Belgravia Nominees Pty Ltd v Lowe Pty Ltd [No 4]

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

BELGRAVIA NOMINEES PTY LTD -v- LOWE PTY LTD [No 4] [2016] WASC 74



SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIACitation No:[2016] WASC 74
Case No:CIV:2583/20131 MARCH 2016
Coram:TOTTLE J9/03/16
14Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Application to reopen allowed
Plaintiffs' renewed application for leave to amend indorsement of claim rejected
B
PDF Version
Parties:BELGRAVIA NOMINEES PTY LTD
JOONDEL DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
LOWE PTY LTD
COLIN REGINALD HEATH
PENHURST NOMINEES PTY LTD

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure
Amendment to indorsement on writ
Application dismissed in part
Where plaintiff applied to reopen case
Whether plaintiff denied procedural fairness
Where judge applied principle of law not raised in argument
Where principle taken from case which was discussed in argument
Plaintiffs were deprived of opportunity to put submissions
Appeal would cause further delay in proceedings
Leave to reopen granted
Practice and procedure
Amendment to indorsement on writ
Where amendment would add new cause of action
Where new cause of action would otherwise be statute barred
O 21 r 5(2) Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)
Limitation period must be current at time writ is issued
Where limitation period for some causes of action had expired before writ issues
O 21 r 5(2) did not apply
Limitation periods
s 38 Limitation Act 2005 (WA)
Extension of limitation period
Where no application yet made to extend limitation period
Section 38 did not affect operation of O 21 r 5

Legislation:

Limitations Act 2005 (WA), s 38, s 43, s 44
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 21 r 5(2) and (5)

Case References:

ABB Service Pty Ltd v Hetherington [2001] WASCA 417
Wentworth v Wentworth [1999] NSWSC 638


JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
    IN CHAMBERS
CITATION : BELGRAVIA NOMINEES PTY LTD -v- LOWE PTY LTD [No 4] [2016] WASC 74 CORAM : TOTTLE J HEARD : 1 MARCH 2016 DELIVERED : 9 MARCH 2016 FILE NO/S : CIV 2583 of 2013 BETWEEN : BELGRAVIA NOMINEES PTY LTD
    JOONDEL DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
    Plaintiffs

    AND

    LOWE PTY LTD
    First Defendant

    COLIN REGINALD HEATH
    Second Defendant

    PENHURST NOMINEES PTY LTD
    Third Defendant

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Amendment to indorsement on writ - Application dismissed in part - Where plaintiff applied to reopen case - Whether plaintiff denied procedural fairness - Where judge applied principle of law not raised in argument - Where principle taken from case which was discussed in argument - Plaintiffs were deprived of opportunity to put submissions - Appeal would cause further delay in proceedings - Leave to reopen granted



Practice and procedure - Amendment to indorsement on writ - Where amendment would add new cause of action - Where new cause of action would otherwise be statute barred - O 21 r 5(2) Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) - Limitation period must be current at time writ is issued - Where limitation period for some causes of action had expired before writ issues - O…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Belgravia Nominees Pty Ltd v Lowe Pty Ltd [No 4] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] WASC 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Belgravia Nominees Pty Ltd, as trustee for the Belgravia Trust, sought to amend its writ to add new causes of action against Lowe Pty Ltd. The dispute arose out of alleged breaches of fiduciary duty, deceit, and fraudulent misrepresentation by Lowe. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The plaintiffs argued that they should be allowed to amend their indorsement to include these new causes of action, despite the limitation periods for some of them having expired before the writ was issued. Lowe opposed the amendment, contending that the proposed changes would introduce new causes of action that were statute-barred.

The court had to determine whether the plaintiffs were denied procedural fairness and whether the amendment should be permitted. The plaintiffs argued that they were not given an opportunity to address the judge's application of a principle of law not raised during the proceedings, which was derived from a case that had been discussed. Lowe contended that allowing the amendment would cause further delay in the proceedings. The court needed to balance the principles of procedural fairness and the efficient administration of justice.

The court found that the plaintiffs were not denied procedural fairness as they had been given an opportunity to address the principles discussed, albeit in a different context. However, the amendment to add new causes of action was rejected because the limitation periods for some of these actions had expired before the writ was issued. The court noted that the amendment rule, Order 21 rule 5(2) of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), did not apply since the limitation periods for some causes of action had expired prior to the writ being issued. The court also held that section 38 of the Limitation Act 2005 (WA), which allows for an extension of the limitation period, did not affect the operation of Order 21 rule 5. Consequently, the application to reopen the case was allowed, but the plaintiffs' renewed application for leave to amend the indorsement of claim was rejected.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application to reopen allowed

Plaintiffs' renewed application for leave to amend indorsement of claim rejected

Background

Background to the litigation

Belgravia Nominees Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, sought to amend the indorsement on their writ to add a new cause of action against Lowe Pty Ltd, the defendant. The proposed amendment aimed to address a matter that would otherwise be barred by statute if not included. The amendment was sought after the limitation period for some causes of action had already expired before the writ was issued. The plaintiff's application to reopen the case was initially dismissed in part. They subsequently appealed against the dismissal, arguing that they were denied procedural fairness. The judge applied a principle of law not explicitly raised in the plaintiff's argument, which was derived from a case discussed in the arguments. This left the plaintiffs without the opportunity to make further submissions on the principle.

The matter initially came before the court when Belgravia Nominees Pty Ltd applied to reopen their case. This application was dismissed in part, leading to an appeal by the plaintiff. The appeal was heard, focusing on whether the plaintiff had been denied procedural fairness and whether the judge's application of a certain principle of law was fair. The court considered the procedural fairness of the case and the implications of the judge applying a principle of law not directly argued by the plaintiff. Additionally, the court examined the plaintiffs' application to amend the indorsement on their writ to include a new cause of action, which would otherwise be statute-barred.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiffs were denied procedural fairness when the judge applied a principle of law not explicitly raised in the plaintiff's argument.
2. Whether the principle applied by the judge, which was derived from a case discussed in the arguments, deprived the plaintiffs of the opportunity to make further submissions.
3. Whether the court should grant leave to reopen the case considering the potential for further delay in the proceedings.
4. Whether the amendment to the indorsement on the writ to include a new cause of action is permissible under Order 21 rule 5(2) of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), given that the limitation period for some causes of action had expired before the writ was issued.
5. Whether section 38 of the Limitation Act 2005 (WA) affects the operation of Order 21 rule 5(2) where no application has been made to extend the limitation period.

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiffs were not denied procedural fairness when the judge applied a principle of law not explicitly raised in the plaintiff's argument, as the principle was derived from a case discussed in the arguments.
2. The principle applied by the judge deprived the plaintiffs of the opportunity to make further submissions, but this did not amount to a denial of procedural fairness.
3. The court refused to grant leave to reopen the case as it would cause further delay in the proceedings.
4. The amendment to the indorsement on the writ to include a new cause of action was not permissible under Order 21 rule 5(2) of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), as the limitation period for some causes of action had expired before the writ was issued.
5. Section 38 of the Limitation Act 2005 (WA) did not affect the operation of Order 21 rule 5(2) where no application had been made to extend the limitation period.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the issue of whether the plaintiffs were denied procedural fairness when the judge applied a principle of law not explicitly raised in the plaintiff's argument. The court found that the principle applied was derived from a case that was discussed in the arguments, thus it did not amount to a denial of procedural fairness. The court also addressed whether the principle applied deprived the plaintiffs of the opportunity to make further submissions. Although the plaintiffs were deprived of the opportunity to make further submissions, the court concluded that this did not result in a denial of procedural fairness.

In relation to the granting of leave to reopen the case, the court noted that the plaintiffs' renewed application for leave to amend the indorsement of the claim was rejected. The court determined that granting leave to reopen the case would cause further delay in the proceedings, which outweighed the potential benefits of reopening the case.

The court then considered the amendment to the indorsement on the writ to include a new cause of action. The court held that the amendment was not permissible under Order 21 rule 5(2) of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), as the limitation period for some causes of action had expired before the writ was issued. The court found that Order 21 rule 5(2) required the limitation period to be current at the time the writ was issued, and since the limitation period for some causes of action had expired before the writ was issued, the rule did not apply.

Finally, the court addressed the effect of section 38 of the Limitation Act 2005 (WA) on the operation of Order 21 rule 5(2). The court concluded that section 38 did not affect the operation of Order 21 rule 5(2) where no application had been made to extend the limitation period. The court held that the absence of an application to extend the limitation period meant that section 38 did not apply to the situation, and thus, it did not affect the operation of Order 21 rule 5(2). The binding legal principle established in this case is that the limitation period must be current at the time the writ is issued for Order 21 rule 5(2) to apply.