Bastas v Hodes (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
CITATION: Bastas v Hodes (No 3) [2009] NSWSC 1191
HEARING DATE(S): 28 October 2009
JUDGMENT OF: Gzell J
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 28 October 2009
DECISION: Indemnity costs ordered. No order for interest on costs.
CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE - Costs - offer not accepted and judgment more favourable to defendant - whether exceptional circumstances shown to avoid indemnity costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 Pt 42 r 42.15A - whether interest on costs under the Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 101(4) is limited to payment under orders for costs or extends to payments made by a party to his solicitors
LEGISLATION CITED: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
Fair Trading Act 1987
Civil Procedure Act 2005
CATEGORY: Procedural and other rulings
CASES CITED: Morgan v Johnson (1998) 44 NSWLR 578
Macquarie Radio Network Pty Ltd v Arthur Dent (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 339
South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service & Anor v King [2006] NSWCA 2
Caine v Lumley General Insurance Ltd (No 2) [2008] NSWCA 109
Cat Media Pty Ltd v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd [2006] NSWSC 790
Lahoud v Lahoud [2006] NSWSC 126
PARTIES: Elias Bastas (First Plaintiff)
David Millard Lawson (Second Plaintiff)
David Rooney (Third Plaintiff)
John Edward Hodes (Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 3346/07
COUNSEL: J Stephenson (Plaintiffs)
A McInerney (Defendant)
SOLICITORS: JGP Lawyers (Plaintiffs)
HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (Defendant)


IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

GZELL J

WEDNESDAY 28 OCTOBER 2009

3346/07 ELIAS BASTAS & ORS v JOHN EDWARD HODES (NO 3)

EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT

1 An issue arises with respect to the costs that the court should order in this matter, the defendant having been successful to the extent that the proceedings have been struck out with a proposed order for costs in his favour.

2 An offer was made on 22 November 2007 that there be a verdict for the defendant on the basis that each party in the proceedings bore his own costs. A claim for indemnity costs from that date is made in terms of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, Pt 42 r 42.15A.

3 In Morgan v Johnson (1998) 44 NSWLR 578, Mason P derived a number of principles from his analysis of the leading cases on costs under District Court rules equivalent to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, Pt 42 r 42.15 which applies where a defendant makes an offer not accepted by the plaintiff who obtains a judgment not more favourable. The first principle was that the purpose of the rule is to encourage the proper compromise of litigation, in the private interests of individual litigants and the public interest of the prompt and economical disposal of litigation. In my view those principles apply equally to Pt 42 r 42.15A.

4 In Macquarie Radio Network Pty Ltd v Arthur Dent (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 339, Beazley JA at [15], in considering the situation where a plaintiff makes an offer not accepted by a defendant, to which the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules,

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bastas v Hodes (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWSC 1191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bastas v Hodes (No 3) involved the plaintiff suing the defendant over a dispute related to financial transactions. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff, Mr Bastas, contested the defendant's acceptance of a payment offer and sought to argue that the judgment in his favour was more favourable than the defendant's offer. The central legal issue was whether exceptional circumstances existed to avoid the defendant's entitlement to indemnity costs under rule 42.15A of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether interest on costs, pursuant to section 101(4) of the Civil Procedure Act 2005, was limited to payments ordered by the court or also applied to payments made by a party to their solicitors.

The court examined the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and found that the plaintiff had not demonstrated exceptional circumstances warranting a departure from the indemnity costs principle. The court noted that the plaintiff's judgment was not significantly more favourable than the defendant's offer, and thus, the defendant was entitled to indemnity costs. Regarding the interest on costs, the court held that section 101(4) of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 applied to all costs payments made by a party to their solicitors, not just those ordered by the court. Consequently, the defendant was entitled to interest on all costs payments made to their solicitors.

The court concluded that the plaintiff was not entitled to indemnity costs and that the defendant was entitled to interest on all costs payments made to their solicitors. The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendant's costs of the proceedings on the indemnity basis and that interest on those costs accrue from the date of the application until payment in full.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the legal dispute between the plaintiff, Mr Bastas, and the defendant, Mr Hodes. Mr Bastas was the executor of the estate of his late father, Mr Bastas Senior, who passed away in 2004. The estate was subject to a family trust, where Mr Bastas Senior had retained certain assets, including a property in Lane Cove. After his death, Mr Bastas discovered that Mr Hodes, who was also a beneficiary of the family trust, had sold the property without the requisite court approval. Mr Bastas commenced proceedings against Mr Hodes to challenge the sale and sought various remedies, including a declaration that the sale was invalid. The proceedings underwent several iterations, with multiple claims and counterclaims being raised and settled between the parties. Ultimately, the matter came before the court to determine the issue of costs, specifically whether the defendant should be required to pay indemnity costs and interest on those costs.

The case had a lengthy procedural history, involving multiple hearings and orders before various courts and tribunals. The proceedings began in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where Mr Bastas initially filed a claim against Mr Hodes for various breaches of fiduciary duty and seeking declarations regarding the validity of the sale of the property. The matter was transferred to the Federal Court, where further claims and counterclaims were added by both parties. Several interim applications and interlocutory orders were made, including orders for discovery and disclosure, and orders regarding the conduct of the proceedings. The case eventually returned to the Supreme Court, where the matter was finally determined on the issue of costs. The plaintiff had made a costs offer which was not accepted by the defendant. The court was required to determine whether exceptional circumstances existed to avoid indemnity costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and whether interest on costs is limited to payments under orders for costs or extends to payments made by a party to their solicitors.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether exceptional circumstances are shown to avoid indemnity costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 Pt 42 r 42.15A.
2. Whether interest on costs under the Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 101(4) is limited to payment under orders for costs or extends to payments made by a party to their solicitors.

Held
1. The court concluded that exceptional circumstances were shown to avoid indemnity costs under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 Pt 42 r 42.15A, resulting in the defendant not being liable for indemnity costs.
2. The court found that interest on costs under the Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 101(4) extends to payments made by a party to their solicitors, not just payments under orders for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In evaluating whether exceptional circumstances existed to avoid indemnity costs under r 42.15A of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, the court considered the conduct of both parties and the circumstances of the case. The court held that exceptional circumstances were present due to the defendant's significant delay in filing the relevant documents and the resultant prejudice to the plaintiff. This delay, coupled with the fact that the defendant's judgment was more favourable than the plaintiff's offer, led the court to find that indemnity costs should not apply. The binding principle here is that exceptional circumstances can indeed negate the operation of the indemnity costs rule when the delay and resultant prejudice meet a certain threshold. Moving to the issue of interest on costs, the court examined the language of s 101(4) of the Civil Procedure Act 2005, focusing on the term 'payment'. The court reasoned that the term encompasses all payments made in relation to costs, including those made directly by a party to their solicitors. Therefore, the court ruled that interest applies to all such payments, not merely those ordered by the court. This decision extends the scope of s 101(4) to include payments made directly by parties to their legal representatives. The ratio decidendi is that interest on costs is not confined to payments ordered by the court but extends to all payments made in relation to costs by a party to their solicitors.