Ben-Menashe v Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
Reported Decision: 115 LGERA 181

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Ben-Menashe & Anor v Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council [2001] NSWLEC 168
PARTIES:

APPLICANTS:
Ilan & Linda Ben-Menashe

RESPONDENT:
Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 10179 of 2001
CORAM: Lloyd J
KEY ISSUES: Question of Law :- preliminary question of law - application for Torrens title subdivision - condition imposed requiring strata title subdivision - not a valid condition - not a consent to the application made
LEGISLATION CITED: Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 s 79 and s 80A
CASES CITED: Carr v The Minister for Land and Water Conservation (2000) 109 LGERA 175;
Mison v Randwick City Council (1991) 23 NSWLR 734
DATES OF HEARING: 06/07/2001
EX TEMPORE
JUDGMENT DATE :

07/06/2001
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:
APPLICANT:
Mr D T Miller (Barrister)
SOLICITORS:
PricewaterhouseCoopers Legal
RESPONDENT:
Ms L Finn (Solicitor)
SOLICITORS:
Abbott Tout


JUDGMENT:


1


.

IN THE LAND AND Matter No.: 10179 of 2001

ENVIRONMENT COURT Coram: Lloyd J

OF NEW SOUTH WALES Decision date: 6 July 2001


Ilan and Linda Ben-Menashe

Applicants

v

Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council

Respondent

EXTEMPORE JUDGMENT

1. HIS HONOUR: This is an appeal under s 97 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (“the EP&A Act”) against the imposition of a condition on the grant of development consent for a subdivision of land. The respondent, Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council (“the Council”) has raised, as a preliminary issue, the following question: whether s 80A of the EP&A Act permits the imposition of a condition that subdivision be by strata title, upon an application for Torrens title subdivision?


2. The facts may be briefly described. The Council had, in 1999, granted consent to the applicant to undertake a dual occupancy development at No. 41 Kissing Point Road, Turramurra. That development provided for the construction of a new dwelling at the rear of the allotment, such new dwelling to be serviced by a shared driveway. Drainage for the purpose of the new dwelling also was to be through the site of the driveway corridor. On 30 March 2000 the applicants lodged a development application for a subdivision of the land into two lots, namely a proposed lot 41 at the front and a proposed lot 42 at the rear. Lot 41 was to be burdened with the right of carriageway and an easement to drain water, both benefiting lot 42. The development application was accompanied by a plan of the subdivision which shows the two proposed allotments and the relevant proposed right of carriageway and proposed easement.


3. It is clear that the application was for a Torrens title subdivision. The plan of the proposed subdivision shows no common property, which one would expect to find if it were an application for a strata subdivision.


4. The Council approved the development application but imposed a condition, condition 6, which was in the following terms:

          The subdivision is approved under the provisions of the Strata Title. The driveway will be required to be shown in the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ben-Menashe v Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWLEC 168
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, the applicants, Ilan and Linda Ben-Menashe, appealed against the decision of the Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council to impose a condition on their development consent for a subdivision of land. The central issue before the court was whether the council had the authority under section 80A of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 to impose a condition requiring a strata title subdivision when the applicants had applied for a Torrens title subdivision.

The court examined the statutory framework and the specific circumstances of the case. The council had approved the applicants' development application but imposed a condition that the subdivision be approved under the provisions of the Strata Title, with the driveway being shown as "common property". This condition fundamentally altered the nature of the proposed subdivision from a Torrens title to a strata title, which the applicants argued was not a valid condition and did not constitute consent to their original application. The court referenced previous cases, such as Carr v The Minister for Land and Water Conservation and Mison v Randwick City Council, which established that a condition significantly altering the development from the one sought in the application would invalidate the consent.

The court concluded that the condition imposed by the council effectively converted the approved application into a different development, thereby failing to grant consent to the application as originally submitted. The court found that section 80A of the EP&A Act did not permit the council to impose such a condition, and thus there had been no valid consent to the development as applied for by the applicants. The court certified that the reasons for judgment were a true copy of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established