Bartercard Limited v Wily & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      BARTERCARD LIMITED v WILY & ANOR [2001]  NSWCA 262

FILE NUMBER(S):
40409/00

HEARING DATE(S):               31 July 2001

JUDGMENT DATE: 16/08/2001

PARTIES:
Bartercard Limited - Appellant
Andrew Wily and Business Barter Exchange Pty Limited (In Liquidation) - Respondents

JUDGMENT OF:       Handley JA Sheller JA Powell JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          3093/98

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Austin J

COUNSEL:
M W Jarrett - Appellant
P M Wood - Respondents

SOLICITORS:
Castrission & Co - Appellant
The Argyle Partnership - Respondents

CATCHWORDS:
CORPORATIONS - winding up - voidable transaction - unfair preference - meaning of 'transaction'- whether creditor who terminates licence agreement receives benefit

LEGISLATION CITED:
Corporations Law

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs.

JUDGMENT:

THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA  40409/00
ED  3093/98

HANDLEY JA
SHELLER JA
POWELL JA

Thursday, 16 August 2001

BARTERCARD LTD v WILY & ANOR

The appellant operated a reciprocal trade exchange, and also acted as a franchisor in respect of this business.  The respondent was the liquidator of BBX, a franchisee of the appellant.  The appellant terminated the licence to BBX at a point when BBX was heavily indebted to it.  BBX’s business was transferred to the appellant, and the appellant set off the value of the business from the debt owed to it by BBX.  BBX was subsequently wound up.  

The respondent claimed, and the trial Judge found, that this arrangement involved a breach of s588FE of the Corporations Law.  The appellant entered into a transaction at a time when BBX was insolvent, and which was within the six month relation back period.  This transaction conferred a greater benefit on the appellant than it would have received if the transaction had been set aside and it was required to prove for the debt in the winding up.

The appellant challenged the finding that there was a “transaction” and that it had received a “benefit”.
Held: (Per Sheller JA, Handley and Powell JJA agreeing):
The trial Judge was correct in finding that:

  1. The evidence, both documentary and of the parties’ conduct, indicated that the appellant made an offer to BBX , and that BBX either accepted or acquiesced in this offer.  The circumstances gave rise to either a contract or an equitable estoppel binding the appellant. The appellant was not simply exercising its right of termination of the licence agreement.

  2. Having regard to the legislative policy concerning unfair preferences, the term “transaction” is sufficiently broad to cover an arrangement such as this.

  3. Although, with the termination of the licence, the appellant automatically acquired BBX’s customer base, the appellant still received a benefit from the arrangement. This was indicated by the appellant’s willingness to reduce BBX’s debt to it in exchange for acquiring the business.

Legislation:

Corporations Law

Cases cited:

Stehar Knitting Mills Pty Ltd v Southern Textile Converters Pty Ltd (1980) 2 NSWLR 514

ORDERS

Appeal dismissed with costs.

****

JUDGMENT

  1. HANDLEY JA:   I agree with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bartercard Limited v Wily & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWCA 262
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned Bartercard Limited and the official liquidator of BBX, Mr Wily. The dispute arose from the termination of a licence agreement between Bartercard and BBX, which occurred shortly before BBX was wound up. The central issue was whether this termination constituted a voidable transaction under corporate law, specifically an unfair preference. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The court was required to determine whether a transaction occurred between Bartercard and BBX on 28 August 1996, when BBX was allegedly insolvent and within the relevant six-month period prior to winding up. Specifically, the court had to consider if Bartercard's act of setting off the value of BBX's business against BBX's debt to Bartercard constituted a transaction that was voidable under section 588FE of the Corporations Act. The legal question was whether the termination of the licence agreement, coupled with the transfer of BBX's business and assets to Bartercard, amounted to a transaction that provided a benefit to Bartercard.

The court found that a consensual arrangement, rather than a unilateral termination, had occurred on 28 August 1996. This arrangement involved Bartercard terminating the licence agreement and taking control of BBX's business, with BBX's acquiescence and co-operation. The court inferred this arrangement from the substantial preparation by Bartercard, the presentation of documents requiring BBX's consent, and the conduct of the parties on the day, including BBX's director cooperating with Bartercard's takeover of the business. The court concluded that this arrangement constituted a transaction where Bartercard received a benefit by setting off an agreed valuation of BBX's business against BBX's debt.

The appeal was dismissed, with costs awarded to the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 17 December 1996 BBX was wound up on an application filed on 14 November 1996 and Mr Wily appointed the official liquidator. Background Bartercard operated a reciprocal trade exchange by which members of its trading programme exchanged goods and services between themselves. The value of the exchanged goods and services was recorded in “Bartercard Trade Dollars”. Bartercard was the record keeper and directed members to each other for the purpose of facilitating trade transactions. It charged transaction and membership fees. Bartercard also acted as a franchisor granting franchises or licences to selected entities to operate within a specified geographical boundary. Its franchisees were referred to as “brokers” and licensed to use the name “Bartercard” and draw a commission on trading volume and cash transaction fees collected. Bartercard provided credit to members and brokers. Before 28 August 1996 BBX was operating a business as a reciprocal trade exchange under a licence agreement with Bartercard dated 1 July 1994. On 28 August 1996 Bartercard terminated the licence agreement with BBX. At that date BBX was indebted to Bartercard in the amount of $656,292. The circumstances in which the licence was terminated are central to the issues raised in this appeal. What follows is a summary of the primary facts found by Austin J. Bartercard did not challenge these findings. BBX was formed in 1991 to purchase a barter exchange business in the Central Coast area north of Sydney from Bartercard. BBX’s principal director and shareholder was Colin Butcher. From 1991 to 1994 BBX conducted that business as an independent barter exchange. It operated in a manner broadly similar to that of Bartercard already described. The business grew and extended into the Newcastle area. By June 1994 it had approximately five hundred members. By letter of 1 June 1993 Wayne Sharp, then the managing director of Bartercard, put to BBX a proposal aimed to establish a national network within which BBX members would trade. BBX would cease to be an independent barter exchange, and become a franchisee of Bartercard. Bartercard would assist BBX with staff training and systems. According to the letter one of the benefits of the change would be to “ensure a full sale value, as a Bartercard brokerage of approximately $150-200,000 net” compared with an estimated $120-150,000 as a separate exchange. Negotiations in the first half of 1994 resulted in the execution of agreements on 1 July 1994. One of those agreements was for the “conversion” of BBX members to Bartercard membership. Because BBX contemplated selling the Newcastle franchise separate licence agreements were made for the Central Coast and Newcastle areas. The licences were each for a term of five years with a right of renewal for another five years. Neither licence was to be assigned without the prior written consent of Bartercard but that consent could not be unreasonably withheld. The licences were non-exclusive licences to operate the business of providing and facilitating trade for Bartercard members in the designated locality. BBX was to receive 70 percent of the “cash transaction net fees” applicable to trade by the members assigned to the designated locality. Bartercard had the right to terminate the licence agreement immediately on various grounds including (clause 14.3(a) and (b)) BBX’s “repeated and persistent breaches of any duties, obligations and responsibilities required to be performed or observed” by it under the agreement or if BBX passed a resolution to wind up voluntarily or suffered a winding up petition or order to be presented or made against it or entered into any arrangement, reconstruction or composition with its creditors or was otherwise unable to pay its debts.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The plaintiffs alleged and Austin J found that there was a transaction entered into on 28 August 1996 between BBX and Bartercard when BBX was insolvent and within the six month relation-back period. The plaintiffs alleged that the transaction by which Bartercard set off its liability to pay BBX for the goodwill of BBX’s business was void pursuant to s588FE of the Law.Austin J’s Conclusion The plaintiffs submitted to Austin J that on 28 August 1996 Mr Dietz on behalf of Bartercard made an offer to Mr Butcher on behalf of BBX to the effect that the Central Coast licence would be terminated and the business transferred to Bartercard with the consent of Mr Butcher and BBX. The plaintiffs said that Mr Butcher, on behalf of BBX, acquiesced in and co-operated with the termination of the licence and the transfer of the business and other assets and thereby accepted Bartercard’s offer. They invited the Court to infer that there was an agreement or arrangement between BBX and Bartercard. They drew attention to three aspects of the context in which the events of 28 August occurred. First there were the prior negotiations between BBX and Bartercard from which there emerged an understanding between the parties that the licence agreement constituted an investment creating an asset of value, which would not be destroyed unless other avenues had been exhausted. Secondly the plaintiffs submitted that in another case where Bartercard brought a licence to an end it did so in a way that preserved some value for the business. That submission referred to a negotiated termination of the Sunshine Coast licence. Thirdly the plaintiffs referred to the behaviour of the parties after the documents were handed over on 28 August 1996. They said that Mr Butcher’s conduct later on that day was consistent with an arrangement going beyond the termination of the licence, and that the conduct of the parties implied that the business, including plant and equipment, was to be transferred to Bartercard. Bartercard denied that there was any such offer, acquiescence or agreement. It submitted that the documents which attributed a value to the Central Coast brokerage of $110,020 and purported to set that amount off against BBX’s debt to Bartercard, were prepared for internal accounting purposes in order to reduce the amount of the bad debt which it would eventually be required to write off. Bartercard said that at no time was it contemplated that any amount would actually be due or payable to BBX. Austin J said:“34I have decided to accept the plaintiffs’ submissions on this point. The evidence implies that before 28 August 1996 Bartercard had decided to terminate the Central Coast licence and take control of BBX’s business, because of the mounting trade debt. The volume and complexity of the documentation handed to Mr Butcher on that day implies substantial preparation on Bartercard’s part. Bartercard might have acted by exercising what it conceived to be its right of termination of the licence agreement, without more. But instead, it chose to present to Mr Butcher a package of documents, some of which required his signature and therefore his consent. As the plaintiffs submit, if Bartercard sought to obtain an accounting benefit by reducing the amount of BBX’s debt to be written off, there was no need for it to give anything to Mr Butcher, let alone documents suggesting that he was being given value for termination of the licence.35The package of documents reflected a transaction containing several components, only one of which was the termination of the licence. The transaction included an agreed valuation of the Central Coast brokerage, acknowledged to be fair by Mr Butcher, and the setting off of that agreed value against the debt owed by BBX to Bartercard.36Although Mr Butcher did not sign the documents, events proceeded on 28 August on the basis that the documents reflected a consensual arrangement between the parties. Mr Dietz authorised his colleagues at Bartercard to proceed to the Central Coast office after Mr Butcher arrived for their meeting. When Mr Butcher arrived at the Central Coast office, the officers of Bartercard were already in the course of replacing BBX there, without Mr Butcher’s previous authority. He acquiesced in and co-operated with that process. If Bartercard’s conduct at the Central Coast office had been referable to their prior unilateral termination of the licence, it is unlikely that Mr Butcher would have conducted himself in the way he did. His co-operative conduct confirms that the parties were proceeding under an arrangement for the amicable replacement of Mr Butcher and BBX.37Additionally, a letter by Bartercard’s managing director to Ms Nea Roberts, an employee of BBX, dated 28 August 1996 tends to confirm that the replacement of Mr Butcher was pursuant to an arrangement. The letter referred to the meeting earlier that day between Mr Dietz and Mr Butcher, and said that ‘as a result of that meeting Colin has relinquished his role as a Bartercard broker and his company’s licence has been withdrawn’. Moreover, on 30 August 1996 Mr Dietz wrote to all staff saying that Mr Butcher was co-operating fully with the actions of Bartercard to secure the future of the Central Coast brokerage.38It is reasonable to infer, and I do infer, that the consensual arrangement implied by this evidence was the arrangement presented to Mr Butcher in the documents handed to him on 28 August 1996, which included the valuation and setting off of the goodwill of the Central Coast business.39Bartercard submits that the documents handed to Mr Butcher on 28 August 1996 were inconsistent, and so they cannot be used as the basis for inferring an arrangement. Paragraph (6) of the document identified in paragraph (d) above [sic - in fact Austin J was referring to document (c)] provides that commission will be forfeited, but the settlement sheet (paragraph (i)) set out an accounting to BBX for commissions. In my opinion, however, there is no inconsistency between the documents, since the settlement sheet refers to commissions that have already become due, while the other document refers to forfeiture of the right to future commission.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.