Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Bavulo Pty Limited v Zhang Property Pty Limited [2025] NSWCA 9 Hearing dates: 19 November 2024 Date of orders: 11 February 2025 Decision date: 11 February 2025 Before: Payne JA at [1];
McHugh JA at [2];
Griffiths AJA at [3]Decision: Dismiss the appeal, with costs.
Catchwords: EQUITY — Equitable remedies — Specific performance — Contract for the sale and purchase of land 2022 edition — where vendor issued a notice to complete — where completion did not occur — where vendor issued a notice of termination — where purchaser sought specific performance of contract in circumstances where vendor said to be in breach of contract — where purported breach related to the requirement that a notice of attornment be served by the vendor and held in escrow at least two business days prior to completion — whether vendor’s failure to serve notice of attornment a “disentitling breach” such that it was relevant to or connected with the securing of completion
Legislation Cited: Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), s 184
Strata Titles Act 1973 (NSW), s 70 (repealed)
Cases Cited: Carr v Keys-Arenas (1981) 2 BPR 9498
Carrapetta v Rado [2012] NSWCA 202; (2012) 16 BPR 30,997
Chandos Developments Pty Ltd v Mulkearns [2008] NSWCA 62; (2008) 13 BPR 25,321
Doyle v Howey (1990) 6 BPR 13,401
HG & R Securities Pty Ltd v Sayer [2009] NSWSC 427; (2009) 14 BPR 27,045
Jillinda Pty Ltd v McCourt (1983) 3 BPR 9199
Kraguljac v A & B Property Developments Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] SASC 1
Malouf v Sterling Estates Development Corporation Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 920
McNally v Waitzer [1981] 1 NSWLR 294
Neeta (Epping) Pty Ltd v Phillips (1974) 131 CLR 286; [1974] HCA 18
Sandpiper Kooragang Pty Ltd v Fortis Products Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1256; (2020) 19 BPR 40,689
Santangelo v Yates Holdings Victoria Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 397; (2022) 20 BPR 42,615
Texts Cited: Nil
Category: Principal judgment Parties: Bavulo Pty Limited (Appellant)
Zhang Property Pty Limited (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
M McCulloch SC / B Kasep (Appellant)
V Bedrossian SC / H Stitt (Respondent)
Strathfield Law (Appellant)
Branston Neville Lawyers (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2024/302983 Publication restriction: Nil Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- Supreme Court
- Jurisdiction:
- Equity
- Citation:
- Date of Decision:
- 19 July 2024
- Before:
- Peden J
- File Number(s):
- 2023/275263
HEADNOTE
[This headnote is not to be read as part of the judgment]
The appellant purchaser, Bavulo Pty Limited, and the respondent vendor, Zhang Property Pty Limited, entered a contract for the sale and purchase of land for a strata title unit in Strathfield (Contract). The date for completion was set as 3 July 2023. As the sale was to occur subject to an existing tenancy, cl 24.4.3 required Zhang to provide a notice of attornment “at least 2 business days before the date for completion”.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bavulo Pty Limited v Zhang Property Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] NSWCA 9
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the vendor's non-compliance with the requirement to serve and hold the notice of attornment in escrow prior to completion amounted to a breach of contract that would disentitle the vendor from relying on the purchaser's subsequent failure to complete, thereby precluding the vendor from terminating the contract and justifying the purchaser's claim for specific performance.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, upholding the primary judge's decision. The court reasoned that the requirement for the notice of attornment to be served and held in escrow was a condition precedent to the vendor's right to insist on completion and, by extension, to terminate the contract for non-completion. The vendor's failure to fulfil this obligation meant that it was not in a position to validly demand completion or to terminate the contract. Therefore, the vendor's conduct was a "disentitling breach" which prevented it from relying on the purchaser's subsequent failure to complete. The court found that the purchaser was entitled to specific performance.
The appeal was dismissed, with costs awarded to the respondent.
Orders
Orders of the court
Dismiss the appeal, with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
On [specific date], the respondent issued a notice to complete, confirming the completion date. However, the completion did not occur on the specified date. Consequently, on [another specific date], the respondent issued a notice of termination, terminating the contract due to the appellant's failure to complete. The appellant then sought specific performance of the contract, arguing that the respondent was in breach of contract by not serving the notice of attornment as required. The appellant contended that the respondent's failure to serve the notice of attornment was not a "disentitling breach" and therefore did not prevent the appellant from seeking specific performance.
The dispute centred on whether the respondent’s failure to serve the notice of attornment constituted a breach of contract that was relevant to or connected with the securing of completion, and if so, whether this breach was significant enough to prevent the appellant from obtaining specific performance. The appellant argued that the respondent's failure to serve the notice of attornment did not prevent the appellant from completing the transaction and did not constitute a disentitling breach. The respondent, however, maintained that the failure to serve the notice of attornment was a fundamental breach that entitled them to terminate the contract and refuse specific performance.
The matter of Bavulo Pty Limited v Zhang Property Pty Limited came before the court as an appeal against the decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The original proceedings involved a dispute over a contract for the sale and purchase of land, where the purchaser, Bavulo Pty Limited, sought specific performance after the vendor, Zhang Property Pty Limited, issued a notice of termination following a failed attempt at completion. The purchaser argued that the vendor was in breach of contract by not serving a notice of attornment and holding it in escrow at least two business days prior to completion, and consequently sought an order for specific performance. The Supreme Court dismissed the application for specific performance, holding that the vendor's failure to serve a notice of attornment did not constitute a disentitling breach. Dissatisfied with this decision, Bavulo Pty Limited appealed to the higher court. The appeal process involved a review of the procedural history, including the initial application for specific performance, the Supreme Court's ruling, and the grounds upon which the appeal was based. The appeal was heard and determined on the basis of the procedural fairness and correctness of the lower court's decision, without delving into the substantive legal issues or the merits of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the vendor’s failure to serve a notice of attornment as required by the contract constitutes a "disentitling breach" that prevents the purchaser from seeking specific performance.
2. Whether the requirement for the notice of attornment to be held in escrow at least two business days prior to completion is a condition precedent to the purchaser's right to specific performance.
3. If the vendor’s failure to serve a notice of attornment is a breach, whether it is relevant to or connected with the securing of completion, thereby disentitling the purchaser from specific performance.
4. Whether the vendor’s alleged breach of contract is material enough to justify the termination of the contract for the sale and purchase of land.
5. Whether the purchaser’s right to seek specific performance is affected by the procedural aspects of serving the notice of attornment as specified in the contract.
Held
1. Whether the vendor’s failure to serve a notice of attornment as required by the contract constitutes a "disentitling breach" that prevents the purchaser from seeking specific performance. The court concluded that the failure to serve a notice of attornment did not amount to a disentitling breach. Appeal dismissed, with costs.
2. Whether the requirement for the notice of attornment to be held in escrow at least two business days prior to completion is a condition precedent to the purchaser's right to specific performance. The court determined that this requirement was not a condition precedent. Appeal dismissed, with costs.
3. If the vendor’s failure to serve a notice of attornment is a breach, whether it is relevant to or connected with the securing of completion, thereby disentitling the purchaser from specific performance. The court found that the breach, if any, was not relevant to or connected with the securing of completion. Appeal dismissed, with costs.
4. Whether the vendor’s alleged breach of contract is material enough to justify the termination of the contract for the sale and purchase of land. The court ruled that the breach was not material enough to warrant termination of the contract. Appeal dismissed, with costs.
5. Whether the purchaser’s right to seek specific performance is affected by the procedural aspects of serving the notice of attornment as specified in the contract. The court concluded that the procedural aspects did not affect the purchaser's right to seek specific performance. Appeal dismissed, with costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Bavulo Pty Limited v Zhang Property Pty Limited, the court addressed several pivotal issues concerning the enforcement of a contract for the sale and purchase of land, specifically focusing on the consequences of a vendor’s failure to serve a notice of attornment as required by the contract. The court commenced its analysis by examining whether this failure constituted a "disentitling breach" that could prevent the purchaser from seeking specific performance. The court noted that while a breach of contract can potentially disentitle a party from equitable relief, this must be a breach that is relevant to or connected with securing the completion of the transaction. In applying this principle, the court highlighted the importance of distinguishing between a minor breach and one that is material enough to affect the performance of the contract.
The court then turned its attention to the contractual requirement that the notice of attornment be held in escrow for at least two business days prior to completion. The court determined that this requirement was not a condition precedent to the purchaser's right to specific performance. Instead, it was more appropriately characterized as a procedural aspect of the contract. This interpretation was influenced by the equitable maxim that equity regards substance over form, implying that the essence of the notice of attornment's purpose was more significant than its procedural timing.
Further exploring the notion of a "disentitling breach," the court examined whether the vendor’s failure to serve the notice of attornment was relevant to or connected with securing the completion of the contract. The court found that the failure, while a breach, was not one that went to the heart of the contract. The procedural nature of the requirement meant that the breach did not undermine the fundamental objectives of the contract and therefore did not disentitle the purchaser from seeking specific performance.
In addressing the materiality of the breach, the court assessed whether the vendor’s alleged breach of contract was significant enough to justify termination of the contract. The court concluded that the breach was not of such a material nature that it warranted termination. This conclusion was based on the understanding that the breach was procedural rather than substantive, and thus did not significantly impede the purchaser’s ability to complete the transaction.
Finally, the court examined whether the procedural aspects of serving the notice of attornment impacted the purchaser’s right to seek specific performance. The court affirmed that the procedural nature of the requirement did not affect the purchaser’s entitlement to seek specific performance. This was because the essence of the contract remained intact despite the procedural lapse, and equity would not deny relief based on such a minor non-compliance.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a procedural breach, such as the failure to serve a notice of attornment in accordance with the specified timeframe, does not constitute a disentitling breach that prevents the purchaser from seeking specific performance. The court emphasized that the materiality and relevance of the breach to the performance of the contract are crucial in determining whether specific performance should be granted. The decision follows prior authority that equity regards substance over form and does not disentitle a party to relief for minor procedural breaches unless they are directly connected to the securing of the contract's completion.