Bellamy and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

Bellamy and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2016] AATA 956 (29 November 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2016/1472

Re

Michael Bellamy

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Egon Fice, Senior Member

Date 29 November 2016
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision to cancel the Applicant’s Private Pilot Licence - Aeroplane Category (PPL) and in substitution determines that the Applicant’s PPL remains valid and must be treated as never having been cancelled.

[sgd]........................................................................

Egon Fice, Senior Member

CIVIL AVIATION - cancellation of license - private pilot licence - aeroplane category - whether failure by applicant in duty regarding safe operation of aircraft - whether applicant is a fit and proper person to hold private pilot license - conduct concerning crash during ground operations - classification of aircraft as amateur-built or experimental - issue of maintenance release - honesty and recognisance of applicant - whether conduct in respect of gyroplane aircraft relevant to conduct in respect of aeroplanes - decision set aside

Legislation

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) ss. 9A, 20A, 20AA, 20AB, 28, 29

Civil Aviation Regulations 1998 (Cth) regs. 2, 5.50, 35, 36, 42CB, 42ZC, 43, 229, 269

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) regs. 21.175

Civil Aviation Order 95.12.1 2006 (Cth) OO 3A, 4    

Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) s. 141.1

Cases

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321

Secondary Materials

Civil Aviation Safety Authority, 'Advisory Circular AC 21.10 (0) - Experimental Certificates' (October 2001)

Civil Aviation Safety Authority, 'Advisory Circular AC 21.4 (2) - Amateur-Built Experimental Aircraft - Certification' (September 2000)

Ian Morcombe, ‘Rotor Management’ in Close Call: Sport Aviation Special (Australian Sport Rotorcraft Association)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Egon Fice, Senior Member

29 November 2016

  1. Mr Michael Bellamy was the holder of a Private Pilot Licence – Aeroplane Category (PPL). That licence was issued to him on 13 August 2002. Mr Bellamy was also the registration holder of a McCulloch J2 gyroplane bearing the Australian registration mark VH-MBY.

  2. On 16 July 2010 Mr Bellamy was conducting ground runs along runway 17/35 at Bendigo airport. On one of those runs he lost control of the aircraft which rolled over on its side causing the rotor to strike the runway and effectively destroy the aircraft. Mr Bellamy was unharmed.

  3. After conducting an investigation into the accident, CASA initiated proceedings in the Bendigo Magistrates’ Court claiming that Mr Bellamy was in breach of s. 145.1 of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (the Criminal Code) which relevantly provides:

    (1) A person commits an offence if:

    (a)the person knows that a document is a false document and uses it with the intention of:

    (i)     dishonestly inducing another person in another person’s capacity as a public official to accept it as genuine; and

    (ii)    if it is so accepted, dishonestly obtaining a gain, dishonestly causing a loss, or dishonestly influencing the exercise of public duty or function; and

    (b)the capacity is a capacity as a Commonwealth public official.

    Penalty: Imprisonment for 10 years.

  4. Mr Bellamy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bellamy and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 956
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr. Bellamy to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) against a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to cancel his Private Pilot Licence (PPL). The cancellation followed Mr. Bellamy's conviction for a false document offence, although he was found not guilty of reckless operation of an aircraft. CASA had issued a show cause notice and subsequently determined that Mr. Bellamy was not a fit and proper person to hold a PPL.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether CASA's decision to cancel Mr. Bellamy's PPL was the preferable decision. This involved assessing whether Mr. Bellamy was indeed not a fit and proper person to hold the licence, considering the circumstances surrounding his conviction and his prior dealings with CASA regarding the restoration and testing of a J2 gyroplane. The Tribunal also had to consider the nature of Mr. Bellamy's qualifications and his attempts to comply with aviation regulations.

The Tribunal reasoned that while Mr. Bellamy had encountered significant difficulties and an unfortunate experience with his gyroplane restoration and testing, which led to his conviction, there was no evidence before it to suggest that similar circumstances would arise in relation to his fixed-wing operations. The Tribunal found that Mr. Bellamy had made significant attempts to comply with legislative requirements, which were not always clear. Crucially, the Tribunal concluded that there was no sound basis for CASA to determine that Mr. Bellamy was not a fit and proper person to hold a PPL – aeroplane.

Accordingly, the Tribunal set aside CASA's decision to cancel Mr. Bellamy's PPL. The Tribunal ordered that Mr. Bellamy's PPL – aeroplane remains valid and should be treated as if it had never been cancelled, with CASA's records to be amended accordingly.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Mr. Bellamy, who holds a Private Pilot Licence (PPL) since 2002. Mr. Bellamy purchased a J2 gyroplane in 2000 with the intention to restore it and obtain a Certificate of Airworthiness in the Standard Category after the restoration. He encountered significant difficulties in obtaining approval from the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) for his intended modifications. Despite these difficulties, Mr. Bellamy proceeded with ground runs on the gyroplane, which resulted in an accident. Consequently, Mr. Bellamy was convicted in the Magistrates' Court for making a false document and reckless operation of an aircraft. CASA issued a show cause notice to Mr. Bellamy on 15 July 2015, and on 16 March 2016, CASA decided to cancel Mr. Bellamy's PPL, finding him unfit and improper to hold the license. Mr. Bellamy applied to the Tribunal for a review of CASA's decision on 22 March 2016.

The case came before the Tribunal as an application for review of a decision made by CASA to cancel Mr. Bellamy's PPL. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether CASA's decision was correct and whether Mr. Bellamy was fit and proper to hold the PPL. Prior to this review, Mr. Bellamy had been charged and found guilty of making a false document but not guilty of reckless operation of an aircraft. CASA had issued a show cause notice to Mr. Bellamy on 15 July 2015, providing him with the opportunity to respond. On 16 March 2016, CASA informed Mr. Bellamy that his PPL was cancelled due to his failure to comply with the regulatory requirements and his unfitness to hold the license. Mr. Bellamy lodged an application with the Tribunal on 22 March 2016, seeking a review of CASA's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I did not have any evidence before me indicating that Mr Bellamy’s operations of that aircraft as holder of a PPL, which he has had since 13 August 2002, attracted the attention of CASA. That being the case, I find that there is no sound basis for coming to the conclusion that Mr Bellamy is not a fit and proper person to hold a PPL – aeroplane.CONCLUSION Despite Mr Bellamy having had a very unfortunate experience in his attempt at restoration and testing his J2 gyroplane, I have found that was no evidence upon which CASA can soundly base a suspension of his PPL. All of the difficulties which Mr Bellamy encountered, including his conviction in the Magistrates’ Court, stemmed from his gyroplane involvement. I had no evidence before me that similar circumstances would arise in the future as far as his fixed-wing operations are concerned. Mr Bellamy did not blatantly ignore the advice given to him by CASA and he appeared to have made significant attempts to comply with all legislative requirements as they existed at the time, which were not as clear as perhaps they could have been. I have found that he is a fit and proper person to hold the PPL – aeroplane. I find that the decision made by CASA on 16 March 2016 cancelling Mr Bellamy’s PPL– aeroplane was not the preferable decision. I set aside that decision. Therefore, Mr Bellamy’s PPL – aeroplane remains valid and should be treated as never having been cancelled. CASA’s records regarding Mr Bellamy should be amended accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Bellamy was also charged with reckless operation of aircraft as described in s. 20A of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Civil Aviation Act). Section 20A provides:Reckless operation of aircraft (1)A person must not operate an aircraft being reckless as to whether the manner of operation could endanger the life of another person. (2)A person must not operate an aircraft being reckless as to whether the manner of operation could endanger the person or property of another person. The second charge was in fact brought under s. 29 of the Civil Aviation Act which provides that the owner or operator of an aircraft commits an offence if he or she operates aircraft or permits aircraft to be operated and the operation of the aircraft results in contravention of s. 20A(1). Mr Bellamy was found guilty of the false document offence but not guilty of reckless operation of an aircraft offence. Nevertheless, CASA issued Mr Bellamy with a show cause notice dated 15 July 2015, providing Mr Bellamy with the opportunity to respond. In a letter dated 16 March 2016 CASA informed Mr Bellamy that it had determined that he failed in his duty as the holder of a PPL and that he was not a fit and proper person to be the holder of a PPL. Accordingly, CASA cancelled his PPL. On 22 March 2016 Mr Bellamy lodged an application with the Tribunal seeking review of CASA’s decision to cancel his PPL.THE PROBLEM AIRCRAFTThe J2 gyroplane VH-MBY was an Australian registered aircraft but had not been issued with a certificate of airworthiness. It previously held a Type Certification in the Standard Category of Certificate of Airworthiness but that certification was cancelled when it was taken off the Civil Register. Mr Bellamy purchased the aircraft in 2000 intending to restore it to its original standard of airworthiness in the Standard Category with some design modifications. Mr Bellamy intended to apply for a Certificate of Airworthiness in the Standard Category after the restoration was completed. He considered himself to be well qualified to complete this restoration having been employed as a professional engineer at the Government Aircraft Factories at Fisherman’s Bend between 1972 and 1986 and with Australian Defence Industries at Bendigo between 1986 and 1999. In 1972 he qualified for the degree of Bachelor of Engineering (Aero) at the University of New South Wales. Unfortunately for Mr Bellamy, he ran into serious difficulties getting approval from the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). No purpose is served in reciting the full history of those difficulties. The fact that CASA produced in excess of 1600 pages in the s. 37 (of the Administration Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act)) documents for the purposes of this matter is testimony to that. In order to provide some background, however, I will briefly set out in outline form the events which led to Mr Bellamy conducting ground runs in the J2 which led to the accident and subsequently his conviction. Mr Bellamy believed that he could improve on some of the engineering aspects of the J2. In particular, as is frequently the case with aircraft which were designed many years ago, technology has improved significantly and in the course of restoration, it appears to be logical to incorporate advanced technology where possible. However, modification of an aircraft or the use of components in substitution for existing components requires the approval of CASA (reg. 35 and 36 of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (CAR). CASA must be satisfied that a modification or repair will not adversely affect the safety of an aircraft.