Barton v Lake Macquarie City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Barton v Lake Macquarie City Council [2014] FCA 1103

Citation: Barton v Lake Macquarie City Council [2014] FCA 1103
Parties: KATE BARTON v LAKE MACQUARIE CITY COUNCIL
File number: NSD 140 of 2013
Judge: KATZMANN J
Date of judgment: 13 October 2014
Catchwords:

EVIDENCE – expert reports tendered by applicant as evidence in reply – whether expert reports relevant – whether expert reports properly evidence in reply – whether evidence usurps the function of the judge in determining the issues in dispute – whether it would be unfairly prejudicial to the respondent to use the evidence

WORDS AND PHRASES – “unfairly prejudicial”

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 55, 56, 80, 136
Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 6, 11 15

Australian Law Reform Commission, Evidence (Interim), Report No 26 (1985)

Cases cited: Addenbrooke Pty Limited v Duncan (No 5) [2014] FCA 625
Fulham Partners LLC v National Australia Bank Ltd [2013] NSWCA 296
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705
Ordukaya v Hicks [2000] NSWCA 180
R v GK (2001) 53 NSWLR 317
Date of hearing: 10 October 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: CATCHWORDS
Number of paragraphs: 51
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms K Edwards with Ms N Case
Solicitor for the Applicant: Paul Murphy & Associates
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms C Ronalds SC with Ms B Tronson
Solicitor for the Respondent: John Croce Palmieri, Solicitor

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 140 of 2013

BETWEEN:

KATE BARTON
Applicant

AND:

LAKE MACQUARIE CITY COUNCIL
Respondent

JUDGE:

KATZMANN J

DATE OF RULING:

13 OCTOBER 2014

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT RULES THAT:

1.The evidence of Anne Sutherland Kelly is not admissible.

2.The applicant may read the affidavit of Dr Helen McGrath and tender Dr McGrath’s report in her case in reply, with the exception of the opinion she gives in answer to question 8(a).

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 140 of 2013

BETWEEN:

KATE BARTON
Applicant

AND:

LAKE MACQUARIE CITY COUNCIL
Respondent

JUDGE:

KATZMANN J

DATE:

13 OCTOBER 2014

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR RULING

(Revised from transcript)

  1. Dr Kate Barton was formerly employed by Lake Macquarie City Council as its sustainable living team leader and later coordinator, managing energy, water, waste and transport across the city and in the Council.  She claims that she was bullied by Council employees and that the bullying and the Council’s response to it were in breach of her contract of employment. 

  2. The bullying allegations are primarily directed against one Alice Howe, who originally held a position at an equivalent level to Dr Barton, but who was later elevated to a position as her immediate supervisor.  Dr Barton claims that she made some informal attempts to have the alleged bullying addressed but that the situation deteriorated, rather than…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barton v Lake Macquarie City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 1103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Barton v Lake Macquarie City Council is a case in which the court had to determine whether certain expert reports could be used as evidence in reply. The nature of the dispute involves Dr Barton, who is seeking to hold Lake Macquarie City Council accountable for the conduct of a mediator, Danielle Carney, who was engaged to facilitate his return to work. The legal issues revolved around whether the expert reports were relevant, properly tendered as evidence in reply, whether they usurped the function of the judge in determining the issues in dispute, and whether their use would be unfairly prejudicial to the respondent.

The court examined the evidence provided by Dr Barton’s expert witnesses, including the experts' opinions on the conduct of the mediator. Notably, the court found that neither expert witness provided the facts, matters, and assumptions upon which their opinions were based, which complicated the evaluation of the evidence. However, the court did not find this to be a sufficient ground to exclude the evidence, as no objection was raised on this basis during the trial. The court also scrutinised the relevance of the expert opinions to the issues in the case. It was determined that some of the expert opinions did not pertain to the issues raised in the pleadings and therefore did not deal with the matters in dispute.

The court concluded that while some of the expert evidence was relevant and could be used to resolve issues arising from Dr Barton's case, the evidence of Ms Kelly should not be admitted as it did not address the issues in the pleadings. The court allowed Dr Barton to tender Dr McGrath's report, with the exception of one specific opinion that was deemed irrelevant. This decision balanced the need for expert evidence with the necessity to ensure that the evidence is pertinent to the issues at hand and does not unfairly prejudice the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Dr Barton’s lawyers provided each of the witnesses with a number of documents and then asked them a series of questions. Although each was asked to “list the facts, matters and assumptions” upon which her opinion was based, neither did. This presents some difficulties for the evaluation of the evidence, because it is not at all clear what assumptions of fact were made and therefore what the factual foundations for the opinions were. The situation would have been otherwise if, as is customary, the witnesses had instead been asked to make certain assumptions Dr Barton expected to be able to prove through the lay witnesses and the documents. But these difficulties may be put to one side for the moment at least, because no objection was taken to the evidence on this basis.The evidence of Ms Kelly Ms Kelly’s evidence focusses on the conduct of Danielle Carney, a mediator with a private consulting firm who was engaged by the Council to facilitate Dr Barton’s return to work. In her affidavit Ms Carney states that she was contacted by the Council’s human resources manager, Tim Hopson, to conduct a mediation between Dr Barton and Dr Howe “to assist with the transition of Dr Barton back into Dr Howe’s direct reporting line”. It is common ground that no such mediation ever took place. Dr Barton agreed to a mediation but not with Dr Howe. Ms Carney did, however, have a number of conversations with Dr Barton. They met on 16 August to discuss the return to work plan. Ms Carney also corresponded by email with Dr Barton and on one occasion they had a meeting which Mr Hopson also attended. Ms Kelly’s evidence is said to go to the reasonableness of the requirement to mediate with Dr Howe and the Council’s evidence on the subject. Two questions were asked of Ms Kelly:(1)whether the work done by Ms Carney “as set out in her evidence” was carried out in accordance with national standards for mediators;(2)whether the work done by Ms Carney “as set out in her evidence” was “appropriate” in all the circumstances of the case, including the alleged bullying of Dr Barton by Dr Howe. In short, Ms Kelly answered “no” to both questions. The report was critical of the approach taken by Ms Carney, in particular, of her failure to assess whether mediation was “suitab[le] … as an intervention, with particular regard to power dynamics and occupational health and safety risks”. Putting aside the difficulties presented by the use of the weasel word “appropriate”, neither of these questions is raised by the pleadings and the opinions expressed in the report do not deal with the issue Ms Kelly’s evidence was said to address. Whether or not Ms Carney carried out her work in accordance with national standards for mediators or failed to independently assess whether mediation was suitable in this case is not in issue in the proceeding. Ms Carney is not a respondent. Nor is she an employee of the respondent. The statement of claim has been amended at least five times but Dr Barton has never alleged that the Council is liable for the acts or omissions of Ms Carney.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons it would not be unfairly prejudicial to the Council to use Dr McGrath’s evidence (to the extent that it is relevant) to resolve issues arising from Dr Barton’s case in chief. Conclusion The evidence of Ms Kelly should not be admitted. But Dr Barton may read the affidavit of Dr McGrath and tender her report, save for the opinion given in answer to question 8(a).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.