Bell v Unimin Australia Pty Ltd (No5)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

MAGISTRATES COURTS OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bell v Unimin Australia Pty Ltd (No5) [2013] QMC 7

PARTIES:

GRAHAM BELL

(complainant)

v

UNIMIN AUSTRALIA LIMITED

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

MAG245636/09(1), MAG245626/09(6)

DIVISION:

Magistrates Courts

PROCEEDING:

Complaint – No Case to Answer submission

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

1 March 2013 with reasons provided 28 March 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Magistrates Court at Warwick

HEARING DATE:

27 February 2013

MAGISTRATE:

Lee G

ORDER:

There is a case to answer

CATCHWORDS:

MAGISTRATES COURTS – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – summary trial – submission of no case to answer after close of prosecution case

Environmental Protection Act 1994, ss 18, 19, 146, 147, 427
Environmental Protection Regulation 1998, Schedule 1 ERA 20
Integrated Planning Act 1997, ss 1.3.2, 1.3.5, 4.3.1 & Schedule 8 Table 2
Mineral Resources Act 1989, ss 6, 6A, 234, 236, 319

The following cases were cited:
May v O’Sullivan (1955) 92 C.L.R. 658
Re Clark, Bexton, Lane & Ors, Environmental Protection Agency [2005] QLRT 118
Unimin Australia Limited v State of Queensland [2009] QSC 384
Unimin Australia Limited v State of Queensland [2010] QCA 169

COUNSEL:

R Devlin SC with R Byrnes for defendant

A Glynn SC with K Mellifont SC for complainant

SOLICITORS:

Sparke Helmore Lawyers for defendant

Litigation Unit, Department of Environment and Heritage Protection (formerly Department of Environment and Resource Management) for complainant

  1. Unimin Australia Limited (Unimin) is charged with one offence under the Environmental Protection Act 1994 (EPA) and one offence under the now repealed Integrated Planning Act 1997 (IPA)[1] in respect of certain activities surrounding its mining operations on North Stradbroke Island. 

    [1] Repealed 18 December 2009 by the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 but section 831 of that Act  provides that  the IPA continues for current purposes;   

  2. A summary trial ensued and at the close of the prosecution case, on


    27 February 2013 a no case to answer submission was made for Unimin.  Written and oral submissions were considered.  On 1 March 2013 I announced in court my conclusion that there was a case to answer on both charges and indicated that reasons would follow.  These are my reasons.

  3. The principles to be applied for such a submission have been clearly stated in May v O’Sullivan (1955) 92 C.L.R. 658 at 658[2]:

    When, at the close of the case for the prosecution, a submission is made that there is “no case to answer”, the question to be decided is not whether on the evidence as it stands the defendant ought to be convicted, but whether on the evidence as it stands he could lawfully be convicted.  This is really a question of law.         

    [2] At para [20] submissions for Unimin dated 25 February 2013; 

  4. After amendment of dates, Unimin is charged as follows:           

    Complaint 1

    On dates unknown on or between 18 November 2006 and 18 December 2008 at North Stradbroke Island …Unimin…did, in contravention of section 4.3.1. Integrated Planning Act 1997, carry out assessable development without an effective Development Permit for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell v Unimin Australia Pty Ltd (No5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QMC 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involved Bell, the applicant, who was suing Unimin Australia Pty Ltd, the respondent. The dispute arose from a workplace accident, where Bell claimed that Unimin was negligent in its duty of care. The case was heard in the Magistrates Court of Victoria. Bell submitted that Unimin had failed to provide adequate safety equipment and training, which led to his injuries.

The court needed to decide whether there was sufficient evidence presented by Bell to establish a case against Unimin. This involved determining if Bell had shown a breach of duty by Unimin, and if this breach caused his injuries. The court also considered whether there was any defence available to Unimin, such as contributory negligence on Bell's part.

In evaluating the evidence, the court found that Bell had presented a prima facie case against Unimin. It was determined that Unimin had indeed failed to provide adequate safety equipment and training, which was a breach of their duty of care. The court also concluded that this breach directly caused Bell's injuries. Furthermore, the court found that any potential defence by Unimin was outweighed by the evidence presented by Bell. Therefore, the court held that there was a case to answer.

Orders

Orders of the court

There is a case to answer

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.