Benjamin v Blundell

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
CITATION: Benjamin v Blundell [2010] NSWSC 31
HEARING DATE(S): 2, 4 February 2010
JURISDICTION: Equity
JUDGMENT OF: Gzell J
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 4 February 2010
DECISION: Orders made to vacate property and not to re-enter.
CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE - Possession of Property - failures to comply with writ of possession and writ of restitution in Common Law Division proceedings - Crown Solicitor's advice that contempt proceedings inappropriate as writs addressed to Sheriff and not to first defendant - whether order should be made in Equity Division proceedings to vacate property and not to re-enter without permission
PARTIES: Victor Hyman Benjamin (First Plaintiff)
Janet Shirley Fingret (Second Plaintiff)
V H Benjamin & Sons Pty Ltd (Third Plaintiff)
Victor Hyman Benjamin (Fourth Plaintiff)
Hamafam Pty Ltd (Fifth Plaintiff)
Melanie Jane Blundell (First Defendant)
Garo Ashikian (Second Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2009/00291383-1
COUNSEL: A Rogers (Plaintiffs)
SOLICITORS: Baccus Investments Ltd - In house Solicitors (Plaintiffs)


IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

GZELL J

THURSDAY 4 FEBRUARY 2010

2009/00291383-1 VICTOR HYMAN BENJAMIN & ORS v MELANIE JANE BLUNDELL & ANOR

EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT

1 The plaintiffs in the proceedings before me today seek an order that Melanie Jane Blundell vacate the property known as 660 Menangle Road, Douglas Park, New South Wales.

2 Similar relief is claimed against the second defendant, Garo Ashikian, but the plaintiffs have been unable to effect service upon him.

3 I am satisfied that Ms Blundell was served with this application. When the process server went to serve the documents on her she ran into the house and attempted to close the door. But the process server was able to drop the documents on the floor in the house in her presence at the same time saying: "That is your copy of the amended summons."

4 The matter has had a protracted history. On 22 September 2008, consent orders were filed in this court under which judgment for the plaintiffs for possession of the property was granted, and leave was granted to the plaintiffs to issue a writ of possession.

5 A writ of possession was issued on 14 November 2008. On 26 November 2008 the Sheriff’s Office gave notice to vacate by 12.30 pm on 17 December 2008 or eviction would proceed without further warning.

6 At about 12.15pm on 17 December 2008, Registrar Deacon informed the solicitors for the plaintiffs that the defendants were seeking a stay of execution of the writ. Counsel was retained and appeared before the Registrar who called on the matter at about 12.30pm. At approximately 1.45 pm the Registrar stayed execution of the writ until 12 January 2009, stating that he had no idea whether the Sheriff had executed the writ.

7 The Registrar and counsel were unaware that the Sheriff executed the writ at about 12.30pm on vacant premises.

8 That was to no avail as the defendants broke back into the house and retook possession.

9 On 27 February 2009 Fullerton J ordered that a writ…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Benjamin v Blundell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWSC 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Benjamin v Blundell involved a dispute over the possession of a property. The plaintiff, Benjamin, sought to enforce a writ of possession and a writ of restitution against the defendants, Blundell, in proceedings that began in the Common Law Division. However, the defendants failed to comply with these writs. The plaintiff then sought an order in the Equity Division to vacate the property and not to re-enter without permission. The Crown Solicitor advised that contempt proceedings were not appropriate as the writs were addressed to the Sheriff, not the first defendant.

The central legal issues revolved around whether the Equity Division had the jurisdiction to make an order compelling compliance with the writs and whether such an order was appropriate given the Crown Solicitor's advice. The court had to consider the nature of the writs, their addressees, and the applicable legal principles regarding contempt and enforcement of court orders. It also needed to assess whether the situation warranted an order under the Equity Division's inherent jurisdiction to prevent an abuse of the court's process.

The court found that, despite the Crown Solicitor's advice, the Equity Division did have the inherent jurisdiction to make an order compelling compliance with the writs. It held that the defendants' failure to comply with the writs constituted an abuse of the court's process. The court reasoned that the writs, while addressed to the Sheriff, were intended to effectuate the court's judgment, and non-compliance with the writs was effectively non-compliance with the court's order. Consequently, the court made the order sought by the plaintiff, directing the defendants to vacate the property and not to re-enter without permission.

In conclusion, the court granted the plaintiff's application and ordered the defendants to vacate the property and not to re-enter without permission. The decision underscores the Equity Division's inherent jurisdiction to prevent an abuse of the court's process, even when the writs themselves are addressed to the Sheriff rather than the party in default.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Benjamin v Blundell involves a dispute over the possession of a property. The proceedings began when the plaintiff, Benjamin, sought possession of the property against the defendant, Blundell, under the provisions of the Common Law Division. Benjamin obtained a writ of possession, and subsequently, a writ of restitution. Blundell failed to comply with both writs, leading to the current litigation. The writs were specifically addressed to the Sheriff, rather than directly to Blundell. The Crown Solicitor provided advice that contempt proceedings against Blundell would not be appropriate due to the nature of the writs. The matter now involves whether an order should be made in Equity Division proceedings requiring Blundell to vacate the property and refrain from re-entering without permission.

The case has proceeded through the Common Law Division where Benjamin initially obtained a writ of possession against Blundell for the property in question. Following Blundell's failure to comply with the writ of possession, Benjamin sought a writ of restitution. Again, Blundell did not comply with this writ. The matter then transitioned to the Equity Division where the question of whether an order should be made for Blundell to vacate the property and refrain from re-entering without permission is being determined. The Crown Solicitor's advice regarding the inappropriateness of contempt proceedings was also considered in this transition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the failures to comply with the writ of possession and writ of restitution justify an order in Equity Division proceedings for Blundell to vacate the property.
2. Whether an order should be made in Equity Division proceedings to prevent Blundell from re-entering the property without permission.
3. Whether the Crown Solicitor's advice that contempt proceedings are inappropriate due to the writs being addressed to the Sheriff and not to Blundell impacts the court's decision on the appropriate remedies.

Held
1. The court concluded that the failures to comply with the writ of possession and writ of restitution justify an order in Equity Division proceedings for Blundell to vacate the property.
2. The court decided that an order should be made in Equity Division proceedings to prevent Blundell from re-entering the property without permission.
3. The court determined that the Crown Solicitor's advice that contempt proceedings are inappropriate due to the writs being addressed to the Sheriff and not to Blundell does not impact the court's decision on the appropriate remedies.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the failures to comply with the writ of possession and writ of restitution, which were intended to restore the property to the rightful owner. Despite the Crown Solicitor's advice that contempt proceedings were inappropriate because the writs were addressed to the Sheriff and not to Blundell, the court found that these failures warranted an order in Equity Division proceedings for Blundell to vacate the property. The court emphasised the importance of enforcing the rights of the property owner and ensuring that the writs were carried out as intended. Consequently, the court made an order to prevent Blundell from re-entering the property without permission, reinforcing the need to uphold the property rights established in the Common Law Division proceedings. The ratio decidendi of this case is that failures to comply with writs of possession and restitution in Common Law Division proceedings can justify orders in Equity Division proceedings to enforce the rights of the property owner, irrespective of the Crown Solicitor's advice on contempt proceedings.