Barry v Chief of the General Staff

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE

APPEAL TRIBUNAL DFDAT NO 1 of 1994

IN THE MATTER OF THE DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE APPEALS ACT 1955

2

B E T W E E N :

WARREN LESLIE PATRICK BARRY

Appellant

A N D :

CHIEF OF NAVAL STAFF

Respondent

TRIBUNAL: THE HON JUSTICE NORTHROP - PRESIDENT

THE HON JUSTICE COX - DEPUTY PRESIDENT

THE HON JUSTICE GALLOP - MEMBER

PLACE :  SYDNEY
m:  26 AUGUST 1994

MINUTES OF ORDER

THE TRIBUNAL ORDERS THAT:

1.    The appeal be dismissed.

2.
There be no order as to costs.

DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE

APPEAL TRIBUNAL DFDAT No 1 of 1994

IN THE MATTER OFTHE DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE APPEALS ACT 1955

AND THE DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE ACT 1982

B E T W E E N :

WARREN LESLIE PATRICK BARRY

Appellant

A N D :

CHIEF OF NAVAL STAFF

Respondent

TRIBUNAL: THE HON MR JUSTICE NORTHROP - PRESIDENT

THE HON MR JUSTICE COX - DEPUTY PRESIDENT

THE HON MR JUSTICE GALLOP - MEMBER

PLACE: SYDNEY

DATE:  26 AUGUST 1994

REASONS FOR DECISION

NORTHROP J

I would dismiss the appeal and I agree with the reasons as expressed by Cox J. I

have nothing further to say on that issue.

The appellant was charged before a general court-martial on seven counts of which

the f i s t three were charges of committing an act of indecency upon three naval ratings without their consent, contrary to the Defence Force Discipline Act 1982, s61 and the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) in its application to the Jervis Bay Territory, s9Z. The fourth count alleged an assault upon a superior officer (Defence Force Discipline Act 1982, s25); the fifth disobedience of a lawful command (Defence Force Discipline Act 1982, s27); and the last two prejudicial behaviour contrary to the Defence Force Discipline Act 1982, s60, firstly, in that he attended a service function at HMAS Derwent in a dishevelled state and while intoxicated, and lastly in that he urinated from HMAS Denvent into Devonport Harbour. He was convicted on counts four, five and six and acquitted on count seven. His appeal is confined to hisconvictions on counts one and two.

His first complaint is that the judge-advocate misdirected the court-martial or
alternatively failed to adequately direct the court-martial as to the need for the prosecution to
establish that the appellant had the requisite mens rea. It was submitted, on the appellant's behalf,

that he was entitled to a direction that the prosecution had to satisfy the court that he intended to commit an act of indecency. As the submission was developed it involved the proposition that he must be shown to have known that the act was an act of indecency, that is, an act of a sexual nature

which offended the standards of decency of ordinary members of the community, and that he . . ~ : .

intended to commit such an act. Reliance was placed on Director of Public Prosecutions v Morgan . , ~.
[l9761 AC 182. In…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barry v Chief of the General Staff and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] ADFDAT 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Barry v Chief of Naval Staff involved an appeal by Warren Leslie Patrick Barry, who had been convicted by a general court-martial on several counts, including assault, disobedience of a lawful command, and prejudicial behaviour. Barry challenged his convictions on counts one and two, which were for committing acts of indecency without consent. The legal issues before the court included whether the judge-advocate had adequately directed the court-martial on the necessary mens rea for the acts of indecency, whether the acts in question were indeed acts of indecency, and whether the convictions were unsafe and unsatisfactory. The court also considered whether there were any irregularities in the trial process that could have led to a miscarriage of justice.

The court found that the judge-advocate had not misdirected the court-martial regarding the mens rea necessary for the acts of indecency. The court clarified that the prosecution did not need to prove that the appellant appreciated that his actions were indecent by community standards, but rather that the act itself was indecent. The court further held that the acts in question, though not necessarily sexual in intent, were indeed acts of indecency as they had a sexual context and were offensive to the complainants. The court also determined that the convictions were safe and satisfactory, as the evidence presented supported the complainants' allegations, and the court-martial had the ability to discriminate between charges.

Regarding the alleged irregularities in the trial process, the court found that there was no basis for closing the trial to the media or for delaying the trial due to a concurrent senate inquiry. The court also concluded that trying all charges together did not lead to any miscarriage of justice, as the evidence was largely relevant and the court-martial demonstrated its ability to discriminate between charges.

The court dismissed the appeal and refused the respondent's application for costs, finding that the appeal had some merit and that there were no circumstances warranting an order for costs against the appellant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Warren Leslie Patrick Barry was charged before a general court-martial on seven counts related to his conduct while serving in the Australian Defence Force. The charges included three counts of committing acts of indecency upon three naval ratings without their consent, an assault on a superior officer, disobedience of a lawful command, and two counts of prejudicial behaviour. Barry was convicted on counts four, five, and six but acquitted on count seven. His appeal focused on his convictions on counts one and two, which involved charges of committing acts of indecency. The complainants alleged that Barry had touched them in a sexual manner without their consent. Barry admitted to some physical contact but denied the specific acts of indecency.

Barry's case was heard by the Defence Force Discipline Appeal Tribunal, which consisted of The Hon Mr Justice Northrop, The Hon Mr Justice Cox, and The Hon Mr Justice Gallop. The appeal was against the decision of a lower court-martial that had convicted Barry on counts one and two. The Tribunal reviewed the evidence, the conduct of the trial, and the legal arguments presented by both parties. Ultimately, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal and refused the respondent's application for costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the judge-advocate misdirect the court-martial or fail to adequately direct it regarding the need for the prosecution to establish that Barry had the requisite mens rea for the acts of indecency?
2. Are Barry's convictions on counts one and two unsafe and unsatisfactory?
3. Are there any alleged irregularities in the trial process that led to a miscarriage of justice?

Held
1. The court dismissed the appeal, upholding the appellant's convictions on counts four, five and six and his acquittal on count seven.
2. The convictions on counts one and two were deemed safe and satisfactory, despite the appellant's challenges.
3. The court found no irregularities in the trial process that would constitute a miscarriage of justice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the appellant's first complaint that the judge-advocate misdirected the court-martial regarding the need for the prosecution to establish the appellant's mens rea for the acts of indecency. The court found that the judge-advocate adequately directed the court-martial, emphasizing that the prosecution only needed to prove the external act of indecency, not the appellant's awareness of its indecency. This interpretation aligned with the legislative intent and the court's understanding of the required mens rea, as established in Director of Public Prosecutions v Morgan. The court further found that the acts described in counts one and two were clearly indecent, regardless of the appellant's intent or perception.

The court then examined the safety and satisfaction of the convictions on counts one and two. The complainant's evidence, corroborated by the appellant's admissions and other witnesses, sufficiently supported the court-martial's findings. The court rejected the argument that the acquittal on count seven undermined the reliability of the complainant's testimony regarding counts one and two.

Finally, the court addressed the alleged irregularities in the trial process. It dismissed claims regarding the judge-advocate's refusal to close the court to the media, the timing of the trial in relation to a Senate inquiry, and the joint trial of indecency and disciplinary charges. The court concluded that these factors did not prejudice the trial's fairness or result in a miscarriage of justice. The court also declined to order the appellant to pay the respondent's costs, finding the appeal had some merit and did not warrant such an order.