] QCAT 70
QBCC v Bloomfield [2015] QCATA 19

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicants:

S Taylor, instructed by Crouch and Lindon

Respondent:

M Robinson, solicitor of Robinson Locke Litigation Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 13 July 2015 the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (‘QBCC’) cancelled Mr Berthelsen’s contractor’s licence on the basis that he was not a fit and proper person to hold a licence. On that same day QBCC also cancelled the corporate contractor’s licence of IDC Developments Pty Ltd (‘IDC’) of which Mr Berthelsen was director and nominee.

  2. Mr Berthelsen applied to the Tribunal to review both of those decisions. The review hearing (the first hearing) was conducted in Bundaberg on 27 April 2016 but the application dismissed.

  3. Mr Berthelsen successfully appealed that decision to the Appeal Tribunal. The Appeal Tribunal ordered his application for review be returned to the Tribunal for reconsideration. That reconsideration is the matter presently before the Tribunal (the second hearing).

    Background

  4. On 12 November 2013 Mr Berthelsen lodged an application with the QBCC for a contractor’s licence in a number of classes. In the application he declared ‘no’ to a question asking whether he had been convicted of any criminal offence (excluding traffic offences) within the last 10 years.

  5. With respect to his company IDC, in May 2014 he applied for a corporate contractor’s licence and similarly answered no to a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Berthelsen v Queensland Building and Construction Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 400
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Berthelsen applied for review of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission’s decision to cancel his licence. The Commission had cancelled the licences on the basis that Mr Berthelsen had knowingly provided false or misleading information when making his declarations for the purpose of obtaining licences. The Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) requires that a person must be fit and proper to hold a contractor’s licence. The Commission contended that Mr Berthelsen was not fit and proper to hold a contractor’s licence on the basis that he was careless. Mr Berthelsen argued that he was fit and proper to hold a contractor’s licence. The Court considered that there was no evidence of intent to mislead and that the false declarations had been made some years ago. The Court found that the evidence of carelessness relied on by the Commission was not sufficient to establish that Mr Berthelsen was not fit and proper to hold a contractor’s licence. The decision of the Commission to cancel the licences was set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decisions of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission of 13 July 2015 to cancel the licences of the applicants are set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Berthelsen successfully appealed that decision to the Appeal Tribunal. The Appeal Tribunal ordered his application for review be returned to the Tribunal for reconsideration. That reconsideration is the matter presently before the Tribunal (the second hearing).Background On 12 November 2013 Mr Berthelsen lodged an application with the QBCC for a contractor’s licence in a number of classes. In the application he declared ‘no’ to a question asking whether he had been convicted of any criminal offence (excluding traffic offences) within the last 10 years. With respect to his company IDC, in May 2014 he applied for a corporate contractor’s licence and similarly answered no to a question whether any director, office holder, major shareholder, nominee or person of influence had been convicted of any criminal offence within the last 10 years. On 24 December 2013 Mr Berthelsen was granted the additional licence class of Builder – Low Rise at Site Supervisor grade and on 13 November 2014 he was approved to change his existing contractor’s grade licence class to Nominee Supervisor grade. In fact, contrary to the declarations made, he had been convicted in the District Court at Bundaberg on 26 June 2008 of various offences and been sentenced to 9 months imprisonment wholly suspended for an operational period of two years. QBCC became aware of the false declarations. QBCC informed Mr Berthelsen it proposed to cancel his licenses on the basis that he was not a fit and proper person to hold them because he knowingly provided false or misleading information when making his declarations for the purpose of obtaining licenses. Despite his representations, Mr Berthelsen’s licences were cancelled by QBCC. He then brought his application for review in the Tribunal. Additional Issues At the first hearing a number of additional issues arose consequent on material presented by Mr Berthelsen. QBCC submitted this new material supported their submission that he was not a fit and proper person to hold a contractor’s licence (nor IDC, with him as director or nominee). Similarly at the second hearing QBCC say Mr Berthelsen has supplied further material which raises further issues about his fitness.The Entitlement to a Licence – The Statutory Scheme Section 31 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) (‘QBCC Act’) provides:(1) A person (not being a company) is entitled to a contractor’s licence if the commission is, on application by that person, satisfied that—(a) the applicant is a fit and proper person to hold the licence;…(2) A company is entitled to a contractor’s licence if the commission is satisfied, on application by that company for a licence, that—(a) the directors, secretary and influential persons for the company are fit and proper persons to exercise control or influence over a company that holds a contractor’s licence; …(3) In deciding whether a particular person is a fit and proper person to hold a contractor’s licence or to exercise control or influence over a company that holds a contractor’s licence, the commission may have regard to—(a) commercial and other dealings in which that person has been involved and the standard of honesty and integrity demonstrated in those dealings; and(b) any failure by that person to carry out commercial or statutory obligations and the reasons for the failure; and…(ca) if the person is an enforcement debtor under an enforcement order for an infringement notice offence for this Act—whether the person has taken steps under the State Penalties Enforcement Act 1999 to discharge the amount stated in the enforcement order; and(d) any other relevant factor.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Amongst ‘other relevant factors’ appropriately to be considered will be the purpose and objects of the QBCC Act which will determine the scope and context of how someone is a fit and proper person to be a contractor. The purpose and objects of the QBCC Act includes the regulation of the building industry to ensure the maintenance of proper standards in the industry and achieving a reasonable balance between the interests of building contractors and consumers.[8] [8]QBCC Act, s 3.The Evidence at the First hearing The appeal Tribunal set aside the decision of the Tribunal made at the first hearing and ordered that the proceeding be reconsidered with the possibility of additional evidence being led. Reconsideration requires consideration of the evidence given at the first hearing and any additional evidence or material produced at the second hearing. At the first hearing Mr Berthelsen admitted he had made a mistake completing the declaration in his applications to the QBCC. He said it was not a case of forgetting about the convictions. He believed at the time that he had no convictions recorded against him.[9] He said the same thing at various times during cross examination and was consistent in that stance.[10][9]T1-30 L1-10 (similar evidence was given concerning the IDS declaration T1-31 L44).[10]T1-30 L1-45; T1-31 L40-45; T1-53 L30; T1-62 L1-15. He admitted he made similar false declarations about his convictions in his Passport and Visa applications but similarly said he believed at the time that he had no recorded convictions. He committed an offence when he failed to pay a building contract insurance premium, but he said it was his first contract as principal and he was not aware that it was compulsory to pay insurance. He said he hadn’t been taught that in any training he had done up to that point in time.[11][11]T1-33 L6. In consequence he had been issued with an infringement notice. That had been in January 2015, the same month that his pregnant wife found out she would not be delivering a healthy child. His wife required surgery and then four weeks later emergency surgery. That news, he said, had devastated both of them and his failure to pay was simply an oversight. This had been a very difficult time. He had instructed someone else to manage things whilst he and his wife took time off.[12][12]T1-33 L29-31. He said he paid the fine but through SPER. At the time he had not been aware that SPER paid out funds on a first-in first-out basis which meant that the monies he was paying in went initially to pay for outstanding traffic fines. He said, however, as at the date of filing his statement of evidence in the Tribunal in the first hearing there was nothing outstanding on his SPER account meaning he had paid off the QBCC fine. Further he said the SPER payment system was an automatic process that came into being when he didn’t pay the fine on time. He said if it hadn’t automatically gone to SPER he would have paid it in full, if late.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, Mr Berthelsen said in January or February 2018 he had completed the technical content part of a Commissioner for Declarations course. He had not completed the practical matter of witnessing documents but had passed the technical part of the course. He also said he would supply the Tribunal with a copy of written evidence confirming that. Mr Robinson for QBCC said evidence about that would go a long way to showing redemption on his part.Consideration As previously stated, there is no issue raised about Mr Berthelsen having the necessary trade skills. Mr Berthelsen says he has learned a great deal over the period of the reviews before QCAT. He had not appreciated the significance of signing documents and the significance of making declarations as to the accuracy of information. However he maintains it is important to understand that at no time did he ever intend to mislead. I note his evidence about that was consistent throughout both review hearings. He believed at the time he made the relevant declarations that he had no convictions recorded against his name. He consistently acknowledged the guilty plea at the first hearing but believed no convictions had been recorded. There was no evidence of intent to mislead. I accept that at the time he made the declarations he held the belief asserted. As conceded by Mr Robinson, the false declarations was the linchpin upon which the issue of not being a fit and proper person to hold a contractor’s licence initially turned, and with the passage of time that issue has lost much of its significance. Those declarations were made respectively 4 and 5 years ago and the time to consider whether Mr Berthelsen is fit and proper to hold a contractor’s licence is at the present time. Mr Robinson for QBCC submits however that the evidence suggests Mr Berthelsen is careless. That lack of care extends to carelessness in swearing statutory declarations. His carelessness most recently extended to his adopting and declaring as true, inaccurate financial records. He showed a general preparedness to ‘gloss’ over important documents and not be bothered reading them carefully.[19] It was only when inaccuracies were brought to his attention that he took steps to make corrections and to be accurate.[19]T1-59 L42. It is not entirely clear that there is one particular sense in which it is suggested Mr Berthelsen is careless. There are different ways of being careless. There is impulsiveness. There is a careless disregard of consequences. There is lack of thought brought to bear about an issue that most people would give some considered thought to. What must be necessary for carelessness to disqualify Mr Berthelsen from being a fit and proper person to be a contractor must, one would think, be such as to show a habit of carelessness. Most of the issues now suggested to be evidence against his being a fit and proper person are not matters of great significance taken individually. Mr Taylor for Mr Berthelsen submits it is not sufficient to find someone not fit and proper simply because they lack care and attention to detail. But that must depend surely on the extent to which and if lack of care and attention affects a contractor’s ability to perform the work required and expected of a contractor.