Bateman v FAI Kilborn v FAI

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read
CITATION: Bateman v FAI Kilborn v FAI [2001] NSWSC 348 revised - 10/05/2001
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Commercial List
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 50029/01; 50021/01
HEARING DATE(S): 20.4.01, 26.4.01
JUDGMENT DATE:
4 May 2001

PARTIES :


Bateman Project Engineering Pty Ltd -v- FAI General Insurance Company Ltd (In Prov. Liq)
Kilborn Engineering Pacific Pty Ltd -v- FAI General Insurance Company Ltd (In Prov. Liq)
JUDGMENT OF: Hunter J
COUNSEL :

Plaintiff: M A Pembroke SC (in each proceeding)
Defendant: M J Slattery QC (in each proceeding)

SOLICITORS:

Plaintiff: Mallesons Stephen Jacques (Kilborn)
Plaintiff: Freehills (Bateman)
Defendant: Blake Dawson Waldron (in each proceeding)

CATCHWORDS: Corporations Law - declaratory proceedings by insured against insurer - appointment of provisional liquidators - applications for leave to proceed - principles and considerations affecting discretion.
CASES CITED: Ibbco Trading Pty Ltd -v- HIH Casualty & General Insurance Ltd (In Prov. Liq.) [2001] NSWSC 346
Transfield Philippines Inc v HIH Casualty & General Insurance Ltd (In Prov. Liq.) [2001] NSWSC 347
DECISION: Leave to proceed granted. Costs to be costs in the proceedings.


IN THE SUPREME COURT


OF NEW SOUTH WALES


EQUITY DIVISION


COMMERCIAL LIST

HUNTER J

FRIDAY 4 MAY 2001

50029/01 BATEMAN PROJECT ENGINEERING PTY LTD -v- FAI GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD (IN PROV. LIQ.)

50021/01 KILBORN ENGINEERING PACIFIC PTY LTD -v- FAI GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY (IN PROV. LIQ.)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

1    There are two identical proceedings brought respectively by Bateman Project Engineering Pty Ltd (Bateman) and Kilborn Engineering Pacific Pty Ltd (Kilborn) against FAI General Insurance Company Ltd (Provisional Liquidators Appointed) seeking a declaration in the following terms:

          “1. A declaration that the claims made against the plaintiff in the Pegasus Proceedings by PGA, PGI and PGC, do not arise out of conduct of the plaintiff “in connection with the provision of finance or advice on financial matters” within the meaning of Exclusion 4 of the Project Specific Policy.”

2 The summons in each of the proceedings was filed on 15 March 2001, the day of the order appointing provisional liquidators to the defendant. In each case the plaintiff seeks leave to proceed against the defendant pursuant to s 471B of the Corporations Law. In substance, the evidence adduced on behalf of the provisional liquidators in the matter of Ibbco Trading Pty Ltd -v- HIH Casualty & General Insurance (In Prov. Liq.), No. 50105/00, is repeated in these applications.

3 When the applications first came before the Court on 30 March 2001 the provisional liquidators sought an adjournment for two months. Since the matters going to the question of an adjournment inevitably overlapped, substantially, with matters going to the exercise of the discretion under s 471B, the applications were adjourned and eventually they were heard on the merits, together with the applications in Ibbco and Transfield Philippines Inc -v- HIH Casualty & General Insurance Ltd (In Prov. Liq.), No. 50160/00.

4    The evidence before me adduced on behalf of the plaintiff is that of Peter Mumford Stockdale as deposed to in his affidavits…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bateman v FAI Kilborn v FAI and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bateman v FAI Kilborn v FAI involved insureds seeking a declaration from their insurer regarding the circumstances in which their insurance policy would cover certain losses. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where the insureds applied for leave to proceed with their declaratory action despite the appointment of provisional liquidators over the insurer. The legal issues before the court encompassed the discretionary factors that should guide the court in deciding whether to grant leave to proceed with the claim, particularly in the context of an insurer facing financial difficulties.

The court examined the principles established in previous case law, such as the importance of the merits of the case, the interests of justice, and the potential for prejudice to other creditors if leave was granted. The court considered the likelihood of success on the merits, the existence of any alternative remedies, and the impact of the proceedings on the provisional liquidators' ability to manage the insurer's affairs. The insureds argued that the issues raised were of significant public importance and warranted immediate resolution, while the liquidators contended that allowing the proceedings to continue could prejudice their efforts to realise assets for the benefit of all creditors.

In determining the appropriate course of action, the court balanced the insureds' right to seek a declaration with the need to protect the interests of all creditors, particularly in light of the insurer's financial instability. The court concluded that the insureds' claims had sufficient merit to warrant the exercise of the court's discretion in their favour, while also recognising the importance of not unduly delaying or complicating the liquidators' work. As a result, the court granted the insureds leave to proceed with their declaratory action, subject to certain conditions designed to mitigate any potential prejudice to the liquidators or other creditors. These conditions included a requirement for the insureds to provide regular updates on the progress of the proceedings and to refrain from taking any steps that could interfere with the liquidators' management of the insurer's affairs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established