BECKSWIFT LIMITED

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

official notice

decision of a deputy commissioner of patents

Patent :          614373 in the name of Beckswift Limited

Title:          Electrical apparatus incorporating shield means to increase the current carrying capacity of electrode thereof.

Action:          Request under s223 for an extension of time to pay a renewal fee.

Decision:          Issued            .

Abstract

At the anniversary date there was no intention to pay the relevant renewal fee. During the so-called grace period the patentee changed their mind, but because of an error or omission the fee was paid 2 days after the end of that period.

The operation of s223 is conditioned upon the identification of the act that was not done, and extending the time for doing that act. If a renewal fee is validly paid after the anniversary, it is necessarily paid ‘in a period that is extended because of r13.6(3)’. There is no other basis for paying a renewal fee after the expiration of the anniversary (assuming there was no error or omission prior to the anniversary.)

The relevant act that was not done was the payment of the fee ‘in a period that is extended because of r13.6(3)’. That action is specifically excluded from the application of s223 by r22.11(3)(b). Accordingly s223 is not available in the circumstances.

Extension of time refused.

patents act 1990

decision of a deputy commissioner of patents

Re:Patent 614373 in the name of Beckswift Limited, and a request under s223 for an extension of time to pay a renewal fee.

background

Patent no. 614373 was applied for on 21 April 1989. Consequently renewal fees fall due on 21 April each year. The renewal fee due 21 April 1996 was not paid by that date, nor by the end of the 6-month ‘grace period’ which expired on 21 October 1996. However on Wed. 23 October 1996 (2 days after the end of the grace period) the patentee paid the renewal fee and filed a request under s223 for an extension of time to pay that fee.

The circumstances surrounding the failure to timely pay the renewal fee are set out in a statutory declaration by Peter Smart [a Chartered Patent Agent (in the UK) and European Patent Attorney] who asserts that he has responsibility for the care of the affairs of the patentee. In brief, Mr Smart declares:

  • the patentee is a company within a multinational group of companies (Tetra Laval Group);

  • in 1996 Tetra Laval decided it would close down Beckswift Limited (the patentee);

  • as a result, the patent (and other patents around the world) would not be maintained;

  • the decision was provisional in the sense that ‘no steps were taken to prevent the patents and patent applications in question from being revived if possible at a future date should there be a change of plan’;

  • in April 1996, Smart instructed Davies Collison Cave to mark their records to indicate the patent would not be renewed;

  • on 1 August 1996, Tetra enquired of Smart the precise status of (inter alia)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BECKSWIFT LIMITED and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] APO 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Beckswift Limited applied for an extension of time to pay a renewal fee for its patent under section 223 of the Patents Act 1990. The patent in question had an anniversary date for the renewal fee payment on 21 April 1996, and the renewal fee was due by that date. However, the renewal fee was not paid by the anniversary date or within the subsequent six-month grace period, which expired on 21 October 1996. On 23 October 1996, two days after the end of the grace period, the patentee paid the renewal fee and filed a request for an extension of time to pay that fee. The court had to decide whether an extension of time was statutorily available in these circumstances.

The court found that section 223 of the Patents Act 1990 requires a causative relationship between the error or omission, and the relevant act that was not done. This necessitates the error or omission occurring before the expiration of that 'certain time.' In this case, the error occurred after the anniversary of the patent. Therefore, the 'certain time' cannot be the period set out in regulation 13.6(1), of twelve months ending on the anniversary (with the relevant act being the payment of the renewal fee). The court found that the relevant act that was not done within the certain time was the payment of the fee 'in a period that is extended because of r13.6(3)'. However, that action is specifically excluded from the application of section 223 by regulation 22.11(3)(b). Consequently, section 223 is not available in the circumstances.

The court concluded that there was no intention at the anniversary date to pay the renewal fee, and there was no error or omission prior to that date. The suggestion that any such decision was provisional in the sense that no action had been taken to prevent subsequent restoration, is not relevant. The court refused to grant the extension of time sought, resulting in the patent irrevocably ceasing.

The final orders of the court were that the extension of time sought by Beckswift Limited to pay the renewal fee was refused, and the patent had irrevocably ceased.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established