Bashford v Information Australia (Newsletters) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Bashford v. Information Australia (Newsletters) Pty. Limited [2001]  NSWCA 470

FILE NUMBER(S):
40619/00

HEARING DATE(S):               16 November 2001

JUDGMENT DATE: 12/12/2001

PARTIES:
Rex Bashford - Appellant
Information Australia (Newsletters) Pty. Limited - Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Sheller JA Hodgson JA Rolfe AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          CLD 20872/97

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Davies AJ

COUNSEL:
Mr. B. McClintock SC with Ms. M. Kumar (A)
Mr. T.S. Hale SC with Mr. White (R)

SOLICITORS:
Eakin McCaffery Cox, Sydney for appellant
Corrs Chambers Westgarth, Sydney for respondent

CATCHWORDS:
DEFAMATION - Common law defence of qualified privilege - Truth - Contextual imputations - Whether occasion of qualified privilege - Reciprocal duty and interest - Inaccurate report of court proceedings - Whether privilege defeated - Whether additional material protected.  D.

LEGISLATION CITED:
Defamation Act 1974 ss.15, 16

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40619/00
CLD 20872/97

SHELLER JA
HODGSON JA
ROLFE AJA

Wednesday 12th December 2001

BASHFORD  V.  INFORMATION AUSTRALIA (NEWSLETTERS) PTY. LIMITED

Judgment

  1. SHELLER JA:  I have had the benefit of reading in draft the reasons for judgment prepared by Hodgson JA and Rolfe AJA.  I agree with Hodgson JA’s decision and the reasons therefore.  Critical to my conclusion is the opinion that the matter complained of was connected and sufficiently connected with the subject matter of the privileged occasion.  On that point Rolfe AJA disagrees.

  2. The test has been described by various epithets.  In Adam v. Ward [1917] AC 309 the expressions “extraneous matter”, “not relevant and pertinent to the discharge of the duty”, “beyond what was germane and reasonably appropriate to the occasion”, “not really necessary to the fulfilment of the particular duty or right which is the foundation of the privilege on the occasion”, “unconnected with and irrelevant to the main statement which is ex-hypothesi privileged” and “foreign and totally unconnected matter” are used to suggest exclusion from the privilege whereas “germane and reasonably appropriate on the occasion”, “part and parcel of the privileged statement and relevant to the discussion” and “germane to the subject matter of the occasion” are used to suggest protection.

  3. In Bellino v. Australian Broadcasting Corporation (1996) 185 CLR at 228 the majority members of the High Court used the expression “relevant to the occasion”. I do not think any one of these expressions is intended to denote a different idea or a different test. They are different ways of describing what is “relevant to the occasion”.

  4. The defamatory material was contained in the last seven paragraphs of an article headed “MSDS Copyright Case Dismissed”.  Most of that article was directed to a claim of copyright in forty-three “material safety data sheets (MSDS)”.  The Federal Court had dismissed that claim.  The article made the point that if the claim had succeeded it would have had the effect of limiting or impeding access to information which should be available to a workplace where particular…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bashford v Information Australia (Newsletters) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWCA 470
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Bashford v Information Australia (Newsletters) Pty Ltd* concerned a defamation claim brought by the appellant, R. A. Bashford Consulting Pty. Limited, against the respondent, Information Australia (Newsletters) Pty Ltd. The dispute arose from an article published in the respondent's newsletter, "Occupational Health & Safety Bulletin," which reported on a Federal Court decision. The appellant alleged that the article conveyed a defamatory imputation that it had been found liable by the Federal Court for publishing a false report concerning ACOHS Pty. Limited, resulting in damages and costs. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the respondent could successfully rely on the defences of truth, contextual truth, and qualified privilege under the *Defamation Act* and at common law. Specifically, the court had to determine if the imputations complained of were substantially true, if contextual imputations were substantially true and related to a matter of public interest or qualified privilege, and if the imputation complained of did not further injure the appellant's reputation due to the truth of the contextual imputations. The court also considered whether the occasion of publication was one of qualified privilege, and if so, whether that privilege was defeated by any additional material published.

The court found that the defamatory material was contained within the last seven paragraphs of an article discussing a Federal Court decision regarding a copyright claim. These paragraphs explained the context of the copyright claim, which was made in response to an action brought against the claimant. The court held that these paragraphs, including the three containing the matter complained of, were relevant to the discussion of the copyright claim and therefore relevant to the occasion of publication. Applying the principle that expressions such as "relevant to the occasion" describe what is relevant to the occasion, the court determined that the occasion was one of qualified privilege.

The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At a previous hearing before a jury, one of three imputations alleged by the appellant was found to have been conveyed, namely: That the Plaintiff by publishing a false report concerning ACOHS Pty. Limited had been found by the Federal Court of Australia liable to ACOHS Pty. Limited in damages and costs for causing it harm and loss; PRIMARY DECISION Relevantly, Davies AJ dealt with three defences: (1) the defence of truth, pursuant to s.15 of the Defamation Act; (2) the defence of contextual truth pursuant to s.16 of the Defamation Act, on the basis of the following alleged contextual imputations:(i) that the plaintiff was engaged in the business of publication of a newsletter one issue of which was found by the Federal Court of Australia to have contained a false report about ACOH Pty Ltd for which the court awarded it damages and costs for the harm and loss it suffered;(ii) that the plaintiff was engaged in the business of the publication of a newsletter one issue of which was found by the Federal Court of Australia to have constituted false and misleading conduct;(iii) that the plaintiff was engaged in the business of the publication of a newsletter one issue of which was found by the Federal Court of Australia to have contained seriously misleading statements which caused harm to the repute and goodwill of ACOH Pty Ltd;(iv) that the plaintiff permitted an edition of a newsletter to be published which the Federal Court of Australia found to contain a false report about ACOH Pty Ltd for which the court awarded it damages and costs for the harm and loss it had suffered;(v) that the plaintiff permitted an edition of a newsletter to be published the publication of which the Federal Court of Australia found to have constituted false and misleading conduct;(vi) that the plaintiff permitted an edition of a newsletter to be published which contained seriously misleading statements which caused harm to the repute and goodwill of ACOH Pty Ltd.(3) the common law defence of qualified privilege. The relevant sections of the Defamation Act are ss.15 and 16, which are as follows:15(1) Notwithstanding section 11, the truth of any imputation complained of is not a defence as to that imputation except as mentioned in this section. (2) It is a defence as to any imputation complained of that: (a)the imputation is a matter of substantial truth, and (b)the imputation either relates to a matter of public interest or is published under qualified privilege. 16(1) Where an imputation complained of is made by the publication of any report, article, letter, note, picture, oral utterance or other thing and another imputation is made by the same publication, the latter imputation is, for the purposes of this section, contextual to the imputation complained of. (2) It is a defence to any imputation complained of that: (a)the imputation relates to a matter of public interest or is published under qualified privilege, (b)one or more imputations contextual to the imputation complained of: (i)relate to a matter of public interest or are published under qualified privilege, and (ii)are matters of substantial truth, and (c)by reason that those contextual imputations are matters of substantial truth, the imputation complained of does not further injure the reputation of the plaintiff.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Bellino v. Australian Broadcasting Corporation (1996) 185 CLR at 228 the majority members of the High Court used the expression “relevant to the occasion”. I do not think any one of these expressions is intended to denote a different idea or a different test. They are different ways of describing what is “relevant to the occasion”. The defamatory material was contained in the last seven paragraphs of an article headed “MSDS Copyright Case Dismissed”. Most of that article was directed to a claim of copyright in forty-three “material safety data sheets (MSDS)”. The Federal Court had dismissed that claim. The article made the point that if the claim had succeeded it would have had the effect of limiting or impeding access to information which should be available to a workplace where particular hazardous substances were used. The last seven paragraphs were directed to explaining the context in which the copyright claim was made, namely in response to an action brought against the claimant. The last three paragraphs which contained the matter complained of were part of that explanation. In my opinion, those three paragraphs were relevant to the discussion of the claim and therefore relevant to the occasion. For the reasons Hodgson JA has given I agree that the appeal should be dismissed with costs. HODGSON JA: This is an appeal by leave from a decision of Davies AJ given on 12th July 2000, in which his Honour dismissed defamation proceedings brought by the appellant against the respondent.CIRCUMSTANCES The publication complained of was made on about 28th May 1997 in the respondent’s newsletter entitled “Occupational Health & Safety Bulletin”. This was a newsletter for the supply of information on occupational health and safety issues, distributed for an annual subscription of $395.00, with readership comprising persons with responsibility for occupational health and safety within their organisations. The publication concerned a decision given on 9th May 1997 by Merkel J in proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia. Those proceedings had been commenced in 1993 by ACOHS Pty. Limited (ACOHS), seeking relief in relation to allegedly misleading statements in a newsletter called Infax, against two companies involved in the publication of that newsletter, and against a person Bernie Bialkower, who was alleged to be the source of the statements and to have authorised their publication. One of the two companies in question was R. A. Bashford Consulting Pty. Limited (RABC), a company of which the appellant was the principal. However, RABC’s involvement in the publication was somewhat indirect: Infax was published by the second company, Risk Management Concepts Pty. Limited (RMC), in connection with a business owned by the two companies. Mr. Bialkower had brought a cross-claim in those proceedings, claiming that ACOHS had breached his copyright in certain safety data sheets by transcribing them into its database, and seeking an injunction against further infringement of that copyright.