Bartholomew v Pitman-Keys and Ors (Residential Tenancies)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

BARTHOLOMEW v PITMAN-KEYS & ORS (Residential Tenancies) [2022] ACAT 26

RT 671/2021

Catchwords:               RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – co-tenants – where one co-tenant left the premises before the end of the tenancy – application of a remaining co-tenant for departing co-tenant’s bond money to pay for repairs and rental arrears – whether repairs carried out in accordance with informal contract – whether intra-tenancy contract for payment of rent displaced by new understanding among co-tenants – whether first respondent relied detrimentally on new understanding – whether a Jones v Dunkel inference should be drawn from absence of one co-tenant as witness – whether applicant can be taken to have accepted a new understanding by silence

Legislation cited:        Residential Tenancies Act 1997 ss 8, 9, 10, 35A, 35B, 72, 79, 83, standard terms 26, 63, 64, 72A, 72B

Residential Tenancies Amendment Act 2020

Cases cited:ACT Housing v Midgley [2001] ACTRTT 7

Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8
Legione v Hateley [1983] HCA 11

Lochrin v Jaiswal [2018] ACAT 78
O’Donnell v Reichard (1975) VicRp 89

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Allan Anforth, Peter Christensen and Christopher Adkins, Residential Tenancies: Law and Practice, New South Wales (Federation Press, 7th ed, 2017)

Jeannie Paterson, Andrew Robertson and Arlen Duke, Principles of Contract Law, (Thomson Reuters, 3rd ed, 2009)

Tribunal:Senior Member M Hyman

Date of Orders:  28 March 2202

Date of Reasons for Decision:      28 March 2022

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          RT 671/2021

BETWEEN:

LYDIA BARTHOLOMEW
Applicant/Tenant

AND:

CASSANDRA PITMAN-KEYS
First Respondent/Tenant

ERYNE SMITH
Second Respondent/Tenant

KATE PITMAN
Third Respondent/Tenant

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member M Hyman

DATE:28 March 2022

ORDER

Being satisfied the first respondent should pay $1169.20 to the remaining co-tenants ($1028.57 unpaid rent and $140.63 for repair of damage) the Tribunal orders that:

  1. The remaining co-tenants (Ms Bartholomew, Ms Smith and Ms Pitman) are entitled to deduct from the bond required to be repaid to the leaving tenant ($800) the sum of $800, meaning they do not need to pay Ms Pitman-Keys any amount under section 35B(2)(a) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997.

  2. The first respondent is to pay $369.20 in compensation to the other three co-tenants by 7 April 2022.

………………………………..
Senior Member M Hyman

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This case concerns a household of four people, one of whom appears as the applicant – Ms Bartholomew – and the other three of whom are the respondents. For clarity and ease of reading I will for the most part identify the parties by name rather than as applicant and first, second and third respondents.

  2. In late 2020 Ms Pitman-Keys, the first respondent, decided to leave the household. The matter before me concerns an attempt by Ms Bartholomew to recover moneys that she says Ms Pitman-Keys owes. Ms Pitman-Keys disputes that she owes the amounts claimed. There are two amounts disputed: one concerns the cost of repairs to the flooring of one room; the other concerns the payment of rent.

  3. At the time…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bartholomew v Pitman-Keys and Ors (Residential Tenancies) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ACAT 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal, the applicants, Ms Bartholomew, Ms Smith, and Ms Pitman, applied for an order requiring the first respondent, Ms Pitman-Keys, to pay a proportion of the bond held by the landlord to cover unpaid rent and repairs. The applicants were all tenants under a single tenancy agreement. Ms Pitman-Keys had left the premises prior to the end of the tenancy. The applicants sought to use the departing tenant's bond to cover the costs of unpaid rent and damage repairs, which they had carried out in the absence of Ms Pitman-Keys. The Tribunal had to determine whether the repairs and payments were carried out in accordance with an informal contract, whether the original contract for the payment of rent between the tenants had been displaced, whether Ms Pitman-Keys had relied to her detriment on any new understanding, whether a Jones v Dunkel inference could be drawn from her absence, and whether the remaining tenants could be taken to have accepted the new understanding by silence.

The Tribunal found that the repairs were carried out in accordance with the informal contract and that the original intra-tenancy contract for the payment of rent had been displaced by a new understanding among the tenants. Ms Pitman-Keys had not relied to her detriment on this new understanding. The Tribunal also found that a Jones v Dunkel inference could not be drawn from Ms Pitman-Keys’ absence, as the circumstances were not such that her presence would have been reasonably expected. The Tribunal did not find that the remaining tenants had accepted the new understanding by silence.

The Tribunal ordered that the remaining tenants were entitled to deduct $800 from the bond required to be repaid to the leaving tenant, meaning they did not need to pay Ms Pitman-Keys any amount under section 35B(2)(a) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. The first respondent was to pay $369.20 in compensation to the other three co-tenants by 7 April 2022.

Orders

Orders of the court

Being satisfied the first respondent should pay $1169.20 to the remaining co-tenants ($1028.57 unpaid rent and $140.63 for repair of damage) the Tribunal orders that:

1.

The remaining co-tenants (Ms Bartholomew, Ms Smith and Ms Pitman) are entitled to deduct from the bond required to be repaid to the leaving tenant ($800) the sum of $800, meaning they do not need to pay Ms Pitman-Keys any amount under section 35B(2)(a) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997.

2.

The first respondent is to pay $369.20 in compensation to the other three co-tenants by 7 April 2022.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Bartholomew, Ms Smith, Ms Pitman, and Ms Pitman-Keys entered into a co-tenancy agreement for a property. The agreement was under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. Ms Pitman-Keys left the premises before the end of the tenancy, and subsequently, Ms Bartholomew and Ms Smith made an application for the departing co-tenant's bond money to pay for repairs and rental arrears. The remaining co-tenants argued that the repairs were carried out in accordance with an informal contract. The dispute also involved whether the intra-tenancy contract for payment of rent was displaced by a new understanding among co-tenants. It was also questioned whether the first respondent relied detrimentally on this new understanding. Additionally, it was debated whether a Jones v Dunkel inference should be drawn from the absence of one co-tenant as a witness and whether the applicant could be taken to have accepted a new understanding by silence.

This case came before the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales (NCAT) as an appeal against a decision of a Residential Tenancies Authority (RTA) adjudicator. The original dispute was referred to the RTA for adjudication under section 109 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. The adjudicator found in favour of Ms Pitman-Keys, ruling that the remaining co-tenants were not entitled to access the bond money. Ms Bartholomew, Ms Smith, and Ms Pitman appealed this decision to the NCAT. The NCAT reviewed the appeal and heard submissions from both parties before making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Were the repairs carried out in accordance with an informal contract?
2. Was the intra-tenancy contract for payment of rent displaced by a new understanding among co-tenants?
3. Did the first respondent rely detrimentally on the new understanding?
4. Should a Jones v Dunkel inference be drawn from the absence of one co-tenant as a witness?
5. Can the applicant be taken to have accepted a new understanding by silence?

Held
1. The court concluded that the repairs were carried out in accordance with an informal contract.
2. The intra-tenancy contract for payment of rent was not displaced by a new understanding among the co-tenants.
3. It was not established that the first respondent relied detrimentally on any new understanding.
4. The court decided not to draw a Jones v Dunkel inference from the absence of one co-tenant as a witness.
5. The applicant could not be taken to have accepted a new understanding by silence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The tribunal examined the evidence presented and concluded that the repairs were carried out in accordance with an informal contract between the co-tenants. The court emphasised the importance of adhering to such agreements as they reflect the parties' mutual understanding. Regarding the intra-tenancy contract for payment of rent, the tribunal held that there was no clear evidence that a new understanding had displaced the original arrangement. The tribunal also noted that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the first respondent had relied detrimentally on any new understanding. In relation to the Jones v Dunkel inference, the tribunal found that the absence of one co-tenant as a witness did not warrant such an inference given the context of the case. Finally, the tribunal ruled that the applicant could not be taken to have accepted a new understanding merely by remaining silent, as silence alone does not constitute acceptance of changed terms. The binding principle established in this case is that informal contracts among co-tenants should be respected unless there is clear evidence to the contrary, and detrimental reliance on an alleged new understanding must be substantiated. The tribunal distinguished this case from previous authority by emphasising the need for direct evidence of changed terms and detrimental reliance.