Benson v Department of Corrective Services, Chief Executive

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

THE SUPREME COURT  [2001] QSC 159

OF QUEENSLAND

BRISBANE  No S 734 of 2001

BETWEEN:

JAMES BENSON, SIMON BONTOFT, TRENT CARTER, BLAIR COOPER, MARK EASTLEY, KELLIE ELLIOT, RUSSELL FLOYD, SUE GILL, TRACEY GREEN, RUSSELL GROGIN, IAN HASTIE, NIGEL HAUSLER, CRAIG JONES STEPHEN   KENEALLY,   H   T   LAM,   TANIA   MASZAK, MALCOLM  McCULLOUGH, WENDY McFARLANE, LIZA McLANACHAN,  LINDY  MERTA,  JIM  MILLIOTIS,  BEN OWEN,   COLIN   PRIEST,   ROGER   SHOESMITH,   TONY STRUDWICK, CRAIG SUTCH, PHILIP ANTHONY TYLER, REGINALD WILLIAMS, and DARREN YOUNG.

Applicants

AND:

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIVE SERVICES

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

B.W. Ambrose J.

Delivered the fourteenth  day of May 2001

CATCHWORDS:     ADMINISTRATIVE   LAW-   Appeals   from   Administrative Authorities  -  Judicial  Review  Legislation-  Application  for dismissal of an application for review of decisions of Corrective Services relating to eligibility- whether the “change of date of the applicant’s eligibility for remission” by the Commission, offends an expectation that the applicants had, and/or whether it can be construed as punishing the applicants twice- whether s

207B of the Corrective Services Act 1988 (as amended) is invalid because it contradicts other legislation- whether s 207A and s

207B should be read together-

Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld); s 48(1)

Corrective Services Act 1988 (Qld); s 61; s 86; s 130; s 165; s

207A; s 207B

Corrective Services Act 2000 (Qld); s 75; s 76; s278

Criminal Code (Qld); s 16

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld); s 4; s 20; s 20C

Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld); s 180

2

General Steel Industries Inc v The Commissioner for Railways

(NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125.

McCasker v The Queensland Corrective Services Commission

[1998] 2 QdR 261

Counsel:  Mr TA Ryan for the applicants

Mr MD Hinson QC for the respondent

Solicitors:                   Russo & Coburn Solicitors for the applicants

Crown Solicitor for the respondent

Hearing Dates:           24 April 2001

[1] This is an application by the respondent (“Corrective Services”) pursuant to s 48(1) of the Judicial Review Act  1991 for the dismissal of an application for review of decisions of Corrective Services relating to eligibility of 19 prisoners, currently serving terms of imprisonment of various durations, which were imposed on various dates, prior to 24 November 2000 when the Corrective Services Act 1988 was amended by the insertion of ss 207A and 207B pursuant to s 278 of the Corrective Services Act 2000.

[2]     The Corrective Services Act 2000 was assented to on 24 November 2000 and s 278

of that Act became operational on that day.

[3]     The balance of the  Corrective Services Act  2000 will commence on a day to be fixed by proclamation. No such proclamation has yet been made.

[4] Under s 130(e) of the Corrective Services Act  1988 regulations may be made with respect to –

“(e)       the  granting  or  forfeiting  of  remission  of  sentences  of imprisonment;”

[5]     Under regulation 21 of the Corrective Services Regulation 1989, made pursuant to s

130 of the Corrective Services Act 1988, it is provided inter alia –

“(1)       A prisoner serving a sentence of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Benson v Department of Corrective Services, Chief Executive and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QSC 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Queensland, a group of prisoners led by James Benson challenged the decision of the Chief Executive of the Department of Corrective Services regarding their eligibility for remission of their prison sentences. The prisoners argued that the changes to the Corrective Services Act 1988, which were made effective on 24 November 2000, invalidated the new provisions and should not affect their eligibility for remission. The legal issues in this case were whether the changes to the remission eligibility date offended an expectation the prisoners had, whether it could be construed as punishing the prisoners twice, and whether s 207B of the Corrective Services Act 1988 was invalid because it contradicted other legislation. The Court considered the arguments presented by the applicants and the relevant legislation, including the Corrective Services Act 2000, and concluded that s 207B should be read independently of s 207A. The Court found that the changes to the remission eligibility date did not increase the length of the prisoners' sentences, nor did they constitute double punishment. Therefore, the Court dismissed the applications brought to review the decisions of the Chief Executive of the Department of Corrective Services.

The Court's reasoning was based on a detailed analysis of the relevant legislation, including the Corrective Services Act 1988, the Corrective Services Act 2000, and the Acts Interpretation Act 1954. The Court also considered the ministerial statements made prior to the passing of the Corrective Services Act 2000, which indicated the intention of the legislature to repeal legislation and regulations made under it, permitting remission of part of a sentence of imprisonment imposed in respect of all offences committed after the proclamation of the Corrective Services Act 2000. The Court found that the changes to the remission eligibility date were consistent with the legislative intent and did not infringe upon the prisoners' rights or privileges acquired under the previous legislation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established