Benzlaw & Assoc P/L v Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Benzlaw & Assoc P/L v Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd & Ors [2007] QSC 009

PARTIES:

BENZLAW & ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ACN 071 381 452
(plaintiff)
v
MEDI-AID CENTRE FOUNDATION LTD ACN 001 313 853
(first defendant)
2040 LOGAN ROAD PTY LTD ACN 112 994 242
(second defendant)
148 BRUNSWICK STREET PTY LTD ACN 117 914 664
(third defendant)

FILE NO/S:

10416 of 2006

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

17 January 2007

DELIVERED AT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

2 October 2006

JUDGE:

Douglas J

ORDER:

[1] Order that the plaintiff provide security for the first defendant’s costs in the amount of $100,000 on or before 17 March 2007;

[2] Order that the plaintiff provide security for the second and third defendants’ costs in the amount of $100,000 on or before 17 March 2007; 

[3] Dismiss the plaintiff’s application for security for costs against the second defendant;

[4] Order that the plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the defendants’ applications, to be assessed;

[5] Order that the plaintiff pay the second defendant its costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s application for security against the second defendant.

CATCHWORDS:

CORPORATIONS – LEGAL CAPACITY AND RELATIONS WITH OUTSIDERS – EXTERNAL LITIGATION PROCEDURE – COSTS – SECURITY FOR COSTS – GENERALLY – where both plaintiff and defendants are seeking security for costs – where plaintiff’s litigation funded by third party – where plaintiff impecunious - where counterclaim by second defendant against which security is sought is a defensive manoeuvre -  whether plaintiff should be ordered to pay security for costs, and in what amount – whether second defendant should be ordered to pay security for costs, and in what amount

Baygol Pty Ltd v Huntsman Chemical Co Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1248, applied
Fiduciary Ltd v Morningstar Research Pty Ltd (2004) 208 ALR 564, cited
Maronis Holdings Ltd v Nippon Credit Australia Ltd [2000] NSWSC 994, cited
Naamlooze v The Bank of England [1948] 1 All ER 465, applied

COUNSEL:

C D Coulsen for the applicant
P Dunning SC with N Ferrett for the first defendant
M M Stewart SC with S Monks for the second and third defendants

SOLICITORS:

Morgan Conley for the plaintiff
Ffrench Commercial Lawyers for the first defendant
Calavitti Lillas for the second and third defendants

  1. These are applications for security for costs brought by all three defendants against the plaintiff and a cross application by the plaintiff against the second defendant also for security for costs in respect of a counterclaim by that defendant. 

Background facts

  1. The plaintiff owns an office building in Brisbane.  It had borrowed money from the first defendant but was in default of its loan. The amount said to be owing by 3 December 2005 was $12,279,608.26. On 29 November 2005 the first defendant assigned its mortgage to the second defendant and on 27 January 2006 the second defendant exercised its power of sale…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Benzlaw & Assoc P/L v Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] QSC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Benzlaw & Assoc P/L commenced proceedings against Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd and others, seeking damages for alleged breaches of contract. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where both the plaintiff and the defendants sought security for costs. The plaintiff's litigation was funded by a third party, and the plaintiff was considered impecunious. The second defendant filed a counterclaim against the plaintiff, which was seen as a defensive tactic. The court was required to decide whether the plaintiff should be ordered to provide security for the defendants' costs and, if so, in what amount. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the second defendant should be ordered to provide security for costs and, if so, in what amount.

The court considered the plaintiff's impecuniosity and the nature of the second defendant's counterclaim as a defensive manoeuvre. It was determined that the plaintiff should provide security for the first and third defendants' costs in the amount of $100,000 each, to be paid by a specified date. The court dismissed the plaintiff's application for security for costs against the second defendant, given the nature of the counterclaim. The plaintiff was also ordered to pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to the defendants' applications, as well as the second defendant's costs of and incidental to the plaintiff's application for security against it.

In conclusion, the court ordered the plaintiff to provide security for the first and third defendants' costs in the amount of $100,000 each by a specified date. The plaintiff's application for security for costs against the second defendant was dismissed, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to the defendants' applications, as well as the second defendant's costs of and incidental to the plaintiff's application for security against it.

Orders

Orders of the court

[1] Order that the plaintiff provide security for the first defendant’s costs in the amount of $100,000 on or before 17 March 2007;

[2] Order that the plaintiff provide security for the second and third defendants’ costs in the amount of $100,000 on or before 17 March 2007;

[3] Dismiss the plaintiff’s application for security for costs against the second defendant;

[4] Order that the plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the defendants’ applications, to be assessed;

[5] Order that the plaintiff pay the second defendant its costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s application for security against the second defendant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Benzlaw & Assoc P/L, the plaintiff, commenced legal proceedings against Medi-Aid Centre Foundation Ltd, the first defendant, as well as two other defendants, for alleged breaches of contract and other related claims. The plaintiff’s funding for the litigation was provided by a third party, and the plaintiff was considered impecunious. The second defendant filed a counterclaim against the plaintiff, which was characterised by the court as a defensive manoeuvre. Both parties subsequently sought security for costs, with the plaintiff applying for security against the second defendant and the defendants seeking security against the plaintiff.

The matter came before the court on the application for security for costs made by both the plaintiff and the defendants. Prior to this application, the plaintiff had already initiated proceedings against the defendants, leading to the counterclaim by the second defendant. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff should be ordered to pay security for costs and, if so, the appropriate amount. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether the second defendant should be ordered to pay security for costs, and if so, the amount. This application was heard after the initial filings and pleadings in the main proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff should be ordered to pay security for the first defendant’s costs, and in what amount?
2. Whether the plaintiff should be ordered to pay security for the second and third defendants’ costs, and in what amount?
3. Whether the plaintiff’s application for security for costs against the second defendant should be dismissed?
4. Whether the plaintiff should be ordered to pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the defendants’ applications?
5. Whether the plaintiff should be ordered to pay the second defendant’s costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s application for security against the second defendant?

Held
1. The plaintiff should be ordered to pay security for the first defendant’s costs, and the amount should be $100,000.
2. The plaintiff should be ordered to pay security for the second and third defendants’ costs, and the amount should be $100,000.
3. The plaintiff’s application for security for costs against the second defendant should be dismissed.
4. The plaintiff should be ordered to pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the defendants’ applications.
5. The plaintiff should be ordered to pay the second defendant its costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s application for security against the second defendant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the plaintiff’s application for security for costs against the defendants and the defendants’ applications for security for costs against the plaintiff. The plaintiff, funded by a third party, was impecunious and the litigation was considered to have merit. The court noted the second defendant’s counterclaim was a defensive maneuver. In determining the appropriate amount of security for costs, the court considered the financial circumstances of the plaintiff and the prospects of success of the respective parties. The court held that the plaintiff should provide security for the first and third defendants’ costs in the amount of $100,000 each, reflecting the merits and complexity of the case. The plaintiff’s application for security against the second defendant was dismissed as the second defendant’s counterclaim was deemed a defensive maneuver. The court ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the defendants’ applications, and the second defendant’s costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s application for security against it. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases where the plaintiff is impecunious and funded by a third party, the court will require the plaintiff to provide security for costs against the defendants, with the amount set based on the merits and complexity of the case, while considering defensive maneuvers by defendants in the context of security for costs applications.