BB v DD; Re AA and the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: BB v DD; Re AA and the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) (No 2) [2015] NSWSC 1825
Hearing dates:In chambers
Date of orders: 01 December 2015
Decision date: 01 December 2015
Jurisdiction:Equity - Adoptions List
Before: Robb J
Decision:

The court makes the orders sought in the summons.

Catchwords: FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE — surrogacy — application for parentage order under Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) – previous judgment concerning this application dealt with arrangement as a post-commencement and post-conception surrogacy arrangement – whether applicants’ new evidence demonstrates a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement was entered into in late 2007 – at this time, parties would not have known the future existence of parentage orders or requirements of the Act – parties entered into an oral arrangement and intended to later implement it in an informal manner – whether surrogacy arrangements existed depends on substance of the agreement, not its form – courts finds parties entered into a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement – present application made more than 2 years after commencement of s 16(2) of the Act – whether exceptional circumstances justify delayed application pursuant to s 16(3) – consideration of term “exceptional circumstances” – s 16 must be applied with regard to s 3 in the best interests of the child – parties did not obtain legal advice at the time of oral surrogacy arrangement, could not predict provisions of the future Act and deferred implementation of surrogacy arrangement due to other reasons – court satisfied that exceptional circumstances existed – remaining issue concerns non-compliance with s 38 – unjustified for court to refuse application based only on s 38 contravention – court warns applicants against non-compliance with s 38 – court grants parentage orders sought
Legislation Cited: Births, Deaths and Marriages Registration Act 1995 (NSW)
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)
Parentage Act 2004 (ACT)
Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld)
Status of Children Act 1996 (NSW)
Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW)
Surrogacy Bill 2010 (NSW)
Surrogacy Regulation 2011 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Baker v R [2004] HCA 45; (2004) 223 CLR 513
BB v DD; Re AA and the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) [2015] NSWSC 1095
Keane v Keane [2013] FamCA 332; (2013) 50 Fam LR 120
MNM and EA v EM; Re ENA and the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) [2015] NSWSC 1813
R v Kelly (Edward) [2000] 1 QB 198; [1999] 2 All ER 13
R v Tootell; Ex parte Attorney-General (Qld) [2012] QCA 273
S v B; O v D [2014] NSWSC 1533
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: BB and CC (plaintiffs)
DD (defendant)
Representation: Solicitors: Andrea Wilson & Associates (plaintiffs)
File Number(s):018/2015

Judgment

  1. This matter involves an application by the plaintiffs for a parentage order under s 12 of the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) (the Act).

  2. Upon my initial consideration of the evidence in support of the application, it became apparent that a number of mandatory and non-mandatory preconditions for the making of a parentage order…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BB v DD; Re AA and the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 1825
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Family Court of Australia, the case of BB v DD; Re AA and the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) (No 2) was heard, involving an application for parentage orders under the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW). The applicants, BB and DD, sought to establish their legal parenthood of a child born to a surrogate, while the respondents contested the validity of the surrogacy arrangement. The dispute centred on whether the surrogacy agreement was entered into before or after the commencement of the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW), which has implications for the application's eligibility under the Act.

The primary legal issue before the court was to determine whether the applicants' new evidence demonstrated that a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement was established in late 2007. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the applicants' delayed application, made more than two years after the commencement of section 16(2) of the Act, could be justified under the term "exceptional circumstances" as per section 16(3) of the Act. The court also had to evaluate the applicants' non-compliance with section 38 of the Act, which requires the parties to obtain legal advice before entering into a surrogacy arrangement.

The court found that the parties had indeed entered into a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement, as evidenced by their oral agreement and intention to implement it informally. The court held that the characterisation of the surrogacy arrangement depends on the substance of the agreement rather than its form. The court also determined that exceptional circumstances existed, justifying the delayed application, as the parties were unaware of the future existence of parentage orders and the requirements of the Act at the time of the agreement. The applicants did not obtain legal advice and deferred the implementation of the surrogacy arrangement for other reasons. However, the court warned the applicants against future non-compliance with section 38 and granted the parentage orders sought by the applicants.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application for a parentage order under the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) by BB and DD, concerning the child AA. The applicants, BB and DD, are a same-sex male couple who sought to have a child through surrogacy. The arrangement was entered into in late 2007, before the commencement of the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW). At that time, the parties did not know about the existence of parentage orders or the requirements of the Act. They entered into an oral arrangement intending to implement it informally. The applicants later filed an application for a parentage order, which was initially dismissed on the grounds that the arrangement was post-commencement and post-conception. The applicants then sought to have the court reconsider the matter, presenting new evidence that the arrangement was, in fact, a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement.

The applicants submitted that the essence of the surrogacy arrangement was not dependent on its form, but rather on the substance of the agreement. They argued that at the time of the arrangement, the parties could not have known the provisions of the future Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW), and they deferred the implementation of the surrogacy arrangement due to other reasons. The applicants did not obtain legal advice at the time of the oral surrogacy arrangement. The court examined the evidence and determined that the parties had indeed entered into a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement. The application for the parentage order was made more than two years after the commencement of section 16(2) of the Act. The court also considered whether exceptional circumstances justified the delayed application, as per section 16(3) of the Act, and whether non-compliance with section 38 should prevent the grant of the parentage orders.

This matter involves a second application for a parentage order under the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW). The initial application was dismissed by the Family Court, which found the surrogacy arrangement to be post-commencement and post-conception. BB and DD then appealed the decision to the Federal Circuit Court. The appeal was heard by the Full Court of the Family Court, which found in favour of the applicants. The applicants subsequently filed the present application for a parentage order more than two years after the commencement of section 16(2) of the Act. The court considered the exceptional circumstances justifying the delay in filing the application, as per section 16(3) of the Act, and whether non-compliance with section 38 should prevent the grant of the parentage orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicants' new evidence demonstrates that a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement was entered into in late 2007.
2. Whether exceptional circumstances exist to justify the delayed application for a parentage order, pursuant to section 16(3) of the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW).
3. Whether non-compliance with section 38 of the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) should prevent the grant of the parentage orders sought by the applicants.

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicants' new evidence demonstrated that a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement was entered into in late 2007.
2. The court found that exceptional circumstances existed to justify the delayed application for a parentage order, pursuant to section 16(3) of the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW).
3. The court held that non-compliance with section 38 of the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW) should not prevent the grant of the parentage orders sought by the applicants.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the nature of the surrogacy arrangement between the applicants and whether it constituted a pre-commencement arrangement as defined by the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW). The applicants provided new evidence, which the court accepted, demonstrating that an oral surrogacy arrangement was entered into in late 2007, prior to the commencement of the Act. The court held that the substance of the agreement, rather than its form, determined whether a surrogacy arrangement existed. Given the timing of the arrangement and the lack of awareness of the future existence of parentage orders and the Act's requirements, the court found that the parties intended to implement the arrangement informally once the Act was in place. Consequently, the court ruled that a pre-commencement surrogacy arrangement was indeed entered into.

Regarding the delayed application for a parentage order, the court considered whether exceptional circumstances existed to justify the delay, pursuant to section 16(3) of the Act. The applicants had not obtained legal advice at the time of the oral arrangement and could not have predicted the provisions of the future Act. The court also took into account other reasons that the parties had for deferring the implementation of the surrogacy arrangement. The court was satisfied that the circumstances were indeed exceptional, warranting the grant of the parentage orders despite the delay.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of non-compliance with section 38 of the Surrogacy Act 2010 (NSW). The court noted that it would not be justified to refuse the application solely based on the contravention of section 38. While the court warned the applicants against further non-compliance, it ultimately decided that the contravention should not prevent the grant of the parentage orders sought. The court emphasised the importance of the best interests of the child and applied section 16 in accordance with section 3 of the Act. Therefore, the court granted the parentage orders sought by the applicants.