BBG21 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

BBG21 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2025] FedCFamC2G 801

File number(s): SYG 730 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE ZIPSER
Date of judgment: 29 May 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – judicial review – decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal refusing to grant protection visa – whether Tribunal erred in finding inconsistency and embellishment in applicant’s evidence - whether Tribunal failed to assess significance and weight of inconsistency – whether Tribunal misunderstood or failed to consider applicant’s explanation for inconsistency - application dismissed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36(2)(a), 36(2)(aa), 65, 476
Cases cited: BEL16 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 1678; 167 ALD 295
Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 55
Date of hearing: 7 May 2025
Place: Parramatta
Counsel for the Applicant: O R Jones
Solicitor for the Applicant: Ray Turner Immigration Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr G Johnson
Solicitor for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

SYG 730 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

BBG21

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE ZIPSER

DATE OF ORDER:

29 MAY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The name of the first respondent is amended to “Minister for Immigration and Citizenship”.

2.The application is dismissed.

3.The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs in the sum of $8,371.30.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE ZIPSER

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 23 April 2021, the applicant lodged an application for judicial review, pursuant to s 476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act), of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) dated 19 March 2021. The Tribunal affirmed the decision of a delegate of the first respondent refusing to grant the applicant a protection (subclass 866) visa under s 65 of the Act.

  2. For the reasons that follow, the application is dismissed.

    FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  3. In November 2015, the applicant, a citizen of Lebanon, first arrived in Australia on a visitor visa.  

  4. On 21 March 2016, the applicant applied for a protection visa. The applicant claimed to fear a real risk of serious harm if she returned to Lebanon.

  5. On 28 April 2017, a delegate of the first respondent, after interviewing the applicant on 18 April 2017, made a decision refusing to grant the visa.

  6. On 22 May 2017, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision.

  7. On 29 January 2021, the Tribunal invited the applicant to attend a hearing on 11…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BBG21 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 801
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a citizen of Lebanon, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) affirming a decision of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship not to grant her a protection visa. The applicant argued that the Tribunal erred in finding inconsistency and embellishment in her evidence, failed to assess the significance and weight of any inconsistency, misunderstood or failed to consider her explanation for the inconsistency, and erred in concluding she was not credible. The court was required to determine whether the Tribunal’s assessment of the applicant’s credibility was legally reasonable and whether any error was material to the outcome.

The court examined the Tribunal’s reasoning process and the applicant’s arguments challenging that process. The Tribunal identified inconsistencies between the applicant's accounts provided to the delegate and to the Tribunal, and noted the accounts were embellished. The Tribunal concluded the inconsistencies and embellishments cast serious doubt on the applicant's claim of adverse attention from Hezbollah in September 2014. The court found the Tribunal's assessment was not legally unreasonable. The Tribunal appropriately considered the applicant's explanation for the inconsistencies and weighed the significance of any inconsistency in assessing credibility. The Tribunal was entitled to conclude the applicant’s accounts were not credible based on the inconsistencies and embellishments.

Accordingly, the application for judicial review was dismissed. The Tribunal did not err in finding the applicant’s evidence inconsistent and embellished, in assessing the significance of the inconsistencies, or in concluding the applicant was not a credible witness. Any errors identified by the applicant did not affect the outcome. The Tribunal's decision affirming the Minister's decision was legally sound.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, the application is dismissed.FACTUAL BACKGROUND In November 2015, the applicant, a citizen of Lebanon, first arrived in Australia on a visitor visa. On 21 March 2016, the applicant applied for a protection visa. The applicant claimed to fear a real risk of serious harm if she returned to Lebanon. On 28 April 2017, a delegate of the first respondent, after interviewing the applicant on 18 April 2017, made a decision refusing to grant the visa. On 22 May 2017, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision. On 29 January 2021, the Tribunal invited the applicant to attend a hearing on 11 March 2021. On 11 March 2021, the applicant, assisted by her representative, appeared before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments. On 19 March 2021, the Tribunal made a decision affirming the decision of the delegate not to grant the applicant a protection visa.TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal at [3]-[13] summarised the applicant’s claims in her protection visa application. The applicant claimed that in September 2014 she was involved in an incident in Lebanon with armed men. Following this, she was the victim of an attempted murder. She then left Lebanon because she feared being harmed further. The Tribunal at [14]-[22] summarised the delegate’s decision dated 28 April 2017 and some documentary evidence provided by the applicant to the Tribunal. The Tribunal at [23]-[54] considered the applicant’s evidence to the Tribunal at the hearing on 11 March 2021. The Tribunal at [55]-[60] considered country information. The Tribunal at [67]-[80] considered the applicant’s credibility, as well as the applicant’s claims concerning events which occurred to her in Lebanon. The Tribunal, after making an upfront finding at [67] that it did “not accept aspects of the applicant’s claims are credible or reliable”, set out reasons in support of this finding at [68]-[79]. The Tribunal then concluded at [79] that the applicant “is not a credible witness”. The Tribunal at [70]-[79] also made findings rejecting parts of the applicant’s claims. The Tribunal at [81]-[85] considered claims by the applicant that she was at risk of harm as a single divorced woman in Lebanon, because of the current political situation in Lebanon, because she will be perceived as wealthy on return to Lebanon, and that she will be harmed in Lebanon by the economic situation. The Tribunal was not satisfied the applicant faced a real chance of serious harm in relation to any of these matters. The Tribunal at [86] concluded that the applicant was not a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations under s 36(2)(a) of the Act. The Tribunal at [87]-[90] considered the complementary protection criterion for a protection visa and concluded that the applicant was not a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations under s 36(2)(aa) of the Act.PROCEEDINGS IN THIS COURT Judicial review application and steps up to hearing on 7 May 2025

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 19 March 2021, the Tribunal made a decision affirming the decision of the delegate not to grant the applicant a protection visa.TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal at [3]-[13] summarised the applicant’s claims in her protection visa application. The applicant claimed that in September 2014 she was involved in an incident in Lebanon with armed men. Following this, she was the victim of an attempted murder. She then left Lebanon because she feared being harmed further. The Tribunal at [14]-[22] summarised the delegate’s decision dated 28 April 2017 and some documentary evidence provided by the applicant to the Tribunal. The Tribunal at [23]-[54] considered the applicant’s evidence to the Tribunal at the hearing on 11 March 2021. The Tribunal at [55]-[60] considered country information. The Tribunal at [67]-[80] considered the applicant’s credibility, as well as the applicant’s claims concerning events which occurred to her in Lebanon. The Tribunal, after making an upfront finding at [67] that it did “not accept aspects of the applicant’s claims are credible or reliable”, set out reasons in support of this finding at [68]-[79]. The Tribunal then concluded at [79] that the applicant “is not a credible witness”. The Tribunal at [70]-[79] also made findings rejecting parts of the applicant’s claims. The Tribunal at [81]-[85] considered claims by the applicant that she was at risk of harm as a single divorced woman in Lebanon, because of the current political situation in Lebanon, because she will be perceived as wealthy on return to Lebanon, and that she will be harmed in Lebanon by the economic situation. The Tribunal was not satisfied the applicant faced a real chance of serious harm in relation to any of these matters. The Tribunal at [86] concluded that the applicant was not a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations under s 36(2)(a) of the Act. The Tribunal at [87]-[90] considered the complementary protection criterion for a protection visa and concluded that the applicant was not a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations under s 36(2)(aa) of the Act.PROCEEDINGS IN THIS COURT Judicial review application and steps up to hearing on 7 May 2025 On 23 April 2021, the applicant lodged in this Court an application for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision. Following a period of inactivity, on 14 March 2025 the registry of the Court informed the parties that the matter was listed for hearing on 7 May 2025. On 15 April 2025, the applicant filed an amended application (Amended Application) which advanced a single ground (as written):1.The Tribunal adopted a legally unreasonable process of reasoning in assessing the applicant’s credibility and thereby committed jurisdictional error. Particularsa. At [70] of its decision, the Tribunal identified inconsistencies between the applicant’s account of the September 2014 incident before the delegate and before the Tribunal in circumstances where there was no real inconsistency.b. The Tribunal did not assess the extent or significance of any such inconsistency, or explain how the inconsistency demonstrated that the applicant’s account was not credible.c. The Tribunal mischaracterised or misunderstood the applicant’s explanation for any inconsistencies.d. The Tribunal’s identification of a motive for the applicant to lie did not demonstrate that she had in fact lied. e. At [71] of its decision, the Tribunal identified inconsistencies between the applicant’s account of the February 2015 incident but did not explain why it had rejected the applicant’s explanation for those inconsistencies. f. The Tribunal impugned the applicant’s credit in relation to the February 2015 incident on the basis that she could not have accurately heard certain words being said, when the real question was whether she honestly believed those words were said.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Counsel then made oral submissions which supplemented their written submissions.CONSIDERATIONGround 1 – particulars (a)-(d) The applicant claimed that in September 2014 an incident occurred which brought her to the attention of Hezbollah. The Tribunal at [67]-[70] considered the claim. The Tribunal expressed the view in the last sentence of [70] that “the inconsistencies and embellishments in the applicant’s evidence cast serious doubt on the claim that she came to the adverse attention of Hezbollah in September 2014”. Particulars (a)-(d) in ground 1 contend the Tribunal “adopted a legally unreasonable process of reasoning” in reaching its opinion in the last sentence of [70]. To assess the applicant’s contention in particulars (a)-(d), it is necessary to consider the Tribunal’s reasoning process and the applicant’s attack on the reasoning process. The Tribunal stated at [67]-[70]:[67] The applicant has claimed to be a divorcee who was first harmed by Hezbollah in September 2014. Her evidence regarding that incident, discussed in more detail below, has been inconsistent and developing. The applicant has also claimed that she was subsequently stalked, threatened and intimated, and in February 2015 she was the victim of an attempted murder … For the following reasons, the Tribunal does not accept aspects of the applicant’s claims are credible and reliable.[68] In her written application, the applicant claimed that she was in dispute with Hezbollah members having been caught filming burning tyres blocking the road to Beirut airport. She claimed that on being spotted filming, “armed men” pushed her to the ground, took her camera and mobile phone and then brutally kicked her. The applicant has provided to the Tribunal copy of the delegate’s decision record. It records that the applicant’s oral evidence provided at her interview differed with respect to this alleged event. She claimed that she was initially in an argument with a man who tried to divert her through Al Dahia, a Shia suburb near the airport. She claimed that when she was out of the car he grabbed her mobile phone and the man subsequently found a caricature of the Hezbollah leader Nasrallah on her phone and angrily demanded to know if she was making fun of Nasrallah. She claimed that then another two men came to see what was going on and one warned her what could happen to her as they were in authority. She claimed, when she tried to take her mobile phone back, they started kicking her. [69] The Tribunal notes that in her oral evidence at her hearing the applicant gave a somewhat different account of what happened in September 2014. She told the Tribunal she was on her way to work when a Hezbollah member was diverting traffic through the Al Dahia area. She indicated that she could not do this because she did not know her way around and she needed to go to work. He insisted that she take the diversion. She started arguing with him and pleaded that she be allowed to proceed so she could go to work but he did not care. She then took out her phone to send her boss a message to explain why she was late and to notify clients and to film the roadblock. The Hezbollah member told her to get out of the car and asked what she was filming and they started screaming at each other. This attracted the attention of two other men who came up and asked what they were arguing about. The first man told them that she was filming. She claimed the superior took her phone and found a caricature of Nasrallah. He asked if she was making fun of their leader. At the hearing she emphasised that she was screaming at them and arguing with them. She claimed one Hezbollah member was kicking her on the leg. She introduced a new claim that she then went off at him and said works to the effect “that’s enough. You are killing us”, to which they replied “you haven’t seen what we can do”. She claimed however that they returned her phone so she could call someone for help.[70] The Tribunal appreciates that the alleged event occurred over six years ago. However it notes that her account to the Tribunal differs to that provided to the delegate (which differed significantly to the written claims) and is somewhat embellished in that she now asserts that she argued and screamed at three armed Hezbollah members. This was despite acknowledging to the Tribunal that she was scared of Hezbollah members. The Tribunal has some doubts that the applicant would have engaged with three armed Hezbollah members in the manner she described at the hearing. It also notes that she did not mention in the written application the Hezbollah member finding the caricature on her phone. It has taken into account her explanation for this, that her first representative omitted to include it in her written application. However it is of the view that this is an important, highly relevant claim and it is not satisfied it would have been left out of her written application if it had in fact occurred. The Tribunal is concerned that the applicant has embellished her oral evidence at the hearing to overcome the issued raised by the delegate, that Hezbollah does not target ordinary Lebanese citizens and non-Shia critics of Hezbollah would not be a risk of harm unless they presented a direct threat to Hezbollah’s political power. Overall the Tribunal is of the view the inconsistences and embellishments in the applicant’s evidence cast serious doubt on the claim that she came to the adverse attention of Hezbollah in September 2014.