Bellingers Variety Pty Ltd v Ok Bazaar Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[2002] TASSC 4

CITATION:      Bellingers Variety Pty Ltd & Anor v OK Bazaar Pty Ltd [2002] TASSC 4

PARTIES:  BELLINGERS VARIETY PTY LTD (ACN 081 071 981)

BAZAARS TASMANIA PTY LTD (ACN 089 451 025)

v
  OK BAZAAR PTY LTD (ACN 080 101 926)

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  APPELLATE
FILE NO/S:  FCA 103/2001
DELIVERED ON:  7 February 2002
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATES:  6, 7 February 2002
JUDGMENT OF:  Underwood J

[Edited version of reasons for judgment delivered orally]

CATCHWORDS:

Appeal and New Trial - Tasmania - Time for appeal - Extension of time - Whether it is just between the parties to extend time.

Supreme Court Civil Procedure Act 1932 (Tas), s46.
Aust Dig Appeal and New Trial [387]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
           Applicants:  R E Hudson
           Respondent:  P W Tree
Solicitors:
           Applicants:  Butler McIntyre & Butler
           Respondent:  Dobson Mitchell & Allport

Judgment Number:  [2002] TASSC 4
Number of Paragraphs:  21

Serial No 4/2002
File No FCA 103/2001

BELLINGERS VARIETY PTY LTD and BAZAARS TASMANIA PTY LTD
v OK BAZAAR PTY LTD

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  UNDERWOOD J
(DELIVERED ORALLY)  7 February 2002

  1. This is an application to extend the time within which to file a notice of appeal to the Full Court from an order of a single judge.  The order which is the subject of this application was made by the learned Chief Justice on 2 July 2001.  It provides:

"1   Judgment be entered for the plaintiff in respect of the counterclaims of the first named and second named defendants, together with costs to be taxed.

2    The counterclaim of the first named and second named defendants be dismissed for want of prosecution.

3    The first named and second named defendants pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to the application to be taxed."

  1. The respondent and the applicants were engaged in commerce by dealing in variety goods.  Proceedings between the applicants and the respondent were commenced on 15 December 1999 by the filing of a writ.  The respondent claimed that by reason of a memorandum of understanding between it and the applicants, and their subsequent dealings, the applicants owe the respondent almost $400,000.  The statement of claim was met with a denial and a counterclaim based on alleged breaches of contract.

  1. On 19 June 2000, almost exactly 12 months before the order which is the subject of this application was made, the respondent's solicitor requested the applicants' solicitor to deliver particulars.  Three days after this request, some rudimentary particulars were delivered, but the respondent sought further particulars.  On 12 July 2000, an order was made by the Master that those particulars be delivered within seven days.

  1. From time to time between that date and 25 May 2001 when the respondent lodged the application to dismiss the counterclaim for want of prosecution (a period slightly in excess of 10 months), the applicants delivered some particulars but never fully complied with the order of the Master.  On two occasions during this period, the last being…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bellingers Variety Pty Ltd v Ok Bazaar Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] TASSC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bellingers Variety Pty Ltd and Bazaars Tasmania Pty Ltd v OK Bazaar Pty Ltd involved an application to extend the time within which to file a notice of appeal from an order made by a single judge. The order dismissed the counterclaim of the applicants and granted judgment to the respondent. The applicants, who were engaged in commerce with the respondent, failed to provide particulars as ordered, leading to the dismissal of their counterclaim. The application to extend the time for filing a notice of appeal was made six months out of time, but the respondent had been notified of the intention to apply for an extension. The court had to decide whether it was just between the parties to extend the time for lodging an appeal.

The court considered the length of the delay, the reason for it, and any prejudice suffered by the respondent due to the delay. Although the applicants' financial position might have weakened over the period of delay, the evidence was speculative and uncertain. The court found that the applicants would have opposed the strike-out application and filed an appeal in a timely manner if they had been properly informed. The court also rejected the argument that the applicants could commence fresh proceedings, stating that they were entitled to assert their appellate rights if it was just to extend the time. The court was satisfied that it was just to grant the application, considering the arguable case that the single judge erred in exercising their discretion.

The court made several orders to ensure the appeal would be dealt with expeditiously, including extending the time for filing and serving a notice of appeal, setting a deadline for the applicants to list their documents, and requiring the applicants to serve the notice of appointment to settle the contents of the appeal book on the respondent. The applicants were also ordered to pay the respondent's taxed costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bellingers Variety Pty Ltd and Bazaars Tasmania Pty Ltd were involved in a commercial dispute with Ok Bazaar Pty Ltd. The proceedings began on 15 December 1999 when Ok Bazaar filed a writ claiming almost $400,000 from Bellingers Variety and Bazaars Tasmania for alleged breaches of a memorandum of understanding and subsequent dealings. Bellingers Variety and Bazaars Tasmania denied the claim and filed a counterclaim based on alleged breaches of contract by Ok Bazaar.

Throughout the proceedings, Bellingers Variety and Bazaars Tasmania struggled to comply with orders to provide particulars. On 19 June 2000, Ok Bazaar's solicitor requested particulars from Bellingers Variety and Bazaars Tasmania, and an order was subsequently made on 12 July 2000 for the particulars to be delivered within seven days. Although some particulars were delivered, Bellingers Variety and Bazaars Tasmania never fully complied with the order. The Master extended the time for delivering particulars on two occasions, the last being 16 August 2000. Bellingers Variety and Bazaars Tasmania changed their solicitors in late December 2000.

On 25 May 2001, Ok Bazaar applied to dismiss the counterclaim for want of prosecution. Before the Chief Justice struck out the counterclaim on 2 July 2001, Bellingers Variety and Bazaars Tasmania had failed to furnish the outstanding particulars. The Chief Justice dismissed the counterclaim and ordered judgment for Ok Bazaar, stating that there had been a significant and inexcusable delay, making it unjust for the counterclaim to proceed. Bellingers Variety and Bazaars Tasmania subsequently applied for an extension of time to file a notice of appeal against the Chief Justice's order.

The matter before the Supreme Court of Tasmania was an application to extend the time within which to file a notice of appeal from an order made by the Chief Justice on 2 July 2001. The application was filed by Bellingers Variety Pty Ltd and Bazaars Tasmania Pty Ltd, the applicants, against OK Bazaar Pty Ltd, the respondent. The applicants sought an extension of time to appeal the order that dismissed their counterclaim for want of prosecution and ordered judgment in favour of the respondent, along with costs. The order was made after the applicants failed to comply with an earlier Master's order to deliver particulars within a specified time frame, despite multiple extensions and reminders. The applicants argued that they had an arguable case for appeal and that it was just to extend the time for appeal given the circumstances of the case, including the lack of prejudice to the respondent from the delay. The Court considered the length of delay, reasons for the delay, and any prejudice to the respondent, ultimately granting the extension on the terms set out in the judgment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether it is just between the parties to extend the time within which to file a notice of appeal.
2. If it is just to extend time, what should be the terms and conditions of such an extension.
3. Whether the applicants have an arguable case that the learned Chief Justice erred in making the order dismissing the counterclaim and ordering entry of judgment in favour of the respondent.
4. Whether the existence of alternative avenues for the applicants to prosecute their counterclaim affects the justness of extending the time for appeal.

Held
1. Whether it is just between the parties to extend the time within which to file a notice of appeal: The court concluded that it was just between the parties to grant the application for an extension of time.
2. If it is just to extend time, what should be the terms and conditions of such an extension: The court extended the time for filing and serving a notice of appeal until 14 February 2002, and set other terms and conditions for the appeal process.
3. Whether the applicants have an arguable case that the learned Chief Justice erred in making the order dismissing the counterclaim and ordering entry of judgment in favour of the respondent: The court concluded that the applicants do have an arguable case that the learned Chief Justice erred in making the order.
4. Whether the existence of alternative avenues for the applicants to prosecute their counterclaim affects the justness of extending the time for appeal: The court concluded that the existence of alternative avenues does not affect the justness of extending the time for appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered whether it was just between the parties to extend the time within which to file a notice of appeal. The application was filed approximately six months out of time, but the respondents had been given notice of the intention to apply about a month before the formal application was made. The Court held that the relevant matters to be considered included the length of delay, the reason for it, and any prejudice that the respondents may have suffered due to the delay. The Court noted that the delay was not excessively long, and the applicants had acted promptly and with due despatch after becoming aware of the making of the order. The Court also found that the existence of alternative avenues for the applicants to prosecute their counterclaim did not affect the justness of extending the time for appeal.

In relation to the terms and conditions of the extension, the Court ordered that the time for filing and serving a notice of appeal be extended until 14 February 2002. The applicants were also required to leave their list of documents for inclusion in the appeal books with the Principal Registrar on or before 15 February 2002 and to serve the notice of appointment to settle the contents of the appeal book on the respondent within 2 days of their receipt of it from the Registrar. The applicants were further ordered to pay the respondents' taxed costs of the application.

The Court found that the applicants had an arguable case that the learned Chief Justice erred in making the order dismissing the counterclaim and ordering entry of judgment in favour of the respondents. The Court noted that the period of delay in the delivery of the ordered particulars was less than a year in total, and some of the particulars were delivered from time to time during that period. The Court also noted that the time for delivery was judicially extended several times, and no self-executing interlocutory order was made during that 10-month period. The Court held that, in all these circumstances, there was an arguable case that general error occurred in the exercise of the discretion.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that, in determining whether it is just between the parties to extend the time within which to file a notice of appeal, the Court will consider the length of delay, the reason for it, and any prejudice that the respondents may have suffered due to the delay. The Court will also consider whether the applicants have an arguable case that the learned Chief Justice erred in making the order. The Court may grant an extension of time even if the applicants have alternative avenues to prosecute their counterclaim. The Court will also set terms and conditions for the extension to ensure that the appeal has a speedy disposition.