Basnayake v TAFE Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Basnayake v TAFE Queensland [2022] QIRC 444

PARTIES:

Basnayake, Thusitha
(Appellant)

v

TAFE Queensland
(Respondent)

CASE NO.:

PSA/2022/646

PROCEEDING:

Public Service Appeal - Conversion of fixed term temporary employment

DELIVERED ON:

HEARING DATE:

17 November 2022

On the papers

MEMBER:

Merrell DP

DATES OF WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS:

Appellant's written submissions filed on 16 August 2022 and on 5 September 2022 and Respondent's written submissions filed on 1 September 2022 and on 8 September 2022.

ORDERS: 

The orders made in paragraph [42] of these reasons for decision.

CATCHWORDS:

PUBLIC SERVICE - APPOINTMENT UNDER PUBLIC SERVICE AND SIMILAR ACTS - PUBLIC SERVICE APPEAL - Appellant employed on a fixed term temporary basis as a Tutor and Teacher by TAFE Queensland - review of Appellant's fixed term temporary employment - decision to continue Appellant's fixed term temporary employment - appeal against that decision - directions issued for the hearing and determination of Appellant's appeal - Appellant did not comply with directions - whether Appellant's appeal should be dismissed pursuant to r 45 of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 - consideration of reasons given by Appellant for non-compliance with directions - submissions made by parties permit appeal to be fairly determined - operational reasons given not to convert Appellant's employment inconsistent with internal briefing memorandum to decision maker - decision on appeal set aside and returned to decision maker with directions that the decision maker conduct a fresh review of the Appellant's employment status

LEGISLATION:

Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 562C

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011, r 45 and r 97

Public Service Act 2008, s 149B

CASES:

King-Koi v State of Queensland (Department of Education) [2020] QIRC 209

Paul Scott v State of Queensland & Ors [2019] QIRC 115

Reasons for Decision

  1. Ms Thusitha Basnayake is currently employed by TAFE Queensland ('TAFE') as a fixed term temporary employee in the Faculty of English Language and Migrant Education ('the Faculty') as a part-time Tutor and as a part-time Teacher. Ms Basnayake has been employed, on a fixed term temporary basis, as a Tutor since 18 April 2017 and as a Teacher since 8 October 2019.

  2. By email dated 21 April 2022, Ms Basnayake was advised that a review of her fixed term temporary employment was to be undertaken. Ms Basnayake made a written submission in support of her conversion to permanent employment by email sent on 26 April 2022.

  3. By letter dated 13 June 2022 from Mr Brent Kinnane, General Manager of TAFE's Brisbane Region, Ms Basnayake was advised that, arising out of the review, the decision was made not to permanently appoint her based on genuine operational requirements ('the decision'). By appeal notice filed on 4 July 2022, Ms Basnayake appealed against the decision.

  4. By Directions Order dated 5 July 2022, I ordered that Ms Basnayake file and serve written submissions in respect of her appeal by 4.00 pm on 2 August 2022 and that TAFE file and serve its written submissions by 4.00 pm on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Basnayake v TAFE Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QIRC 444
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Basnayake v TAFE Queensland, the applicant, Ms Basnayake, sought review of a decision by TAFE Queensland regarding her employment status as a Tutor and Teacher. The application was heard and determined by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The primary issue for the Tribunal to decide was whether Ms Basnayake's appeal against the decision not to convert her fixed-term temporary employment to a permanent position should be dismissed due to her non-compliance with certain procedural directions, or whether the appeal should proceed and be determined on its merits.

The Tribunal considered the reasons provided by Ms Basnayake for her non-compliance with the procedural directions, which included operational reasons provided by TAFE Queensland. The Tribunal found that the operational reasons given by TAFE Queensland were inconsistent with an internal briefing memorandum prepared for the decision-maker. The Tribunal also noted that submissions made by both parties allowed the appeal to be fairly determined despite the non-compliance. Consequently, the Tribunal determined that Ms Basnayake's appeal should not be dismissed, and it proceeded to consider the appeal on its merits. The Tribunal set aside the original decision and returned the matter to the decision-maker with directions to conduct a fresh review of Ms Basnayake's employment status.

In summary, the Tribunal held that the decision not to convert Ms Basnayake's employment to a permanent position was based on operational requirements that were not consistent with the briefing provided to the decision-maker. The Tribunal ordered that the decision be set aside and returned to the decision-maker with specific directions for a fresh review of Ms Basnayake's employment status.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders made in paragraph [42] of these reasons for decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the decision, Mr Kinnane relevantly stated:Conversion review decisionI have conducted a review of your employment status and have determined that your employment will remain as fixed term temporary at this time. You will continue in the role of Tutor and Teacher until 31 March 2023.Notwithstanding this decision, I am pleased to offer the extension of your current fixed term temporary engagement in line with the existing AMEP contract, being until 30 June 2023. Further, please be advised that your employment status will again be reviewed when the outcome of the upcoming tender process is known.Considerations when making the decisionI have considered the requirements of the Procedure and your employment history with TAFE Queensland, including any previous conversion review decisions. In summary, I have taken into consideration:· whether you are eligible for appointment having regard to the merit principle;· whether there is a continuing need for someone to be employed in the role you are performing, or a role that is substantially the same as the role you are performing; · the relevant genuine operational requirements of TAFE Queensland; and· Part 2 of the Human Rights Act 2019 (HR Act).The decision not to permanently appoint you at this time is based on genuine operational requirements which may impact continuing staffing needs in the AMEP program. Specifically, my reasons are:· TAFE Queensland currently holds the contract for the delivery of the AMEP program, with an end date of 30 June 2023. As advised, your current fixed term temporary engagement will be extended in line with this contract.· While it is anticipated that the tender process for a new contract will commence later this year, it is unknown whether TAFE Queensland will be successful in securing it. Further, it is expected that the terms of the new contract will differ from the current contract terms, which may affect method of delivery, however, this is yet to be confirmed.Consequently, conversion to a permanent role is not appropriate or viable at this time due to genuine operational requirements of TAFE Queensland. The '… AMEP program', referred to in Mr Kinnane's letter, is a reference to the Adult Migrant English Program.Ms Basnayake's submissions Ms Basnayake submits that the decision was not fair and reasonable for the following reasons:·the information provided in the decision is '… inconsistent and incongruent with their actions in fact they are outright contradictory to the requirements under legislation and the continued engagement of the Appellant';·other TAFE employees performing similar duties have been given an opportunity for permanency despite the fact that TAFE was expecting the AMEP contract was coming up for tender in the second half of 2022; and·the fact that TAFE has, on 10 occasions, extended her fixed term temporary employment, that there are no performance issues concerning her and that TAFE currently holds the contract for delivery of the AMEP '… negates the genuine operational requirements argument'.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established