Bax v Legal Practitioners Admission Board

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bax v Legal Practitioners Admission Board [2020] QCA 71

PARTIES:

CRAIG STEPHEN BAX
(appellant)
v
LEGAL PRACTITIONERS ADMISSION BOARD
(respondent)

FILE NO:

Appeal No 7696 of 2019

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

DELIVERED ON:

15 April 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

25 November 2019

JUDGES:

Morrison and McMurdo JJA and Mullins AJA

ORDER:

1.   Appeal dismissed.

2.   No order as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – QUALIFICATIONS AND ADMISSION – FIT AND PROPER PERSONS – where the appellant previously struck off the roll of solicitors for professional misconduct for backdating documents and persistent dishonesty – where over 20 years later the appellant applied to the Legal Practitioners Admissions Board for a declaration under s 32 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) that without more, the striking off would not adversely affect the assessment of whether he is a fit and proper person for admission as a legal practitioner – where the appellant held a number of licences and registrations in connection with debt collecting, taxation advice, administration of Commonwealth debt agreements, superannuation advice and as a real estate agent – where the appellant expressed remorse for the misconduct that resulted in his striking off – where the Board refused to make the declaration – whether the Board erred in refusing to make the declaration – whether application for early consideration of suitability was appropriate for a person seeking re-admission after being struck off as a legal practitioner

Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld), s 9, s 10, s 31, s 32, s 33, s 35, s 39

Attorney-General v Bax [1999] 2 Qd R 9; [1998] QCA 89, related
Attorney-General of the State of Queensland v Legal Services Commissioner& Anor[2018] QCA 66, cited
Dempsey v Legal Practitioners Admissions Board[2013] QCA 193, cited
Gregory v Queensland Law Society Incorporated [2002] 2 Qd R 583; [2001] QCA 499, cited
KMB v Legal Practitioners Admissions Board (No 1) [2018] 1 Qd R 94; [2017] QCA 76, considered
KMB v Legal Practitioners Admissions Board (No 2) [2018] 1 Qd R 500; [2017] QCA 146, considered
Ex parte Lenehan (1948) 77 CLR 403; [1948] HCA 45, considered

COUNSEL:

G J Radcliff for the appellant
L K Crowley QC for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Legacy Legal for the appellant
Bennett & Philp for the respondent

  1. MORRISON JA:  I have read the reasons of Mullins AJA and agree with those reasons and the orders her Honour proposes.

  2. McMURDO JA:  I agree with Mullins AJA.

  3. MULLINS AJA: On 9 July 2018 Mr Bax applied to the Legal Practitioners Admissions Board pursuant to s 32 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) (the Act) for a declaration that the suitability matters relevant to him, as detailed in his affidavit sworn on 9 July 2018 would not, without more, adversely affect the Board’s assessment of his suitability for admission. The suitability matter that was the primary focus of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bax v Legal Practitioners Admission Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCA 71
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Mr. Bax, had previously been struck off the roll of solicitors for professional misconduct and persistent dishonesty. Over twenty years later, Mr. Bax applied to the Legal Practitioners Admissions Board (Board) for a declaration under section 32 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) that, without more, the striking off would not adversely affect the assessment of whether he was a fit and proper person for admission as a legal practitioner. The Board refused to make the declaration, and Mr. Bax appealed to the Supreme Court. The court was required to determine whether the Board erred in its decision and whether an application for early consideration of suitability was appropriate for someone seeking readmission after being struck off as a legal practitioner.

The court considered the Board's reasons for refusing the declaration, which included the seriousness of the misconduct leading to the striking off, the inherent persistent dishonesty, and the lack of evidence to suggest that Mr. Bax's character had changed over the intervening years. The court noted that the statutory scheme for early consideration of suitability requires a person to be a fit and proper person to be admitted to the legal profession. The court found that the Board's decision was based on a proper consideration of the suitability matters disclosed by Mr. Bax in his original application and that the Board was entitled to reach its resolution on the basis of those matters. The court also found that the application for early consideration of suitability was appropriate in this case, as it allowed the Board to assess Mr. Bax's suitability for readmission based on the information available at the time of his original application.

The appeal was dismissed, and no order was made as to costs. The court found that the Board's decision was not in error and that the application for early consideration of suitability was appropriate in this case. The court did not exercise its jurisdiction under section 35 of the Act in relation to an application for admission, as the appeal was limited to the refusal of the declaration sought under section 32 of the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. No order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The jurisdiction of the court under s 32(5)(b) of the Act is to review the refusal of the Board to make the declaration that was sought by Mr Bax in relation to the effect of his striking off on whether he is a fit and proper person to be admitted to the legal profession. The court is not exercising the jurisdiction conferred on the court under s 35 of the Act in relation to an application for admission.The reasons for the Board’s decision The reasons the Board gave for its decision were set out in the letter dated 28 June 2019 as follows:“(1)the nature of the acts and conduct that led to the finding of professional misconduct and subsequent removal of Mr Bax’s name from the Roll of Solicitors were serious;(2)the persistent dishonesty inherent in the conduct and behaviour that led to Mr Bax’s initial strike off in 1998 is contrary to the high standards of integrity, honesty and candour expected of a member of the legal profession and demonstrates fundamental character flaws.…(3)There is nothing in the material currently to persuade the Board that Mr Bax’s character has changed over the intervening years.” The reference in the reasons to persistent dishonesty inherent in the conduct that led to the striking off is taken from passages in the reasons for striking off (at 20). The Board also noted in its letter that it had reached its resolution on the basis of consideration only of the suitability matters disclosed to the Board by Mr Bax in his original application under s 32 of the Act. The reasons for striking off The Statutory Committee established under the Queensland Law Society Act 1952 (Qld) considered charges brought by the Council of the Queensland Law Society (QLS) against Mr Bax and found them proven and to constitute professional misconduct. The Statutory Committee found Mr Bax guilty of professional misconduct and fined him $15,000. The Minister for Justice and Attorney-General and the QLS successfully appealed to the Court of Appeal against the penalty. The conduct of Mr Bax that resulted in his being struck off can be summarised from the reasons for striking off as follows. Mr Bax was an equity partner in the solicitors’ firm which acted for Mr Douglas Staples. Mr Bax made a note to file dated 20 August 1993 regarding an advance from Mr Staples to his son Bryan to the effect the firm was to prepare a second bill of mortgage to be collateral to a deed of loan also to be prepared by the firm to secure the sum of about $500,000. Mr Bax prepared a mortgage in registrable form in favour of Mr Douglas Staples relating to the half interest of Bryan in certain land. The mortgage secured past and future advances. It was not dated when executed, but the date was inserted by Mr Bax in April 1994 as 30 March 1993. About the same time, Mr Bax prepared a deed of loan which had its date typed in as “the 30th day of March 1993”. The lender named in the loan deed was Mr Douglas Staples and the borrowers were Bryan and his wife Susan. It recited an agreement on the part of the lender to lend $500,000 and included a promise on the part of the borrowers to give a mortgage over the subject property. The second mortgage and the deed of loan were executed at sometime between 20 September 1993 and 14 October 1993. On various dates in May 1994, a meeting of the creditors of Bryan and Susan was held. Mr Bax was elected chairman of the meeting. Proofs of debt totalling amounts in excess of $1.1m had been lodged. The meeting considered and passed a resolution accepting a proposal that a sum of $60,000 be accepted in full and final satisfaction of all creditors’ claims. Bryan was asked during the meeting when the second mortgage in favour of his father was executed. According to the minutes, Mr Bax replied the mortgage was executed “on March 1993”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By letter dated 28 June 2019 the Board informed Mr Bax that it “resolved to refuse to make the declaration under section 32(3)(c) of the Act that the suitability matters the substance of Mr Bax’s application, i.e. his earlier strike off in May 1998 by itself, will not, without more, adversely affect the Board’s assessment of his suitability for admission to the legal profession”. Mr Bax appeals to this court pursuant to s 32(5)(b) of the Act against the refusal.The statutory scheme for early consideration of suitability Under s 31(1) of the Act, a person is suitable for admission to the legal profession only if the person is a fit and proper person to be admitted. Under s 31(2), in deciding if the person is a fit and proper person to be admitted, the Supreme Court must consider each of the suitability matters in relation to the person to the extent a suitability matter is appropriate. The definition of “suitability matter” is found in s 9(1) of the Act. Whether the person is currently of good fame and character is a suitability matter under s 9(1)(a). Section 32 of the Act provides:“(1) This section applies if a person considers a matter may adversely affect an assessment as to whether the person is a fit and proper person to be admitted to the legal profession under this Act.(2)The person may apply, in the approved form, to the board for a declaration that a matter stated in the application, including, for example, a suitability matter, will not, without more, adversely affect the board’s assessment as to whether the person is a fit and proper person to be admitted to the legal profession under this Act.(3)The board must consider the application and do 1 of the following—(a)make the declaration;(b)refer the application to the tribunal for a direction if the board considers a direction would be appropriate;(c)refuse to make the declaration.(4)A declaration made under subsection (3)(a), or under a direction mentioned in subsection (3)(b), is binding on the board unless the applicant failed to make a full and fair disclosure of all matters relevant to the declaration sought.(5)If the board decides to refuse to make the declaration sought—(a)the board must give the applicant an information notice about the refusal; and(b)the applicant may appeal to the Supreme Court against the refusal within 28 days after the day the information notice is given to the applicant.” Under s 33(2) of the Act, the appeal to this court is by way of rehearing, and fresh evidence or evidence in addition to, or in substitution for, the evidence before the Board may be given on the appeal. Under s 33(3), the court may make an order as it considers appropriate. The requirements for an information notice are set out in s 10(1) of the Act. The notice must include the decision and the reasons for the decision. The jurisdiction of the court under s 32(5)(b) of the Act is to review the refusal of the Board to make the declaration that was sought by Mr Bax in relation to the effect of his striking off on whether he is a fit and proper person to be admitted to the legal profession. The court is not exercising the jurisdiction conferred on the court under s 35 of the Act in relation to an application for admission.The reasons for the Board’s decision