BCI Finances Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BCI Finances Pty Limited (in liq) v Binetter (No 3) [2015] FCA 1336

Citation: BCI Finances Pty Limited (in liq) v Binetter (No 3) [2015] FCA 1336
Parties: BCI FINANCES PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 055 988 531, EGL DEVELOPMENT (CANBERRA) PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION), LIGON 268 PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) and BINQLD FINANCES PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) v GARY ROBERT BINETTER IN HIS CAPACITY AS THE LEGAL PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE LATE EMIL BINETTER, MARGARET BINETTER IN HER CAPACITY AS THE LEGAL PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE LATE ERWIN BINETTER, MARGARET BINETTER, ANDREW JOHN BINETTER, GARY ROBERT BINETTER, MICHAEL THOMAS ROBERT BINETTER, MILGERD NOMINEES PTY LIMITED, ERMA NOMINEES PTY LIMITED, LIGON 159 PTY LIMITED, LIGON 158 PTY LIMITED, DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION, RAWBIN FINANCES PTY LTD, BINQLDL PTY LTD, AB KAMBALA HOLDINGS PTY LTD ATF THE AB KAMBALA HOLDINGS TRUST, NUDIE FRANCHISING SYSTEMS PTY LIMITED, NUDIE FOODS PTY LIMITED, NUDIE PTY LIMITED, REAL JUICE PTY LIMITED, NUDIE FOODS AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED and TAMARAMA FRESH JUICES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
File number: SAD 5 of 2015
Judge: GLEESON J
Date of judgment: 1 December 2015
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for freezing orders – where freezing order against third party to proceeding sought – existing freezing orders amended –Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 7.35(5)(b)

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to re-open hearing of interlocutory application – leave granted in part

Legislation:  Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), rr 7.32, 7.34, 7.35
Cases cited: Apostolidis v Kalenik [2011] VSCA 307; (2011) 35 VR 563
Audio Products Group Pty Ltd v Mamone [2005] NSWSC 982
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Rich [2006] NSWSC 826; (2006) 235 ALR 857
BCI Finances Pty Limited (in liq) v GR Binetter as the Representative of the Estate of E Binetter [2015] FCA 86
Caboche v Southern Equities Corporation Ltd [2001] SASC 55
Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd [1999] HCA 18; (1999) 198 CLR 380
Davis v Turning Properties Pt Ltd [2005] NSWSC 742; (2005) 222 ALR 656
Patrick v Capital Finance Pty Ltd (No 2) [2003] FCA 263
Rafferty v Time 2000 West Pt Ltd (No 7) [2011] FCA 405
Date of hearing: 22, 29 October 2015
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 101
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr B Mostafa
Solicitor for the Applicants: Cosoff Cudmore Knox
Counsel for the First, Second, Third, Fifth, Seventh and Ninth Respondents: The First, Second, Third, Fifth, Seventh and Ninth Respondents did not appear
Counsel for the Fourth, Eighth and Tenth Respondents: Mr DL Williams SC with Mr DL Cook
Solicitor for the Fourth, Eighth and Tenth Respondents: Polczynski Lawyers
Counsel for the Sixth Respondent: Mr CD Freeman
Solicitor for the Sixth Respondent: ClarkeKann Lawyers
Counsel for the First Prospective Respondent: Dr G O’Mahoney
Solicitor for the First Prospective Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Second, Third and Fourth Prospective Respondents: Mr D Krochmalik
Solicitor for the Second, Third and Fourth Prospective…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BCI Finances Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 1336
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of BCI Finances Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter (No 3) involved an application for freezing orders against third parties in a proceeding. The Federal Court was required to amend existing freezing orders and grant leave to reopen a hearing of an interlocutory application. The primary legal issues centered around the applicability of Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 7.35(5)(b), which deals with the freezing of assets belonging to third parties, and the circumstances under which an application for leave to reopen a hearing of an interlocutory application could be granted. The court had to consider whether the applicants had demonstrated a sufficient prospect of success in their claim to warrant the freezing of assets and whether there was a need to reopen the hearing due to new evidence or developments in the case.

In its reasoning, the court first addressed the application for leave to reopen the hearing of the interlocutory application. The court found that the applicants had not provided sufficient grounds to warrant the reopening of the hearing. However, the court did consider the application for freezing orders against third parties. The court concluded that the applicants had demonstrated a sufficient prospect of success in their claim to warrant the freezing of assets. The court also found that the applicants had not shown that the existing freezing orders were insufficient to protect their interests. Consequently, the court granted leave to amend the existing freezing orders to include additional third parties and assets. The court emphasized the importance of balancing the interests of all parties involved in the case and ensuring that the freezing orders were not overly burdensome or oppressive to the third parties.

The court's final orders included amending the existing freezing orders to include additional third parties and assets, and directing the parties to prepare orders reflecting the court's reasons. The court also adjourned the proceedings for argument on the final form of the orders. The court's decision highlighted the importance of carefully considering the circumstances of each case when granting freezing orders and the need to balance the interests of all parties involved. The court's decision also demonstrated the importance of providing clear and detailed reasons for its decisions, particularly in complex cases involving multiple parties and significant assets.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days of the date of this judgment, the parties file and serve either:

(a) a joint proposed minute of order giving effect to these reasons; or

(b) in the event of disagreement, proposed minutes of order with short written submissions in support.

2. Further to the freezing orders dated 30 January 2015 as varied by orders dated 11 February 2015, 13 February 2015, 21 May 2015, 23 June 2015 and 29 June 2015, the amount of $7,122,377.00 deposited in a controlled monies or trust account operated by the Australian Government solicitor (‘Account’) on 8 September 2015 remain in the Account until further order;

3. The proceedings be adjourned for argument on the final form of the orders on a date to be fixed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thus, Palmer J concluded that the possibility that a trustee in bankruptcy of the first defendant might ultimately obtain contribution from a surplus of assets of the second defendant brought the case within the principle set out at paragraph 30(4) above.At [15], his Honour concluded:It is unrealistic to suppose that [the first defendant], as a 50% shareholder of [the second defendant] and as a co-director of [the second defendant] with his wife, cannot have any influence in the fraudulent disposition of [the second defendant]’s assets if he were minded to engage in such a course of action to prevent the Plaintiff from recovering any fruits of a judgment against him.FACTS The application follows the completion of the trial in the proceeding. The trial commenced on 31 August 2015 and continued until 9 September 2015. Further submissions were made on 28 and 29 September 2015. Judgment is now reserved.Rawbin Finances, BINQLD and Kambala Andrew Binetter is the sole director and company secretary of each of Rawbin Finances, BINQLDL and Kambala. The sole shareholder of Rawbin Finances is Andrew Binetter. The sole shareholder of each of BINQLDL and Kambala is Michael Binetter, the sixth respondent.Commissioner of Taxation The Commissioner is the sole creditor of the applicants with the possible exception of one or more related entities which the liquidators do not appear to accept are creditors.Original freezing orders On 30 January 2015, Mr Binetter gave an undertaking to the Court until 4pm on 11 February 2015 to refrain from removing from Australia or in any way disposing of, dealing with or diminishing the value of his assets in Australia to the extent that those assets did not exceed an unencumbered value of AUD 15 million. Besanko J also made an order against, relevantly, Nudie Franchising Systems Pty Ltd, Nudie Foods Pty Ltd, Nudie Pty Ltd, Real Juice Pty Ltd and Nudie Foods Australia Pty Ltd (collectively the “third parties”) restraining the third parties from removing from Australia or in any way disposing of, dealing with or diminishing the value of their assets in Australia to the extent that those assets did not exceed an unencumbered value of AUD 15 million (“the freezing order”). On 11 February 2015, the freezing order was varied, relevantly by including Tamarama Fresh Juices Australia Pty Ltd (“Tamarama”) as a third party.] On 13 February 2015, the freezing order was further varied by Besanko J, relevantly, to make Mr Binetter subject to the freezing order: BCI Finances Pty Limited (in liq) v GR Binetter as the Representative of the Estate of E Binetter [2015] FCA 86. At [11], Besanko J noted that the freezing order was supported by an undertaking as to damages to the extent of $500,000. There was no evidence on this application that the undertaking was sufficient, although Mr Williams SC questioned its adequacy.Andrew Binetter’s 11 March 2015 affidavit On 11 March 2015, Andrew Binetter swore an affidavit setting out, relevantly, his assets, their value to the extent known to him and their location and encumbrances.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no evidence that would lead me to conclude that the present undertaking as to damages may be insufficient.CONCLUSION I will direct the parties to prepare orders reflecting my reasons above. I will hear the parties on costs and on any exceptions which ought to apply to the freezing orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, Mr Williams SC submitted that the applicants do not bring themselves within rule 7.35(5)(b). The evidence is to the contrary, namely that the payment was not a gift.CONSIDERATION The applicants did not ultimately identify a process under which either BINQLDL or Kambala may be obliged to disgorge assets or contribute toward satisfying a judgment against Andrew Binetter. They did not put a case that such a process might apply in relation to any judgment against Michael Binetter. Accordingly, I am not satisfied that the proposed order should be made against either BINQLDL or Kambala. As to Rawbin Finances, I accept that there must be a prospect that, in the event of a judgment against Andrew Binetter in this proceeding, he will have insufficient funds to pay the judgment debt, leading to his bankruptcy and the appointment of a trustee in bankruptcy in the manner described by Palmer J in Audio Products. As judgment has been reserved, this is not a remote prospect. There was no evidence of the precise prejudice to Rawbin Finances if it continues to be deprived of the use of the funds currently frozen. I accept that the applicants have delayed in seeking to freeze Rawbin Finances’ funds. On the other hand, the funds were not transferred to Rawbin Finances until 1 September 2015. Thereafter, they were not used for Rawbin Finances’ business activities. In the circumstances, I do not conclude that the applicants’ delay disentitles them from the relief sought against Rawbin Finances. There is no evidence that would lead me to conclude that the present undertaking as to damages may be insufficient.CONCLUSION I will direct the parties to prepare orders reflecting my reasons above. I will hear the parties on costs and on any exceptions which ought to apply to the freezing orders.