Berry v Police No. Scgrg-99-353 Judgment No. S201

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

BERRY v POLICE
[1999] SASC 201

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal

  1. PERRY J. (ex tempore) The appellant appeals against the sentences imposed upon him in the Magistrates Court sitting at Christies Beach following his plea of guilty to a charge that on the 28 November 1998 at Victor Harbor he assaulted a young man contrary to s39(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935.

  2. At the same time, the appellant was charged with breach of a bond upon which a three month term of imprisonment for an earlier assault charge had been suspended, the period of the bond being two years.

  3. The breach of the bond which was alleged was that although he had seen through the two years without further offending he had completed only 80 out of 120 hours of community service.

  4. The magistrate, on taking the plea of guilty to the assault charge, imposed a sentence of eight months' imprisonment with respect to that, after intimating that if it were not for the plea of guilty a sentence of some 12 months might have been appropriate.

  5. He declined to exercise his discretion to excuse the breach of the bond, and he activated the suspended term of imprisonment, but he reduced it to one month.

  6. This meant that the overall head sentence became nine months.

  7. The appellant advanced three grounds of appeal in the notice of appeal, namely, that the learned special magistrate ought to have excused the breach of bond and extended the time within which the community service was to be performed; that the term of imprisonment imposed with respect to the charge of assault was in all the circumstances manifestly excessive; and that in any event, the learned sentencing magistrate should have exercised his discretion to suspend the term of imprisonment which was ordered.

  8. The appellant is a 30 year old man.  The circumstances of the assault charge are summarised in the affidavit of the police prosecutor, Mr Marsh, who appeared in the court below.  According to his affidavit, he put to the learned sentencing magistrate that the victim was 17 years of age.  He was walking along Hill Street at Victor Harbor at about 2.00 am on the morning in question.  He was with another young man called Damien Belle.  They both were talking loudly.

  9. He was stopped by a group of males who stated that they were sick of people behaving like that, but they kept on walking, although Belle apparently kept yelling at the other group.

  10. At some point Belle left the roadway to urinate.  The victim then kept walking and was approached by a person who turns out to be the appellant.  He said something which the victim could not recall, and then struck the victim in the right eye causing him to fall to the ground.  He got up and walked to his sister's place and suffered headaches and numbness as a result of the punch.

  11. In the victim impact statement which was put before the learned sentencing magistrate, some more detail…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Berry v Police No. Scgrg-99-353 Judgment No. S201 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Berry v Police involved the appellant appealing the sentences imposed upon him in the Magistrates Court at Christies Beach. The appellant had pleaded guilty to assaulting a young man, an offence contrary to section 39(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935. Additionally, the appellant had breached a bond condition, having failed to complete the required hours of community service. The primary legal issues for the court to address were whether the breach of the bond should have been excused and if the sentence imposed for the assault was manifestly excessive. The court also had to consider whether the term of imprisonment should have been suspended.

The court considered the appellant's arguments that the breach of the bond should have been excused and that the term of imprisonment for the assault was excessive. The magistrate had declined to excuse the breach of the bond and activated the suspended term of imprisonment, resulting in an overall sentence of nine months. The appellant's counsel argued that the magistrate had erred in not considering the circumstances of the breach against the consequences of the activation of the sentence. The court agreed that the magistrate had misapplied the law by not weighing the breach against the potential consequences. However, the court found that the breach could not be excused entirely due to the need to maintain the integrity of the sentencing process. Regarding the assault, the court determined that the sentence of eight months was too high, taking into account the degree of provocation and the mitigating circumstances. The court reduced the sentence to five months, resulting in a total head sentence of six months.

The court allowed the appeal and reduced the sentence of imprisonment to six months, reflecting the appropriate balance between punishment and the circumstances of the case. This decision underscores the importance of correctly applying the law in sentencing, particularly in relation to breaches of community service orders and the proportionality of sentences imposed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRY J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRY J