Bell v Veigel; Bell v Broughton; Broughton v Veigel (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: BELL v VEIGEL; BELL v BROUGHTON; BROUGHTON v VEIGEL (No 2) [2008] NSWCA 110
HEARING DATE(S): On the papers
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

27 May 2008
JUDGMENT OF: Mason P at 1; Giles JA at 1; Tobias JA at 1
DECISION: Each appeal and Mrs Broughton's cross-appeal upheld with costs.
CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE – Costs – general rule – costs follow the event – costs of whole action – where offer of compromise made – costs at first instance – costs on appeal – co-defendants – multiple matters
LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Procedure Act 2005
PARTIES: Edwin BELL
Jamie DEE
John VEIGEL bht Paula TALLEN
The Nominal Defendant
Dean Leslie DAVIS
Christie BROUGHTON
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40470/2005; 40471/2005; 40499/2005
COUNSEL: P R Garling SC/ C Thompson (Bell and Dee)
R Letherbarrow SC/ A Stone (Veigel)
L M Morris QC/ J M Morris (Broughton CA40470/05,CA 40499/05)
R McIlwaine SC/ J Davidson (Broughton CA40471/05)
R Stitt QC/ D Wilson (The Nominal Defendant)
R Seton SC/ P Carr (Davis)
SOLICITORS:

Carrolll & O'Dea (Bell and Dee)
Stacks Goudkamp (Veigel)
Moray & Agnew (Broughton, CA40470/05, CA40499/05)
Keddies Litigation Lawyers (Broughton, CA40471/05)
Sparke Helmore (The Nominal Defendant)
Ferguson Bolton (Davis)

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): DC 8279/2002
DC 1082/2004
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Coorey DCJ
LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 12 May 2005
27 May 2005
8 September 2005





                          CA 40470/2005
                          CA 40471/2005
                          CA 49499/2005

                          MASON P
                          GILES JA
                          TOBIAS JA

                          Tuesday 27 May 2008

Elwin BELL & Anor v John VEIGEL & Ors


Elwin BELL & Anor v Christine BROUGHTON & Ors


Christine BROUGHTON v John VEIGEL & Ors


(NO 2)

JUDGMENT

1 THE COURT: We shall refer to the parties by surname without intending any disrespect.

2 The reasons for judgment handed down on 20 March 2008 (Bell v Veigel; Bell v Broughton; Broughton v Veigel [2008] NSWCA 36) addressed three sets of appellate proceedings:

      (a) The Bell/Dee appeal (CA 40470 of 2005) in relation to Bell/Dee's liability in Veigel's action;
      (b) The Broughton appeal (CA 40499 of 2055) in relation to Broughton's liability in Veigel's action; and
      (c) The Bell/Dee appeal (CA 40471 of 2005) in relation to liability (with damages to be assessed) in Broughton's action.

3 We determined that Broughton was neither negligent nor contributorily negligent; and that there must be a new trial as to the identity of the offending vehicle and its owner/driver. Para 238 of our reasons may be repeated:

          Each appeal ought to be upheld, with costs. So too should Mrs Broughton’s cross appeal in CA 40471 of 2005. Verdicts and judgments on liability should be entered in Mrs Broughton’s favour. Other verdicts and judgments on liability, in the actions and the cross-claims, should be set aside, along with ensuing costs orders. The scope of the new trial to be ordered has already been indicated. Subject to any special costs issues, the costs of the first trial touching all parties except Mrs Broughton in her status as…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell v Veigel; Bell v Broughton; Broughton v Veigel (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWCA 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceedings involved appeals and cross-appeals concerning a trial before Coorey DCJ. The primary dispute appears to have involved claims related to an offending vehicle and its owner/driver, with multiple parties involved as appellants, respondents, and cross-claimants. The appeals were heard by Mason P, Giles JA, and Tobias JA in the Court of Appeal.

The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal included the determination of costs in circumstances where offers of compromise had been made, the application of the general rule that costs follow the event, and the allocation of costs for the whole action, including appeals and cross-appeals, particularly in the context of co-defendants and multiple matters. The court was also required to consider the setting aside of previous judgments and orders and the remittal of certain issues for a new trial.

The Court of Appeal upheld the appeals and cross-appeals in part, setting aside most of the previous judgments and orders made by Coorey DCJ. The court remitted the matter for a new trial, limited to the issues concerning the identity of the offending vehicle and its owner/driver. Costs of the appeals and cross-appeals were generally awarded in favour of the successful parties, with specific orders made for the payment of costs between various parties. The costs of the trial before Coorey DCJ were largely left to the discretion of the judge who would hear the new trial, with certain exceptions. Notably, several costs orders were stayed pending the outcome of an appeal to the High Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Each appeal and Mrs Broughton's cross-appeal upheld with costs. (Judgment of the Court):

CA 40470 of 2005:

The following orders should be made:

1. Appeal upheld.

2. The third and fourth respondents are to pay the appellants’ costs of the appeal.

3. The cross appeal is dismissed.

4. Each party is to pay their own costs of the cross-appeal.

5. The Judgment and Orders of Coorey DCJ on 12 May, 27 May, 8 September and 7 December 2005 are set aside with the exception of Orders 1, 3, 4 and 8 in the Judgment/Order made on 27 May 2005 and Orders D and E in the Judgment/Order made on 8 September 2005.

6. Verdict and judgment for the second respondent against the first respondent.

7. The first respondent is to pay the second respondent’s costs of the trial before Coorey DCJ.

8. Verdict and judgment for the second respondent on the first cross claim by the third respondent.

9. The third respondent is to pay the second respondent’s costs of the first cross claim.

10. Verdict and judgment for the second respondent on the second cross claim by the first and second appellants.

11. The first and second appellants are to pay the second respondent’s costs of the second cross claim.

12. Verdict and judgment for the second respondent on the fifth cross claim by the fourth respondent.

13. The fourth respondent is to pay the second respondent’s costs of the fifth cross claim.

14. The third, fourth and sixth cross claims are dismissed with no order as to costs.

15. The matter is remitted for a new trial limited to the issues as to the identity of the offending vehicle and its owner/driver.

16. Subject to any costs orders in paragraphs 1 to 15 inclusive above, the costs of the trial before Coorey DCJ are to be at the discretion of the judge who hears the new trial, with the exception of the Orders D and E in the Judgment/Order made on 8 September 2005.

17. The costs orders referred to in paragraphs 2, 9, 11 and 13 are stayed pending the outcome of the appeal to the High Court.

CA 40471 of 2005:

The following orders should be made:

1. Leave to appeal is granted.

2. The appeal is upheld.

3. The second and third opponents are to pay the first and second cross claimants/appellants’ [Bell/Dee] costs of the appeal.

4. Leave granted to cross appeal.

5. The cross appeal is upheld.

6. The cross opponents are to pay the cross claimants’ costs of the cross appeal.

7. The Judgment and Orders of Coorey DCJ on 12 May, 27 May, 8 September 2005 are set aside.

8. The matter is remitted for a new trial limited to the issues as to the identity of the offending vehicle and its owner/driver.

9. The costs of the trial before Coorey DCJ are to be at the discretion of the judge who hears the new trial.

10. The costs orders referred to in paragraphs 3 and 7 are stayed pending the outcome of the appeal to the High Court.

CA 40499 of 2005:

The following orders should be made:

1. By consent, the Amended Notice of Appeal with Appointment filed by the appellant on 6 October 2005 in proceedings No 40499 of 2005 (to be found at Red 269) be amended by deleting the words “Owen Arnold” (being the identity of the third respondent in the appeal and the third defendant in the court below), and substituting it with the word “Elwin”.

2. The appeal is upheld.

3. The respondents other than the first respondent are to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

4. The cross appeal is dismissed.

5. Each party pay their own costs of the cross appeal.

6. The Judgment and Orders of Coorey DCJ on 12 May, 27 May, 8 September and 7 December 2005 are set aside with the exception of Orders 1, 3, 4 and 8 in the Judgment/Order made on 27 May 2005 and Orders D and E in the Judgment/Order made on 8 September 2005.

7. Verdict and judgment for the appellant against the first respondent.

8. The first respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the trial before Coorey DCJ.

9. Verdict and judgment for the appellant on the first cross claim by the second respondent.

10. The second respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the first cross claim.

11. Verdict and judgment for the appellant on the second cross claim by the third and fourth respondents.

12. The third and fourth respondents are to pay the appellant’s costs of the second cross claim.

13. Verdict and judgment for the appellant on the fifth cross claim by the fifth respondent.

14. The fifth respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the fifth cross claim.

15. The third, fourth and sixth cross claims by the appellant are dismissed with no order as to costs.

16. The matter is remitted for a new trial limited to the issues as to the identity of the offending vehicle and its owner/driver.

17. Subject to any costs orders referred to in paragraphs 1 to 16 inclusive above, the costs of the trial before Coorey DCJ are to be at the discretion of the judge who hears the new trial, with the exception of the Orders D and E in the Judgment/Order made on 8 September 2005.

18. It is noted that the appellant reserves her right to claim as against the first respondent an entitlement to: (a) interest on the sum of $2.25 million paid to the first respondent; and (b) interest on costs which she is entitled to recover, but will not be finally addressed until after the re-trial.

19. The costs orders referred to in paragraphs 3, 8, 10, 12, 14 and 15 are stayed pending the outcome of the Appeal to the High Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.