BERRY v POLICE
[SASC] 1999 168
Magistrates Appeal
Debelle J (ex tempore)
This is an appeal against sentence.
On 14 January 1999, at the Magistrates Court at Mount Gambier, the appellant pleaded guilty to breaking and entering a building occupied by the Australian Red Cross Society in stealing goods to the value of some $790. He was sentenced to a period of four months imprisonment. The appellant has appealed against the sentence. The only ground of appeal is that the magistrate ought to have suspended the sentence.
There were some aggravating features of the offending. The stolen property has not been recovered. It included a video cassette recorder. In addition, in the course of breaking into the premises occupied by the Red Cross Society, some $1,000 worth of damage was caused. When arrested, the appellant sought to minimise his involvement in the offence. He suggested that he was only keeping watch for an accomplice. Later inspection of the premises showed his fingerprints were on a cash box and on a filing cabinet in the premises.
The appellant was aged 21 years when sentenced. He has a number of offences in the Northern Territory as a juvenile between 1990 and 1994. Many are for the unlawful entry into buildings and for stealing. He has not, however, offended since May 1994. The last sentence ordered in the Northern Territory was for a period of imprisonment for 15 months for offences of unlawful entry and stealing. The sentence was suspended upon the appellant entering into a bond to be of good behaviour for a period of two years. He has complied with the terms of that bond.
The appellant has had a most unfortunate childhood and has been offending since he was about 13. Although his initial offending was as a result of what is said to be emotional deprivation, later offending was for the purpose of serving his habit of smoking marijuana very heavily. He has submitted to a drug rehabilitation program and vocational training. The appellant's educational level is low. It is said that he is almost illiterate. The appellant came to Mount Gambier some 13 months ago. He obtained some casual employment. He is now unemployed and in receipt of unemployment benefits. He lives with a woman he proposes to marry. He is undertaking some training for the purpose of obtaining a licence to drive a forklift. He believes that there are some prospects of employment as a forklift driver.
It is apparent from the sentencing remarks that the magistrate believed some steps should be taken to assist the rehabilitation of the appellant. The course taken was to have regard to the usual penalty for a first offence of breaking and entering and then substantially to reduce that period of imprisonment. The magistrate said:
“The defendant will be sentenced to four months imprisonment forthwith. The prospects for his rehabilitation are taken into account in the reduction of two months from the suggested six months head sentence in Halse (albeit that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BERRY v POLICE No. SCCRM-99-271 Judgment No. S168 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] SASC 168
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the magistrate misapplied the sentencing principles by not first considering whether there was an alternative to imprisonment and subsequently deciding whether to suspend the sentence. The court found that the magistrate's approach did not follow the recommended sequence, which requires first considering an appropriate alternative to imprisonment and then, if imprisonment is necessary, deciding on its duration and whether it should be suspended. Despite the aggravating factors, the court considered Berry's prospects for rehabilitation, his efforts to reform, and the potential benefits of a suspended sentence in encouraging rehabilitation.
The court found that the magistrate misapplied the sentencing principles by not adequately considering the alternative to imprisonment. Berry, despite his criminal history, had not offended for several years and had taken steps towards rehabilitation. The court concluded that a suspended sentence would be more appropriate, providing Berry with an opportunity to demonstrate his capacity for rehabilitation. The appeal was allowed, and the sentence was varied to a nine-month imprisonment, suspended for three years, subject to conditions including a bond to be of good behaviour, payment of $1,000 in restitution, and attendance to apologise to the Red Cross Society.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi