FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Barrick (Australia Pacific Exploration) Pty Limited v Barrick (PD) Australia Pty Limited, in the matter of Barrick (Australia Pacific Exploration) Pty Limited [2017] FCA 998
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Barrick (Australia Pacific Exploration) Pty Ltd v Barrick (P... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FCA 998
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court made orders convening meetings to consider the proposed schemes of arrangement and approving an explanatory statement subject to minor amendments. The court also made orders regarding the convening, holding, and conduct of the meetings, the appointment of a chairperson, the quorum, and the recording of resolutions. The court extended the time for lodging the explanatory statement with ASIC and exempted the plaintiffs from certain procedural requirements. The court granted liberty to apply and ordered that the orders be entered forthwith and an office copy be lodged with ASIC.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Pursuant to s 411 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), there be convened:
(a) by the first plaintiff (Barrick (Australia Pacific Exploration) Pty Limited (ACN 008 648 440), a meeting of the holder of the fully paid ordinary shares in the capital of the first plaintiff to be held in Perth, Western Australia on Tuesday 22 August 2017 at 11:30am (WST) (or on such other date and such other time as the Court may approve) for the purpose of considering and if thought fit, approving with or without modifications, the scheme of arrangement proposed between the first plaintiff and its shareholder, being contained in the supplementary affidavit of Luke Reginald Stephenson Fleming sworn 15 August 2017 at Annexure LRSF42 pages 45 - 62.
(b) by the second plaintiff (Barrick (GSM) Pty Limited (ACN 002 594 881)), a meeting of the holder of the fully paid ordinary shares in the capital of the second plaintiff to be held in Perth, Western Australia on Tuesday 22 August 2017 at 11:35am (WST) (or as soon as practicable after the meeting in order 1(a) above, or on such other date and such other time as the Court may approve) for the purpose of considering and if thought fit, approving with or without modifications, the scheme of arrangement proposed between the second plaintiff and its shareholder, being contained in the supplementary affidavit of Luke Reginald Stephenson Fleming sworn 15 August 2017 at Annexure LRSF42 pages 45 - 62.
(c) by the third plaintiff (Delta Gold Pty Limited (ACN 002 527 899)), a meeting of the holder of the fully paid ordinary shares in the capital of the third plaintiff to be held in Perth, Western Australia on Tuesday 22 August 2017 at 11.40am (WST) (or as soon as practicable after the meeting in order 1(b) above, or on such other date and such other time as the Court may approve) for the purpose of considering and if thought fit, approving with or without modifications, the scheme of arrangement proposed between the third plaintiff and its shareholder, being contained in the supplementary affidavit of Luke Reginald Stephenson Fleming sworn 15 August 2017 at Annexure LRSF42 pages 45 - 62.
(d) by the fourth plaintiff (Barrick (Kalgoorlie) Pty Limited (ACN 009 712 092)), a meeting of the holder of the fully paid ordinary shares in the capital of the fourth plaintiff to be held in Perth, Western Australia on Tuesday 22 August 2017 at 11.45am (WST) (or as soon as practicable after the meeting in order 1(c) above, or on such other date and such other time as the Court may approve) for the purpose of considering and if thought fit, approving with or without modifications, the scheme of arrangement proposed between the fourth plaintiff and its shareholder, being contained in the supplementary affidavit of Luke Reginald Stephenson Fleming sworn 15 August 2017 at Annexure LRSF42 pages 45 – 62, as amended to refer to an ‘amalgamation’ in the proposed scheme document at clause 4.4.
(e) by the fifth plaintiff (AurionGold Pty Limited (ACN 008 560 978)), a meeting of the holder of the fully paid ordinary shares in the capital of the fifth plaintiff to be held in Perth, Western Australia on Tuesday 22 August 2017 at 11.50am (WST) (or as soon as practicable after the meeting in order 1(d) above, or on such other date and such other time as the Court may approve) for the purpose of considering and if thought fit, approving with or without modifications, the scheme of arrangement proposed between the fifth plaintiff and its shareholder, being contained in the supplementary affidavit of Luke Reginald Stephenson Fleming sworn 15 August 2017 at Annexure LRSF42 pages 45 - 62.
(f) by the sixth plaintiff (Barrick (Granny Smith) Pty Limited (ACN 009 466 175)), a meeting of the holder of the fully paid ordinary shares in the capital of the sixth plaintiff to be held in Perth, Western Australia on Tuesday 22 August 2017 at 11.55am (WST) (or as soon as practicable after the meeting in order 1(e) above, or on such other date and such other time as the Court may approve) for the purpose of considering and if thought fit, approving with or without modifications, the scheme of arrangement proposed between the sixth plaintiff and its shareholder, being contained in the supplementary affidavit of Luke Reginald Stephenson Fleming sworn 15 August 2017 at Annexure LRSF42 pages 45 - 62.
(together, the Scheme Meetings).
2. Pursuant to s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the explanatory statement required by s 412(1)(a) of the Corporations Act and being contained in the supplementary affidavit of Luke Reginald Stephenson Fleming sworn 15 August 2017 at Annexure LRSF42 pages 29-88, be and is approved, subject to:
(a) correction of any minor typographical or grammatical errors and the date of the Scheme Meetings (above); and
(b) any minor amendments required or approved by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) for registration under s 412(6) of the Corporations Act.
3. Each of the Scheme Meetings shall be convened by a notice of meeting, a copy of which forms part of the approved explanatory statement in order 2 above, accompanied by a copy of the explanatory statement.
4. Subject to registration of the explanatory statement pursuant to s 412(6) of the Corporations Act, service of the notice of meeting and accompanying explanatory statement (substantially in the form of the of the document approved in order 2 above) may be effected by electronic means or by hand delivery to a person who is a director of the member or a person who is a proxy, corporate representative appointed under section 250D of the Corporations Act or attorney under power, of each member of the applicable plaintiff at any time before a relevant meeting commences.
5. Dispatch of the documents referred to in order 4 above in general accordance with its terms is to be taken to be sufficient notice of the Scheme Meetings.
6. Subject to these orders, the Scheme Meetings are to be (so far as practicable):
(a) convened, held and conducted in accordance with the provisions of Part 2G.2 of the Corporations Act that apply to members of a company and the provisions of the plaintiffs’ constitutions that are not inconsistent therewith and that apply to meetings of members;
(b) convened, held and conducted pursuant to s 1319 of the Corporations Act, on short notice at the times set out in order 1 and on the basis that Corporations Regulations 5.6.11 to 5.6.11A and 5.6.13A to 5.6.36A do not apply to the Scheme Meetings; and
(c) convened using the notices of meetings substantially in the form or to the effect of the notices to be contained in or accompanying the explanatory statement.
7. Mr Daniel David Kirk or, failing him, Mr Derek Noel La Ferla is to be appointed to act as chairperson of the Scheme Meetings (Chairperson) and report the result of the Scheme Meetings to this Court.
8. The Chairperson of each of the Scheme Meetings has the power to adjourn each such meeting, in his absolute discretion.
9. A single shareholder present in person or by proxy, corporate representative or attorney under power and entitled to vote shall constitute a quorum for each of the Scheme Meetings.
10. A proxy, appointment of corporate representative or power of attorney to act on behalf of a member of a plaintiff may be delivered to the Chairperson of the relevant scheme meeting at any time up until the vote is cast on a resolution at that meeting.
11. A resolution put to the vote at any stage of the scheme meetings to approve the proposed schemes of arrangement, or any modification to the proposed schemes of arrangement, must be recorded by the member or its representative signing a record of the resolution.
12. The matter is to be relisted on Friday 1 September 2017 for such applications as appropriate following the Scheme Meetings.
13. If the matter is relisted, the plaintiffs are to give notice of the hearing of the applications pursuant to ss 411(4)(b) and 413 of the Corporations Act for orders approving the Schemes and other orders by publishing an advertisement in the public notices column of “The Australian” and “The West Australian” newspapers substantially in accordance with “Annexure A” to these orders, such advertisement to be published at least five days before any date allocated for the hearing and the plaintiffs are otherwise exempted from compliance with rule 3.4 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000.
14. The period of 7 days in rule 2.4(2) of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules) be extended to 17 days pursuant to rule 1.39 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
15. There be liberty to apply.
16. These orders be entered forthwith.
17. An office copy of these orders shall be lodged with ASIC as soon as practicable after these orders are made.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter is the first court hearing in relation to the application for orders under section 411 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The application seeks approval for convening meetings at which the shareholders of the six plaintiffs will vote on the proposed schemes of arrangement. The application includes an approval of a draft explanatory statement to be sent to the shareholders. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Are there compromises or arrangements proposed in the schemes?
2. Is there a Pt 5.1 body involved in the schemes?
3. Are there members or creditors of a company involved in the schemes?
4. Are there classes of members or creditors involved in the schemes?
5. Should the Court make orders to convene the meetings for the shareholders to vote on the proposed schemes?
Held
1. There are compromises or arrangements proposed in the schemes.
2. There is not a Pt 5.1 body involved in the schemes.
3. There are members of the companies involved in the schemes.
4. There are not classes of members or creditors involved in the schemes.
5. The Court should make orders to convene the meetings for the shareholders to vote on the proposed schemes.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The ultimate holding company of BRAPL is Barrick Gold Corporation. Barrick Gold Corporation is a Canadian company listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX) and New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and one of the world’s largest gold producers, with interests in producing gold mines in Argentina, Australia, Canada, the Dominican Republic, Papua New Guinea, Peru and the United States, and interests in copper mines in Zambia, Chile and Saudi Arabia. The purpose of the schemes is to consolidate corporate structures within an Australian group. In recent years, GSM, Delta, B(Kal), AurionGold and Granny Smith, disposed of their main undertakings to third parties. Each had either owned and operated a gold mine in Western Australia, or held related joint venture, royalty or tenement rights. BAPE was a service company for those and various other group companies. The six plaintiffs are now otherwise dormant entities. By the terms of the schemes and additional orders made under s 413, it is proposed that there be a reconstruction or amalgamation to reduce the expense and complexity of corporate administration. There are three stages to an application under s 411: (i) Court approval to convene the meetings at which the BAPE shareholder, GSM shareholder, Delta shareholder, B(Kal) shareholder, AurionGold shareholder and Granny Smith shareholder (schemes shareholders) will vote according to their respective holdings in the plaintiffs on the BAPE scheme, GSM scheme, Delta scheme, B(Kal) scheme, AurionGold scheme and the Granny Smith scheme (scheme meetings) and approval of a draft explanatory statement to be sent to the schemes shareholders; (ii) the schemes shareholders voting on the schemes at the scheme meetings; and (iii) Court approval of the schemes: Re CSR Ltd (2010) 183 FCR 358, 362 [7]; [2010] FCAFC 34 (Keane CJ, as he then was, and Jacobson J). The principal questions relevant to this first stage are as follows:·Are there compromises or arrangements?·Is there a Pt 5.1 body?·Are there members or creditors of a company?·Are there classes of members or creditors?·Should the Court make orders to convene meetings? The standard of review at this stage is whether the schemes are not inappropriate and are one that sensible business people might consider of benefit: Re Sonodyne International Ltd (1994) 15 ACSR 494, 499 (Hayne J). If the proposed arrangement is one that seems fit for consideration by a meeting of members (or creditors) and is a commercial proposition likely to gain the Court's approval if passed by the necessary majorities, then leave should be given to convene the meetings: Re ACM Gold Ltd (1992) 107 ALR 359 at 365 (O'Loughlin J). The Court is not required to be satisfied either at the convening or approval stage that no better scheme or schemes could have been devised: Re Foundation Healthcare Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 252 at 265 [44]; [2002] FCA 742 (French J, as he then was). While s 411(2) contains a statement of the circumstances in which a scheme meeting must not be ordered, s 411 contains no statement of the criteria that must be satisfied before a meeting is ordered: Re CSR Ltd at 362-3 [8].