Bean and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Bean and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023] AATA 3492 (28 September 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2023/5165

Re:Hohepa Paetai Bean

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Dr N A Manetta

Date:28 September 2023

Date of written reasons:        26 October 2023

Place:Adelaide

For the reasons given orally at the conclusion of the hearing of this matter, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision that the cancellation of the applicant’s visa be revoked.

…………[sgnd]……………………….

Senior Member Dr N A Manetta

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – mandatory cancellation of applicant’s visa – applicant does not satisfy character test – whether another reason for the cancellation decision to be revoked – Direction no. 99 – conviction for manslaughter – sentencing remarks considered – positive assessment of applicant’s prior character – special circumstances of crime – excessive force in self-defence – primary considerations – community’s expectations weigh against the applicant – low risk of reoffending – applicant’s ties to Australia and the best interests of minor children weigh in applicant’s favour – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

CASES

FYVY and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023] AATA 790

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; (2008) 235 CLR 286

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Cth), Direction no. 99 ‒ Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (23 January 2023)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Dr N A Manetta

26 October 2023

  1. After I delivered my decision with oral reasons, I received a request for written reasons, which I now publish.[1]  These are the reasons I read out to the parties with minor amendments.

    [1] These reasons include certain standard paragraphs I use, especially [6] and [26].

  2. This is an application by Mr Hohepa Paetai Bean seeking a review of the decision of the respondent’s delegate dated 6 July 2023.  By that decision, the delegate declined to revoke the cancellation of Mr Bean’s visa.[2] The cancellation had earlier taken place, and mandatorily so, after Mr Bean was found guilty of the offence of manslaughter in circumstances that I shall describe in due course. He was sentenced to a lengthy term of imprisonment, part of which he was required to serve on a full-time basis in jail. In these circumstances, the delegate was required to cancel Mr Bean’s visa under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).

    [2] A class TY subclass 444 special category visa.

  3. Mr Bean sought an internal review of the delegate’s decision.[3] The internal-review delegate was required to address two questions under section 501CA(4)(b) of the Act. The first was whether Mr Bean passed the so-called “character test” as defined in section 501. Given his lengthy term of imprisonment, Mr Bean could not pass the character test, and the delegate’s conclusion in this regard was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bean and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicult... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3492
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Bean against the mandatory cancellation of his visa, which had been cancelled on the grounds that he did not satisfy the character test. The Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs was the respondent. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether there was another reason for the cancellation decision to be revoked.

The Tribunal was tasked with considering whether the circumstances surrounding Mr Bean's conviction for manslaughter, specifically the application of Direction No. 99, warranted the revocation of the visa cancellation. This involved weighing various factors, including the nature of the offence, Mr Bean's prior character, the special circumstances of the crime, the community's expectations, the risk of reoffending, and the best interests of minor children.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal acknowledged the extreme violence involved in the manslaughter conviction but gave significant weight to the sentencing remarks from the Supreme Court. These remarks indicated that the offence arose in highly unusual circumstances, involving excessive force in self-defence rather than a deliberate infliction of unjustifiable harm. The Tribunal also considered positive assessments of Mr Bean's prior character, his low risk of reoffending, and his strong ties to Australia, including the best interests of minor children.

The Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted a decision that the cancellation of Mr Bean's visa be revoked.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I have decided to set aside the decision under review and to substitute a decision that the cancellation of Mr Bean’s visa be revoked. I now set out the background facts and my reasons for this conclusion.BACKGROUND FACTS The background facts are as follows. Mr Bean was born on 3 June 1975 and was, therefore, 48 years old at the time of the hearing before me. He was born in New Zealand and remains a citizen of that country. His father left the family home when Mr Bean was very young. Mr Bean’s evidence to the Tribunal, which I accept, was that his father had been violent towards his mother. The sentencing remarks, which were before me and to which I shall refer in some detail in due course, refer to Mr Bean’s troubled childhood. It involved much physical and verbal abuse by his father.[6] Mr Bean was raised by his mother. He has a number of siblings and half-siblings. He has an older sister presently living in Queensland and he has contact with her frequently, he says. Mr Bean also has a younger sister living in Hawkes Bay, New Zealand, but he does not have regular contact with her. He has no contact with his three half siblings, one of whom lives in Hawkes Bay and another in Adelaide, as I understand the evidence. Mr Bean’s mother died some 15 years ago. I accept this evidence.[6] See R v Bean [2022] NSWSC 783, [79] (reproduced at Ex R1, G6). Mr Bean came to Australia in 1997 when he was about 21 years of age. He came here to get away from Hawkes Bay, he said in his oral evidence. Hawkes Bay was a place where he had employment but which he also described as having gangs and few job opportunities. Mr Bean settled in the vicinity of Coffs Harbour, New South Wales to work with an uncle on a farm. The farm involved potato cultivation and cattle rearing. Mr Bean said that he also did seasonal work around Coffs Harbour, he said. He gave evidence that he enjoyed the work very much; but mechanisation ended up reducing his hours. He continued to work on and off in the potato sheds, he said, but he also began working in a sawmill. He would also help out with odd jobs and fencing. I accept this evidence. Mr Bean met his partner, Ms Carter, in a town called Dorrigo. They did not have any children, but the sentencing remarks refer to the couple having raised Ms Carter’s niece.[7] Mr Bean also had a long-standing friendship with a man named Mr Boardman. Mr Boardman was a mechanic in the town. Mr Bean had met him at the local pub and started playing rugby with him. They became firm friends, he said. I accept this evidence.[7] Ibid [81]. Despite his friendship with Mr Bean, Mr Boardman began an intimate relationship with Ms Carter, who, as I have said, had been Mr Bean’s long-standing partner. Mr Bean found out about the infidelity about six weeks before the shooting that led to Mr Boardman’s death, which I shall now describe. The shooting occurred in October 2018. Mr Bean pleaded guilty to manslaughter (on the basis of self-defence with excessive force). I accept them, and I rely on them. The remarks refer to a statement of agreed facts that informed the Court’s sentencing.[8] [8] Ibid [9]. The Court also had regard to the transcript of evidence of the earlier murder trial to resolve matters that remained in dispute: see Ibid [11].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the hearing before me, Ms Maher appeared for the applicant; Ms Jones-Bolla for the respondent. I acknowledge particularly Ms Jones-Bolla’s assistance to me. STATEMENT OF CONCLUSION I have decided to set aside the decision under review and to substitute a decision that the cancellation of Mr Bean’s visa be revoked. I now set out the background facts and my reasons for this conclusion.BACKGROUND FACTS The background facts are as follows. Mr Bean was born on 3 June 1975 and was, therefore, 48 years old at the time of the hearing before me. He was born in New Zealand and remains a citizen of that country. His father left the family home when Mr Bean was very young. Mr Bean’s evidence to the Tribunal, which I accept, was that his father had been violent towards his mother. The sentencing remarks, which were before me and to which I shall refer in some detail in due course, refer to Mr Bean’s troubled childhood. It involved much physical and verbal abuse by his father.[6] Mr Bean was raised by his mother. He has a number of siblings and half-siblings. He has an older sister presently living in Queensland and he has contact with her frequently, he says. Mr Bean also has a younger sister living in Hawkes Bay, New Zealand, but he does not have regular contact with her. He has no contact with his three half siblings, one of whom lives in Hawkes Bay and another in Adelaide, as I understand the evidence. Mr Bean’s mother died some 15 years ago. I accept this evidence.[6] See R v Bean [2022] NSWSC 783, [79] (reproduced at Ex R1, G6). Mr Bean came to Australia in 1997 when he was about 21 years of age. He came here to get away from Hawkes Bay, he said in his oral evidence. Hawkes Bay was a place where he had employment but which he also described as having gangs and few job opportunities. Mr Bean settled in the vicinity of Coffs Harbour, New South Wales to work with an uncle on a farm. The farm involved potato cultivation and cattle rearing. Mr Bean said that he also did seasonal work around Coffs Harbour, he said. He gave evidence that he enjoyed the work very much; but mechanisation ended up reducing his hours. He continued to work on and off in the potato sheds, he said, but he also began working in a sawmill. He would also help out with odd jobs and fencing. I accept this evidence. Mr Bean met his partner, Ms Carter, in a town called Dorrigo. They did not have any children, but the sentencing remarks refer to the couple having raised Ms Carter’s niece.[7] Mr Bean also had a long-standing friendship with a man named Mr Boardman. Mr Boardman was a mechanic in the town. Mr Bean had met him at the local pub and started playing rugby with him. They became firm friends, he said. I accept this evidence.[7] Ibid [81]. Despite his friendship with Mr Bean, Mr Boardman began an intimate relationship with Ms Carter, who, as I have said, had been Mr Bean’s long-standing partner. Mr Bean found out about the infidelity about six weeks before the shooting that led to Mr Boardman’s death, which I shall now describe.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I proceed on the basis that New Zealand has a broadly equivalent economy and welfare system to Australia’s. I further bear in mind that Mr Bean lived in New Zealand until he was about 21 and so is familiar with its life and culture. I do not ascribe any significance to any impediments arising from the process of relocation to New Zealand as such. Like the delegate,[41] however, I do believe that Mr Bean would experience a strong degree of emotional dislocation if he were permanently removed since Australia has become his home and given his connections here. That is a matter I should take into account.[41] Ibid [104].WEIGHING THE CONSIDERATIONS I turn now to weighing the considerations I have identified. This has not been an easy matter. I am conscious of the extreme violence that has occurred in this case. There is other antisocial behaviour that has occurred, but I have concluded that this behaviour is not a “tipping point” in my deliberations, and so it is sufficient for me to concentrate in these remarks on the manslaughter conviction. As I have said, the violence in question was extreme. There can be no more serious violence than that resulting in a person’s death. The violence in question was the result of the use of a firearm that had the potential for lethal effect. The community-expectations consideration counts clearly against Mr Bean. The Direction taken as a whole speaks strongly against violence, and for the very reason that violence threatens directly and immediately the well-being of members of the Australian community. It is better for violent non-citizens to be removed from Australia as a general principle or norm. Mr Bean’s risk profile, whilst low, is not nil. In this case, however, the circumstances of the violence need to be borne in mind so as to reach the preferable decision in the weighing process. It is appropriate, in my opinion, to bear in mind closely the sentencing remarks in this regard. Although Mr Bean’s offending involved a crime of extreme violence, it arose in highly unusual circumstances (although not unprecedented). Mr Bean genuinely believed he needed to act in the way he did to defend himself. The Court was not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that he intended to kill Mr Boardman, although he did intend to wound him severely. His use of the weapon, whilst excessive and unreasonable in all the circumstances, was not judged to be a grossly disproportionate response. The crime is one, therefore, of negligence and not one involving the deliberate infliction of unjustifiable harm by a perpetrator who knows the harm to be unjustifiable. That aspect of the matter does need to be weighed carefully in my opinion, as do the Court’s remarks in respect of the applicant’s prior character, which reflected quite positively on him. Mr Bean was not found to be a violent man by the sentencing Court, which viewed many abusive and aggressive texts from Mr Bean and formed the impression that he was trying to stand up to an aggressive and threatening person in Mr Boardman.[42] I have assessed the risk of reoffending to be low, although not nil. I do not doubt that the circumstances of jail, and now detention for almost a year, with the prospect of losing his life in Australia have had a significant impact on Mr Bean. I believe that he will do what he can to minimise the chances of any recurrence. His intimate relationship with Ms Carter is now over, of course, and it was that relationship that was the catalyst for the events that took place. [42] See R v Bean [2022] NSWSC 783 [49] (reproduced at Ex R1, G6).