[BARRY v NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK]
COURT OF APPEAL
PINCUS JA
No 257 of 2000
DUCHESNE ROSE PHILLIPINE BARRY Appellant (Defendant)
and
NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK
ACN 004 044 937 Respondent (Plaintiff)
BRISBANE
..DATE 04/02/2000
JUDGMENT
PINCUS JA: This application, which I heard this morning, sought relief in respect of two matters: one, leave to file a notice of appeal against an order made on 7 December 1999, and secondly a stay pending determination of the appeal. Because Mr Sheahan, counsel for the respondent, says that he is not ready to argue the application for leave to file notice of appeal, I propose to deal with the stay only.
The order, made on 7 December 1999, which is sought to be stayed was one that unless the applicant Mrs Barry paid a sum of $37,034.35 into Court within 28 days, the respondent bank should be at liberty to enter judgment to recover possession of certain land. The money was not paid into Court and so, subject to any order which may be made for a stay pending appeal, the bank is entitled to recover possession.
The order which Atkinson J made was made on an application for judgment by the bank on the basis of a deed of settlement which I will mention later. The land the subject of the order was one on which there are three mortgages registered. First, one in favour of the bank; second, one in favour of a company called Equityloan Securities Proprietary Limited, and there is a third mortgage.
There has also been registered an instrument giving the Equityloan mortgage priority over the bank's mortgage. There is an affidavit providing evidence that Mrs Barry is in default under both of the other mortgages, that is the mortgages other than the bank's, and the bank also says she is in default under its mortgage. The material discloses that the amount due under the third mortgage is a matter of dispute. With respect to the Equityloan mortgage it is said the arrears are about $17,000 and the total of the debt is over $385,000.
One of the principal matters upon which reliance was placed on behalf of Mrs Barry is an affidavit which she made providing evidence that, if the land in question on which her family home is situated has to be vacated, that will cause considerable hardship to those comprising her family and in particular a disabled daughter. It is unnecessary to go into the details of that or of those relating to another child who will be inconvenienced by moving.
It seems clear however that the order cannot be stayed merely on that ground; there must be some reason to think that the order made by Atkinson J. was in error. For the purpose of determining that, it is not necessary of course to go into the facts in every case; it may be clear on the face of the matter, that there is a substantial appeal. Here, however, the matters sworn…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Barry v National Australia Bank and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] QCA 12
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the order made by Atkinson J. was in error and if the bank's security rights could be superseded. The court examined the evidence provided by Mrs. Barry, including an affidavit stating that if the land in question had to be vacated, it would cause considerable hardship to her family, particularly a disabled daughter. The court considered the settlement deed executed by Mrs. Barry, which outlined the terms of the agreement between the parties. Mrs. Barry argued that the deed was unenforceable due to the circumstances of its execution.
The court held that the evidence did not support the notion that the order made by Atkinson J. was in error. The claims relied upon by Mrs. Barry to resist the bank were vague and obscure, and the bank's security rights were not superseded. The court emphasised that it was not good policy to make commercial agreements supported by security ineffective or to delay recourse to them unless there was a real justification for doing so.
The court refused the application for a stay, concluding that the allegations raised against the bank had not been strengthened but rather weakened by the evidence filed in this application. The court acknowledged the personal hardship that the exercise of security rights might cause to the debtor and the debtor's family, but found no justification for further staying the proceedings. The court dismissed the application for a stay with costs.
The final orders were that the application for a stay would be dismissed with costs and that the time for compliance with the original order of Justice Atkinson's would not be extended.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.