Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd v Prichard

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd v Prichard [2021] QSC 179

PARTIES:

BENDIGO AND ADELAIDE BANK LTD
ACN 068 049 178

(plaintiff)

v
WAYNE FRANCIS PRICHARD

(defendant)

FILE NO:

BS 1999 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

6 August 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

23 June 2021

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

1.   The plaintiff recover as against the defendant possession of that piece or parcel of land described as Lot 1 on Crown Plan MRY31, situated in the County of Murray, Parish of Morer, being the whole of the land contained in Title Reference 17665081.

2.    The defendant’s counterclaim filed on 28 April 2021 is dismissed.

3.    The subpoena for production issued on 7 June 2021 upon the request of the defendant is set aside.

4.    The Court will hear from the parties further as to the amount of the monetary judgment, including the calculation of interest, and as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY – SUMMARY DISPOSAL – SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR PLAINTIFF OR APPLICANT – FOR DEBT OR LIQUIDATED DEMAND OR FOR POSSESSION OF LAND – where the plaintiff granted mortgage-secured loans to the defendant – where the defendant defaulted – where the plaintiff seeks recovery of unpaid sums of the loans and possession of the mortgaged property – where the defendant defends the claim on the basis that the plaintiff has no standing to enforce the instruments because the plaintiff has “securitised” them – whether the defendant has no real prospect of defending the claim and whether there is no need for a trial

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES – DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS – PRODUCTION AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS – GENERAL MATTERS – SUBPOENAS – where a subpoena for the production of documents was issued on the defendant’s request – where the subpoena was issued prior to the parties undertaking disclosure/discovery – where the subpoena refers to 20 categories of documents – where the plaintiff applies to have the subpoena set aside – whether the subpoena is an abuse of process because it is, in substance, a “fishing” expedition

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 292, r 293, r 416

McLean v Westpac Banking Corporation [2012] WASCA 152, cited

COUNSEL:

D E F Chesterman for the plaintiff
The defendant appeared on his own behalf

SOLICITORS:

Corrs Chambers Westgarth for the plaintiff
The defendant appeared on his own behalf

  1. The plaintiff applies for summary judgment on its claim against the defendant pursuant to r 292 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR) and on the defendant’s counterclaim pursuant to r 293. Pursuant to r 416, the plaintiff also applies for an order setting aside the subpoena for production issued on 7 June 2021 at the defendant’s request.

  2. At the hearing of these applications, the defendant, who represented himself, made an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd v Prichard and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 179
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd v Prichard involved a dispute where the bank sought to recover unpaid sums from the defendant, Wayne Prichard, and to obtain possession of mortgaged property following Prichard's default on mortgage-secured loans. Prichard defended the claim, alleging that the bank had securitised the loans and thus lacked standing to enforce them. The primary legal issues were whether Prichard had any real prospect of successfully defending the claim and if a trial was necessary. Additionally, the court had to decide whether a subpoena for document production issued by Prichard was an abuse of process.

The court found that Prichard's defence lacked merit as he had admitted owing the debt in his defence. The court concluded that Prichard had no real prospect of defending the claim and that there was no need for a trial. Regarding the subpoena, the court held that it was a fishing expedition and an abuse of process, as it was issued without proper discovery and referred to numerous document categories. Consequently, the subpoena was set aside.

The court ordered that the bank recover possession of the mortgaged property, dismissed Prichard's counterclaim, set aside the subpoena, and directed the parties to provide further information on the monetary judgment, including interest, and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff recover as against the defendant possession of that piece or parcel of land described as Lot 1 on Crown Plan MRY31, situated in the County of Murray, Parish of Morer, being the whole of the land contained in Title Reference 17665081.

2. The defendant’s counterclaim filed on 28 April 2021 is dismissed.

3. The subpoena for production issued on 7 June 2021 upon the request of the defendant is set aside.

4. The Court will hear from the parties further as to the amount of the monetary judgment, including the calculation of interest, and as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

To support his allegation that the plaintiff has sold its legal and equitable rights to a trust, the defendant has sought to obtain evidence by serving a notice to admit facts[6] and requesting that a subpoena be issued to the proper officer of the plaintiff.[7] [6]Notice to Admit Facts, CD-6.[7]Request for Subpoena, CD-10.Relevant background The relevant factual background is uncontentious and is set out in paragraphs 5 to 19 of the plaintiff’s written submissions:[8][8]Plaintiff’s Submissions (Application for Summary Judgment), filed by leave on 23 June 2021.“5.On or about 20 April 2013 the plaintiff, at the request of the defendant, provided him with a trading limit facility and two term loan facilities, as follows:[9][9]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 6, Exhibit MWC-1.(a)the trading limit facility was a $100,000 facility, repayable on 31 January 2014;[10][10]Referred to as the “First Loan Agreement” in the statement of claim and the Currey Affidavit.(b)one term loan facility was a $100,000 facility, with repayments to be made progressively over the 24 month term;[11][11]Referred to as the “Second Loan Agreement” in the statement of claim and the Currey Affidavit.(c)the other term loan facility was a $2,785,000 facility, with repayments to be made progressively over the 60 month term.[12][12]Referred to as the “Third Loan Agreement” in the statement of claim and the Currey Affidavit.6.As security for the loans, the defendant (relevantly) granted the plaintiff a registered land mortgage over rural property known as ‘Old Glenroy Station’.[13][13]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 10, Exhibit MWC-3.7.On or about 6 June 2014 the plaintiff, at the request of the defendant, increased the limit of the trading limit facility to $120,000, and extended the repayment date to 31 January 2015.[14][14]Currey Affidavit, paragraphs 7-9, Exhibit MWC-2.8.By no later than May 2015 the defendant had defaulted under the loan agreements and the mortgage by failing to pay amounts required to be paid when due.[15][15]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 11.9.On or about 5 August 2015 the plaintiff and the defendant entered into a written ‘Deed of Forbearance’, by which the defendant agreed:(a)by cl 5.4, to pay his debts to the plaintiff in full by 30 June 2016;(b)alternatively, if he was unable to repay those debts by that time, by cl 5.5 he was to hold an unconditional contract for the sale of ‘Old Glenroy Station’ on terms acceptable to the plaintiff.[16][16]Currey Affidavit, paragraphs 15-17, Exhibit MWC-4.10.Importantly, by cl 3.1 of the deed the defendant acknowledged and agreed that:(a)as at 3 July 2015 the plaintiff was entitled to recover pursuant to the facilities $3,060,721.00;(b)he was liable to the plaintiff for that debt; and(c)he was presently in default under the loan facilities and the mortgage security. By cl 3.2(c) the defendant also acknowledged and agreed that the mortgage secured the repayment of the debt.11.Pursuant to cl 5.1 of the Deed of Forbearance, on or about 10 September 2015 the defendant accepted the plaintiff’s offer to make available to him a replacement term loan facility.[17] The new loan facility replaced the two extant term loan facilities.[18][17]Currey Affidavit, paragraphs 18-21, Exhibit MWC-5.[18]Referred to as the “Fourth Loan Agreement” in the statement of claim and the Currey Affidavit.12.The defendant failed to comply with cll 5.4 and 5.5 of the Deed of Forbearance.[19][19]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 22.13.On or about 31 January 2017, the plaintiff and the defendant entered into a Supplementary Deed of Forbearance (Supplementary Deed of Forbearance).[20][20]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 12.14.Pursuant to cll 2.4 and 1.2 of the Supplementary Deed of Forbearance, the defendant agreed and undertook to repay his debts to the plaintiff in full by 31 August 2017.[21] The date for repayment was subsequently extended on 11 August 2017 to 30 September 2017.[22][21]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 25.[22]Currey Affidavit, paragraphs 26-27.15.Despite this, the defendant failed to repay his debts to the plaintiff by 30 September 2017.[23]16.The plaintiff has demanded repayment of the facilities on and from 10 April 2019.[24] A notice of intention to sell the mortgaged property was sent on 28 May 2019[25] and advertised on 30 May 2019.[26] A notice requiring the defendant to vacate by 15 February 2021 was also sent on 30 October 2020.[27]17.The defendant did not indicate he would comply with the notice to vacate, so on 2 December 2020 the plaintiff provided him with a notice that it would commence legal proceedings in the event he remained in possession of the mortgage property after 15 February 2021.[28] Again, the defendant ignored the notice.18.As at 19 February 2021, the defendant was (and remains) indebted to the plaintiff:(a)in the amount of $972,169.71 under the trading limit facility (as varied); and(b)the amount of $3,062,000.00 under the term loan facility.[29]19.He also remains in possession of ‘Old Glenroy Station’.[30]”[23]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 28.[24]Affidavit of Martin David Byres sworn 3 June 2021, CD-8, paragraph 6 (First Byres Affidavit).[25]First Byres Affidavit, paragraph 7.[26]First Byres Affidavit, paragraph 8.[27]First Byres Affidavit, paragraph 11.[28]First Byres Affidavit, paragraph 12.[29]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 33.[30]Currey Affidavit, paragraph 35. See also the affidavit of Wayne Francis Prichard affirmed 20 June 2021, CD-16, which states his address as ‘Old Glenroy Station’, even though he denies this in his defence.The plaintiff’s summary judgment application

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.