Baykal v Cronan

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Baykal v Cronan [2017] FCA 1332

File number: NSD 514 of 2017
Judge: BROMWICH J
Date of judgment: 19 October 2017
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – claim for relief arising from alleged interest in proceeds of sale of bankrupt estate – whether payment was a loan or created an equitable interest by way of a constructive trust – held: no existence of a constructive trust established and therefore no beneficial interest – statement of claim dismissed
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 58(1), 116
Cases cited:

Associated Alloys Pty Ltd v ACN 001 452 106 Pty Ltd (2000) 202 CLR 588

Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Queensland) v Joliffe (1920) 28 CLR 178

Kauter v Hilton (1953) 90 CLR 86

In re Cozens [1913] 2 Ch 478

Dates of hearing: 19 October 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub Area: General and Personal Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 32
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr B Skinner
Solicitor for the Respondents: Grace Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 514 of 2017
BETWEEN:

TONBUL BAYKAL
Applicant

AND: JASON SHANE CRONAN AND TERRY VAN DER VELDE AS TRUSTEES FOR THE BANKRUPT ESTATE OF HAKAN TANDOGAN
Respondents

JUDGE:

BROMWICH J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 OCTOBER 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s statement of claim dated 23 January 2017 be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs on an ordinary basis up to and including 28 July 2017, and on an indemnity basis thereafter.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Revised from transcript

BROMWICH J:

  1. The applicant, Ms Tonbul Baykal, is the mother of Mr Hakan Tandogan.  The respondents are the trustees of Mr Tandogan’s bankrupt estate (Trustees).  This is a claim by Ms Baykal for an interest, by way of a constructive trust, in the proceeds of sale of a unit in West Wollongong, New South Wales (the property), purchased by Mr Tandogan in 2005 and sold by the Trustees.  The claim arises by reason of:

    (1)a $15,000 contribution Ms Baykal made towards the purchase of the property; and

    (2)aggregate contributions of $24,889.41 that she made towards the property mortgage, council rates, water rates and strata levies.

  2. The matter is complicated by the fact that there are no net funds left in the bankrupt estate to satisfy any successful claim by Ms Baykal.

  3. Sometime in October 2005, Ms Baykal paid Mr Tandogan $15,000.  The transaction was recorded in a handwritten document signed by both of them, which stated the following (verbatim):

    Date     19-10-2005

    I Tonbul Baykal lent Hakan Tandogan.  The sum off $15,000 for Deposit to purchoce the unit benig unit 10/1.5 mt keira rd Wollongong N.S.W. 2500

    Witch he did in November 2005

    Tonbul Baykal  Hakan Tandogan

    [signature]  [signature]

  4. It is not in doubt that the money was used for the stated purpose of assisting Mr Tandogan…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Baykal v Cronan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 1332
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Baykal v Cronan, the Federal Court was tasked with determining whether a payment made by the applicant, Ms Baykal, to her son constituted a loan or created an equitable interest via a constructive trust. The case involved Ms Baykal's claim for a share of the proceeds from the sale of a property purchased jointly with her son. The primary issue before the court was whether Ms Baykal had established the existence of a constructive trust over the property, thereby asserting a beneficial interest in the proceeds of its sale.

The court meticulously examined the documentary evidence and affidavits provided by Ms Baykal and her son. The court concluded that there was no evidence to support the creation of a constructive trust at the time the payment was made in 2005. The document evidencing the payment explicitly referred to it as a loan, and Ms Baykal's affidavits reflected a hope of recovering her money if the property was sold, rather than an intended or established trust. The court found that Ms Baykal had not demonstrated the requisite intention or basis for a constructive trust. Consequently, the court dismissed the statement of claim, ruling that no constructive trust existed, and therefore Ms Baykal had no beneficial interest in the proceeds of the sale.

The court also addressed the issue of costs, noting that while the claim was ultimately unsuccessful, it was not entirely without merit. Given the circumstances, the court decided that Ms Baykal should pay the costs of the Trustees on an ordinary basis up to a certain date, and on an indemnity basis thereafter. The final orders of the court dismissed Ms Baykal's statement of claim and directed her to pay the Trustees' costs under specified terms.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s statement of claim dated 23 January 2017 be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs on an ordinary basis up to and including 28 July 2017, and on an indemnity basis thereafter.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the above statements of principle have been considered and applied many times since, it is not necessary to go further. Neither the original document recording the payment of $15,000, reproduced above, nor Mr Tandogan’s statement of affairs of 24 March 2014 give any basis for believing that any trust was intended to be created at the time when the payment of $15,000 was made in late 2005. The most that can be said about the affidavit evidence of Ms Baykal and Mr Tandogan is that they reflect a wish that she would get her money back in the event that the property was sold, not that any trust was intended, let alone created. I am not able to be satisfied that any intention to create a trust existed in 2005, nor that any proper basis exists to infer the creation of a constructive trust.Conclusion Ms Baykal has not established the existence of any constructive trust over the property, and thus no beneficial interest in the proceeds of sale. The statement of claim must therefore be dismissed.Costs The trustees sought an order for indemnity costs. Initially, I thought that that was not appropriate in all the circumstances. While Ms Baykal’s claim was not successful, it was not necessarily so doomed to fail that indemnity costs were necessarily appropriate. That is so even given the fact that declaratory relief is discretionary. However, it is not just the theoretical result that matters, but the practical outcome also. In that regard, the basis for the claimed constructive trust was extremely thin but, more importantly, there was no money to satisfy the claim even if successful. Although the situation may not have been clear to Ms Baykal prior to the matter coming before me on 28 July 2017, at that time I made it abundantly clear to her that there was no money to satisfy her claim. She nonetheless decided to persist despite the situation being explained to her with the assistance of an interpreter. In all the circumstances, I therefore consider that it is appropriate that Ms Baykal pay the costs of the Trustees on an ordinary basis up to and including 28 July 2017, being the date at which I note the Trustees were prepared to have the case dismissed with no order as to costs, and that Ms Baykal should pay costs on an indemnity basis thereafter, up to and including today. The orders of the Court therefore are that:(1)The applicant’s statement of claim dated 23 January 2017 is dismissed; and(2)The applicant is to pay the respondents’ costs on an ordinary basis up to and including 28 July 2017, and on an indemnity basis thereafter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It follows from the foregoing that Ms Baykal’s claim of a constructive trust is a barren exercise for which she cannot receive any money even if successful. However, a futile result is still a result which she, at least on one view, is entitled to pursue. The claim must therefore be addressed, and indeed should be for the purpose of completeness.Consideration Ms Baykal’s claim of a constructive trust depends upon the circumstances in which the payment of $15,000 was made to her son. She deposes to what took place in an affidavit sworn on 13 December 2016 and filed in the Supreme Court of NSW on 14 December 2016 as follows (emphasis in original):3.Around November 2005 my son and I purchased a unit at 10/1-5 Mount Keira Road West Wollongong (the “Property”).4.I could not obtain a home loan because I was not employed but still wanted to purchase the property with my son. My son was working and could get a home loan but did not have sufficient savings for the deposit and other costs of purchasing the Property.5.I had some savings, I borrowed from friends and sold some of my personal jewellery to come up with the money. I gave my son approximately $15,000 around October 2015 [sic] which was used to pay the deposit on the purchase of property, the stamp duty payable and other ancillary costs. The purchase price of the property was $98,000.6.To document the payment of money on 19 October 2005 my son wrote on a piece of paper that I lent him $15,000 for the deposit for the purchase of the Property. My son and I signed this document. Attached as Annexure A is a copy of this document. I did not see it as a loan but rather as an investment. I signed the document so that I had a record of the payment of money. Ms Baykal swore and filed in the Supreme Court a second affidavit on 23 January 2017. That affidavit deposed to the following in relation to the purchase of the property and subsequent events (emphasis in original):3.Around November 2005 my son and I purchased a unit at 10/1-5 Mount Keira Road West Wollongong (the “Property”).4.Before we purchased the Property my son approached me said words to the effect of “I saw a property in Wollongong, I want a new start it is a studio and I can live in it too”. My son had gone through a divorce and I had lost a lot of money that I had contributed to his failed marriage and I did not want to lose money again. I said “I will help you out but I don’t want to lose money like I did with your divorce”. He said “You won’t lose your money, you can have a share in the property and when we sell it you can get your money back and make money from the increase in the value of the property”. I said “Ok, good let’s do it”.5.I could not obtain a home loan because I was not employed but still wanted to purchase the property with my son. My son was working and could get a home loan but did not have sufficient savings for the deposit and other costs of purchasing the Property.6.I had some savings, I borrowed from friends and sold some of my personal jewellery to come up with the money. I gave my son approximately $15,000 around October 2015 [sic] which was used to pay the deposit on the purchase of property, the stamp duty payable and other ancillary costs. The purchase price of the property was $98,000.7.To document the payment of money on 19 October 2005 my son wrote on a piece of paper that I lent him $15,000 for the deposit for the purchase of the Property. My son and I signed this document. Attached as Annexure A is a copy of this document. I did not see it as a loan but rather as an investment. I signed the document so that I had a record of the payment of money.8.I have asked my son to obtain the conveyancing documents for the Property but he told me that his solicitor could not find them because of the time that has passed since the purchase.9.I have also paid for from time to time the mortgage repayments, council rates, water rates and strata levies for the Property.10.I have paid at least $5,000 in mortgage repayments, $2,815.17 for council rates, $1,330.60 for water rates and $15,743.64 for strata levies. Attached as Annexure B are copies of my credit card statements showing some of the payments made by me. The entries on the attached credit card statement which are not blacked out are the entries for the payments for the council rates, water rates and strata levies for the Property.