Catchwords: MIGRATION – Review of decision by Immigration Assessment Authority – whether Immigration Assessment Authority’s decision affected by jurisdictional error – whether the Immigration Assessment Authority considered all claims made by the applicant – whether the Immigration Assessment Authority’s credibility findings were open to it – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed.
Appeared in person with the assistance of Pashto interpreter
Solicitors for the Respondents:
Mr Siva Valliappan (DLA Piper)
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT SYDNEY
SYG 677 of 2019
BEM19
Applicant
And
MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS
First Respondent
IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
Second Respondent
EX TEMPORE
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
This is an application pursuant to s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) for judicial review of a decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (“the Authority”), dated 8 March 2019, affirming a decision of a delegate of the first respondent (“the Delegate”), made on 9 January 2019, refusing the applicant a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (“SHEV”).
The first respondent’s written submissions accurately summarise the applicant’s background, his claims in support of his SHEV and the Authority’s review and decision as follows:
“Background
2. The applicant is a citizen of Pakistan who arrived in Australia on 27 June 2013 by boat as an unauthorised maritime arrival.
3. On 7 April 2017, the applicant lodged an application for a SHEV on the basis of the following claims:
3.1 He was employed as an assistant officer in the Quetta district council and was in charge of ordering and supplying equipment and furniture for local schools. The applicant was close friends with his chief officer who was a Shia Muslim who also believed in child education and supported people in the community. The Taliban along with other militant groups such as the BLA and SSP did not like this and threatened him and his supervisor many times.
3.2 In June 2013, a Sunni militant group attacked a bus which killed and injured many students.…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bem19 v Minister for Home Affairs and more:
The applicant, a citizen of Pakistan, sought review of the Minister for Home Affairs' decision to refuse him a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (SHEV). The applicant claimed he feared persecution in Pakistan due to his former employment as an assistant officer in the Quetta district council, where he supplied equipment to local schools. He alleged that his work, and his friendship with his Shia Muslim supervisor, had attracted threats from Sunni militant groups, including the Taliban, the Sipah-e-Sahaba Pakistan (SSP), and the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA). He further claimed that a representative of a political party, allegedly ex-SSP, had visited his father at home, leading his family to relocate due to safety fears. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Authority) affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse the visa.
The court was required to determine whether the Authority erred in law by failing to provide adequate reasons for its decision, specifically concerning the applicant's claims of fear of harm from militant groups and the credibility of his account regarding threats to himself and his family. The central legal issue was whether the Authority's findings, particularly regarding the applicant's credibility and the likelihood of him facing harm upon return to Pakistan, were supported by adequate reasoning and the evidence before it.
Emmett J found that the Authority's reasons for rejecting the applicant's claims were inadequate. The Authority had noted inconsistencies in the applicant's evidence, including his initial claim of being an Afghan citizen and his varying accounts of when and why he left Pakistan. However, the Authority failed to adequately explain why it rejected specific aspects of the applicant's claims, such as the alleged visit from the ex-SSP representative and the subsequent relocation of his family. While the Authority accepted that the applicant's supervisor might have been threatened, it did not sufficiently explain why it did not accept that the applicant himself was threatened or that his family had a genuine reason to fear for their safety. The court concluded that the Authority's reasoning did not sufficiently address the material raised by the applicant, particularly concerning the new claims made to the Authority, and therefore did not provide adequate reasons for its decision.
The court ordered that the application for judicial review be granted, the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal be set aside, and the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for redetermination according to law.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
The first respondent’s written submissions accurately summarise the applicant’s background, his claims in support of his SHEV and the Authority’s review and decision as follows: “Background2. The applicant is a citizen of Pakistan who arrived in Australia on 27 June 2013 by boat as an unauthorised maritime arrival.3. On 7 April 2017, the applicant lodged an application for a SHEV on the basis of the following claims:3.1 He was employed as an assistant officer in the Quetta district council and was in charge of ordering and supplying equipment and furniture for local schools. The applicant was close friends with his chief officer who was a Shia Muslim who also believed in child education and supported people in the community. The Taliban along with other militant groups such as the BLA and SSP did not like this and threatened him and his supervisor many times.3.2 In June 2013, a Sunni militant group attacked a bus which killed and injured many students. Later in the day, the deputy commissioner whilst visiting victims at a hospital was killed along with a number of others in a bomb blast. Accordingly, the applicant made arrangements to leave for Australia as he fears he will be targeted by the SSP, that the authorities will not be able to effectively protect him and that he would be unable to relocate to another part of Pakistan.4. On 24 October 2018, the applicant attended an interview with the delegate in which he claimed that the deputy commissioner had warned him in April or May that he was under threat because of his position at the district council. Further, the applicant clarified that he had left Pakistan in May before the deputy commissioner was killed and that no members of his family have since or ever been threatened by Sunni militants.5. On 9 January 2019, a delegate of the Minister made a decision to refuse to grant the applicant the visa and so the matter was referred to the Authority for review. 6. On 29 January 2019, the applicant made submissions to the Authority which raised new claims, namely, that a representative of a political party who is ex-SSP, came to his home and threatened his father in relation to his whereabouts and that his family have now taken shelter with relatives in another city due to fears for their safety. 7. On 8 March 2019, the Authority affirmed the decision under review. The decision of the Authority8. The Authority was satisfied that the applicant had been told by his family that they had been approached by the representative and relocated as a consequence after the delegate's decision and that the new claims related to the continued interest in the applicant by Sunni militants which was material to his claimed inability to return to Pakistan. Accordingly, it considered there were exceptional circumstances to consider the new information. Further, it was satisfied there were exceptional circumstances to consider an updated DFAT report which was published after the date of the delegate's decision. 9. In relation to his employment, the Authority accepted that the applicant was a professional local government employee whose role was to order supplies and equipment. However, it did not consider he had demonstrated that he had a high profile role as his duties were simply administrative upon direction by his supervisor. It considered his overall account of his fear of harm to be inconsistent and lacking in detail. The Authority found that the applicant had provided an unreliable account of whether he had been threatened by militant groups, and if so, the identity of those groups. 10. On the basis of country information, the Authority accepted that the supervisor may have received threats as he could be considered to be a high profile Shia in Quetta. However, it noted that despite claiming to have been threatened by the Taliban, in his SHEV interview, the applicant confirmed that he and his family were never threatened by the SSP or other militant groups. In respect of the applicant's claim that his supervisor had warned him of threats being made to them, the Authority found that he had provided no detail as to the nature or source of the threats and noted that it was his own evidence that he had worked in his role for several years, raised a family and purchased property. Given his contradictory evidence and his claim to have never been personally threatened, the Authority did not accept that he was ever threatened or subject to any harm. 11. In respect of the BLA, the Authority noted that the applicant had not identified any particular threat made to him or provided a basis for why he fears harm from the BLA or any other Balochi separatist groups. In the absence of any further information, it did not accept he had ever faced harm from these sources. In relation to the death of the deputy commissioner, the Authority found that it was not apparent from the country information that he was specifically targeted but rather that he was killed in the course of visiting students who were the target of the attack. 12. The Authority found that the applicant was unable to explain different accounts for his reason for departing Pakistan, namely, whether he departed after the death of the deputy commissioner or whether he was warned of threats and told to be cautious. It considered on the basis of his varied and inconsistent evidence and vague explanations, that the applicant was never the subject of threats by militant groups in Pakistan or that he was in fear of his life at the time of his departure. Further, the Authority was satisfied that the applicant had departed Pakistan legally and that he now had a valid passport and therefore could return. 13. In consideration of the new claims raised, the Authority noted that the applicant had provided no country information about the Rah-e-Haq party or the person claimed to have visited his family. Further, it noted that he had not provided any information about the date of the claimed visit, why they were motivated to seek him out six years after he had left, the location of where his family now reside or the means of how they support themselves. The Authority did not place any weight on the photograph provided in support, noting that it was: not apparent who the people were in it or when it was taken; improbable that a relative would take a posed photograph of them being threatened; and, entirely plausible that he visited the community as part of his role as a party representative. 14. The Authority noted that the applicant in his SHEV interview had claimed that no members of his family had ever been threatened by Sunni militants, that he departed Pakistan unhindered and that his family had not changed address. It did not accept that Sunni militants would have developed an interest in the applicant 6 years later in 2019 or that he had provided any credible explanation as to why this would be the case. It considered it plausible that a member of a local political party had visited the family in 2019; however, it did not accept as credible that the person was seeking out the applicant or threatening him with harm. Accordingly, the Authority did not accept that his family had relocated and sought shelter with relatives. 15. The Authority noted that prior to his SHEV interview, the applicant's representative had requested that his application be advanced due to his health concerns and provided a letter from a psychologist who had seen the applicant twice for counselling. However, it found his responses to this issue at the interview to be vague, evasive and contradictory. The Authority then noted the applicant's evidence at his interview regarding his various employment in Australia and ability to send significant amounts of money to his family in Pakistan. In those circumstances, it was not satisfied the applicant had any ongoing health concerns diagnosed or otherwise that would preclude his return to Pakistan or that would prevent him from earning a living and supporting his family. 16. The Authority did not consider that the applicant or his family had faced discrimination or other mistreatment and noted that he had attended university, had held a secure job for several years and that he owns income deriving property. It considered that he would not be precluded from obtaining employment and that he would likely return to his family in Quetta with whom he had been in regular contact with. The Authority found that the applicant had embellished and fabricated elements of his evidence since his arrival in Australia in order to enhance his claim for protection. In addition to the inconsistencies it had already addressed, the Authority noted that the applicant had initially claimed to have been a citizen of Afghanistan but later recanted this and overall did not find him to be a credible witness. 17. Although the Authority accepted that Quetta continued to suffer incidents of sectarian and separatist violence, the gradual reduction in violence and the applicant's circumstances led it to conclude that he would only face a remote chance of being harmed as a consequence. It found that there was no information before it to believe that the applicant would face a real chance of harm on the basis of his Pashtun ethnicity, Sunni religion and beliefs, former employment, or association with prominent Shias. 18. For those reasons, the Authority was not satisfied the applicant had met either ss 36(2)(a) or (aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act) and accordingly affirmed the decision of the delegate to refuse to grant the applicant the visa.”(Footnotes omitted)