| I N TFE FEDERiL CCURT OF AUSTPALIA | ) |
| 1 |
| N W SOUTH '~ALZS | D I S T X I C T | R E G I S T R Y | ) | No. | G | 222 of | 1982 |
| GENZRAL GI',IISION |
| ED1:!INA | P.LICE | EARTON |
Prosecutor
:';ESTPk.C BANKING CORFORATIL'N
Defendant
| CORAN: | SHEPPARD J . |
REASONS FOR JUXCMENT
| Thls p rosecu to r fo r a l l eged b reach | i s a | p r o s e c u t l o n l n s t l t u t e d | by | xhe |
| by | the defendant |
| of | s.58 | of | the Trade Pracxlces I?ct 1974 ("the Act"). |
| Sect ion | 58 | 1 s | as fo l lows: |
| "A | c o r p o r a t i o n s h a l l n o t , | I n | t r a d e | or | commerce, |
| accept payment | or other | cons ide ra t ion fo r | goods |
| o r s e r v l c e s | where | a t t h e t i m e | of | the acceptance |
| i t ln t ends | - |
| (a) | n o t | t o | supply goods o r s e rvzces | the goods | o r s e r v l c e s ; | o r |
| (b) | t o | supp ly | ma te r i a l ly |
| d l f f e r e n t | from | the | goods | or | s e r v i c e s i n |
| r e s p e c t o f which | the payment | or o the r |
| cons ldera t lon | i s accepted." |
| The defendant 1 s a banklng | corporenon. | 4 s | zn |
| adJunct to | Its | baRklng | buslness | iT; conducxs a l a r g e |
| t r ave l | bus iness . | Pa r t | o f | t h l s | bus lness | l nvo lves |
| I t | In | wholesa l ing | tours , | mos | t | ly | overseas | tours , | to |
| t r a v e l a g e n t s | who | r e t a i l t h e t o u r s t o t h e l r c u s t o m e r s . |
| I n | 1981-82 | one | s e r l e s o f t o u r s | whlch | was | a v a i l a b l e |
| was knovm as the | "Dlscovery" | series. | These | were |
| tours | to | var | ious places | In | Asia | , | China and other |
| p l aces | In | what 1s known a s T;he Orient . | One such |
| tou r was known as "Dlscovery | Holiday | 526" . | I t | was |
| lncluded In | a brochure contalnlng | a number of |
| "Discoveryt1 | tours. Lumpur, Kuentan | The | l t i n e r a r y was | t o Hong | Kong, |
| Penang, | Kuala | and | Slngapore. | I t |
| was | s a l d t o be a | t o u r whlck! would | ex tend for | 16 | days |
| and |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Barton, Edwina Alice v Westpac Banking Corporation and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1983] FCA 211
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case were whether the defendant intended to supply a service materially different from that for which the payment was accepted, and whether the defendant had the requisite intent to commit the alleged offence. The court considered various submissions, including the defendant's failure to notify its agents of the change, the alleged recklessness and indifference of the defendant in accepting the plaintiff's money, and the defendant's knowledge of the difference in the tour duration.
The court found that while the difference in the tour duration was material, the prosecution had not established the requisite intent on the part of the defendant. The court held that the defendant's agents who accepted the plaintiff's money for the tour did not have the knowledge that the tour they were accepting payment for was materially different from what was advertised. Consequently, the court dismissed the information, and the defendant was acquitted of the criminal charge. The court allowed an adjournment for the parties and their legal advisers to consider the reasons and proposed conclusion and, if necessary, formulate any questions or cases they wished to state or reserve for a Full Court.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi