Barrett v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Barrett v Northern Territory of Australia
[2017] NTSC 70

PARTIES:MOLLIE BARRETT

v

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE TERRITORY EXERCISING TERRITORY JURISDICTION

FILE NO:123 of 2015 (21557436)

DELIVERED:  7 September 2017

HEARING DATES:  21 August 2017

JUDGMENT OF:  MASTER LUPPINO

CATCHWORDS:

Practice and Procedure – Summary judgment – Principles to be applied in summary judgment applications – Requirement that there be a real or serious question to be tried.

Practice and Procedure – Expert reports – Time for filing and service – Modification of the time fixed by the Supreme Court rules for filing and service by Practice Direction 6 of 2009 – Orders for filing and service made at a Case Management Conference is otherwise an abridgement of time pursuant to Rule 3.02.

Supreme Court Rules, rr 3.02, 23.01, 23.03, 33.08, 44.03.

Practice Direction 6 of 2009 – Trial Civil Procedure Reforms, paras 17, 18.

Monck v The Commonwealth of Australia [2017] NTSC 49.
Nibbs v Australian Broadcasting Corporation [2010] NTSC 52.
RTA Pty Ltd & Orsv Brinko Pty Ltd & Ors [2017] NTSC 103.
Outback Civil Pty Ltd v Francis [2011] NTCA 3.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:Mr Connolly

Defendant:Mr Crawley

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:Ward Keller

Defendant:Solicitor for the Northern Territory

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  Lup1706

Number of pages:  16

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Barrett v Northern Territory of Australia
[2017] NTSC 70

No. 123 of 2015 (21557436)

BETWEEN:

Mollie Barrett

Plaintiff

AND:

Northern Territory of Australia

Defendant

CORAM:     MASTER LUPPINO

REASONS

(Delivered 7 September 2017)

  1. The Defendant has applied by interlocutory summons for an order for summary judgment pursuant to Rule 23.03 of the Supreme Court Rules (“SCR”).

  2. The relevant parts of Rule 23 of the SCR are:

    23.01     Stay or judgment in proceeding

    (1)Where a proceeding generally or a claim in a proceeding:

    (a)     does not disclose a cause of action;

    (b)     is scandalous, frivolous or vexatious; or

    (c)     is an abuse of the process of the Court,

    the Court may stay the proceeding generally or in relation to a claim or give judgment in the proceeding generally or in relation to a claim.

    (2)Where the defence to a claim in a proceeding:

    (a)     does not disclose an answer;

    (b)     is scandalous, frivolous or vexatious; or

    (c)     is an abuse of the process of the Court,

    the Court may give judgment in the proceeding generally or in relation to the claim.

    (3)Omitted.

    23.03     Summary judgment for defendant

    On application by a defendant who has filed an appearance, the Court at any time may give judgment for the defendant against the plaintiff if the defendant has a good defence on the merits.

  3. I discussed the law in respect of summary judgment applications most recently in Monck v The Commonwealth of Australia.[1] As I pointed out in that case there have been a number of relatively recent instances in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barrett v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NTSC 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Barrett v Northern Territory of Australia, the plaintiff sought damages for alleged negligence by staff at Royal Darwin Hospital, claiming that they failed to properly diagnose and treat an ankle injury, leading to the development of complex regional pain syndrome. The defendant applied for summary judgment, arguing that the plaintiff's case was untenable due to insufficient evidence of breach of duty. The primary legal issue was whether there was a real or serious question to be tried that would warrant proceeding to a trial. The court examined the principles governing summary judgment applications, particularly the requirement that there must be a real or serious question to be tried. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff's evidence was sufficient to establish a breach of duty of care.

The court found that the plaintiff's expert report, provided by Dr. Saxby, indicated that the treatment and assessment of the plaintiff's injury were appropriate and consistent with the standard of care expected of a reasonably skilled and careful medical practitioner. However, the report also highlighted that the plaintiff did not show significant improvement over time, and the symptoms observed were not consistent with a lateral ligament injury, suggesting a potential misdiagnosis or oversight. Despite the expert's opinion that the care seemed appropriate, the court acknowledged the plaintiff's concern that there was a failure to diagnose and appropriately treat the injury leading to the development of complex regional pain syndrome. The court concluded that the plaintiff's case was not so clearly untenable that it could not possibly succeed, as there was sufficient evidence to raise a serious question about the adequacy of the care provided. Therefore, the court denied the defendant's application for summary judgment.

In light of the court's decision, the defendant's application for summary judgment was dismissed, allowing the plaintiff's claim to proceed to trial. The court found that there was a real or serious question to be tried concerning the adequacy of the care provided by the defendant's staff, and thus, the case could not be decided on the basis of summary judgment. The plaintiff's claim would be evaluated further at trial to determine whether the defendant breached the duty of care owed to the plaintiff and whether such a breach caused the plaintiff's alleged injuries.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Although the reports in this case are medical in nature, they are provided as expert’s reports. Service of expert reports is provided for in Order 44 of the SCR. Rule 44.03(1)(a) provides:-44.03 Service of statement of expert evidence(1)A party who intends at a trial to adduce the evidence of a person as an expert witness shall:(a)not later than the time fixed by a Judge, the Master or a Registrar at a listing hearing or directions hearing held under Order 48; or(b) where no such time is fixed:(i) 6 weeks before the day fixed for the trial; or(ii)before a directions hearing under rule 48.34 to ensure that a proceeding is ready to proceed to trial,whichever is the earlier,serve on every other party a statement in accordance with subrule (2). Where PD6 applies there is no listing hearing as provided for in Rule 44.03(1)(a). That is by reason of paragraph 18 of PD6 providing that Rules 48.16 to 48.19 inclusive, which includes the rule relating to a listing hearing, have no force where PD6 operates. As a Case Management Conference in PD6 matters is in lieu of a listing hearing, Rule 44.03(1)(a) must be read as if the reference to a listing hearing in that Rule was a reference to a Case Management Conference. In any case, and although it is not specifically provided for in PD6, in my view orders made for the provision of evidence at a Case Management Conference necessarily have the effect of abridging, pursuant to Rule 3.02, the time otherwise fixed by the SCR for the filing and service of expert reports. In my view therefore, for all these reasons the orders made on 20 June 2016 take precedence over the timeframe set by Rule 44.03(1)(b), at least absent a further order or leave. An analysis of the Plaintiff’s expert evidence now follows to assess the Defendant’s submission that there is insufficient evidence to enable the Plaintiff to establish breach of duty. The report of Dr Saxby dated 17 October 2016 was in evidence.[8] Relevantly that report shows that Dr Saxby was asked:-Are you able to comment on whether the evaluation of my client’s left ankle sprain was consistent with the standard of care expected of a reasonably skilled and careful medical practitioner in 2012? Please provide reasons for your opinion. In answer Dr Saxby noted the initial treatment and the first discharge for subsequent review and said:-“This would indicate that this lady was initially assessed and treated appropriately in the emergency department as one would expect for a severe ankle (soft tissue) injury.”Dr Saxby then commented on events occurring in the subsequent reviews and went on to say:-“This lady’s care does seem appropriate throughout the outpatient visits but because of her ongoing pain, on 22.11.12, she was further investigated with an MRI Scan which once again confirmed a lateral ligament injury (soft tissue injury) but no bony injury. Therefore, the care received would seem appropriate. The only concern is that when this lady was regularly reviewed and assessed, she did not show a great deal of improvement. The first sign of any abnormal course is on 5.12.12 and it was noted that this lady had hyper aesthesia and discolouration. This was not consistent with a lateral ligament injury but is more consistent with a diagnosis of complex regional pain syndrome. Therefore, I believe this lady’s treatment and assessment appears to be appropriate during her episodes of care at the Darwin Hospital.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

The relevant parts of Rule 23 of the SCR are:23.01 Stay or judgment in proceeding(1)Where a proceeding generally or a claim in a proceeding:(a) does not disclose a cause of action;(b) is scandalous, frivolous or vexatious; or(c) is an abuse of the process of the Court,the Court may stay the proceeding generally or in relation to a claim or give judgment in the proceeding generally or in relation to a claim.(2)Where the defence to a claim in a proceeding:(a) does not disclose an answer;(b) is scandalous, frivolous or vexatious; or(c) is an abuse of the process of the Court,the Court may give judgment in the proceeding generally or in relation to the claim.(3)Omitted.23.03 Summary judgment for defendantOn application by a defendant who has filed an appearance, the Court at any time may give judgment for the defendant against the plaintiff if the defendant has a good defence on the merits. I discussed the law in respect of summary judgment applications most recently in Monck v The Commonwealth of Australia.[1] As I pointed out in that case there have been a number of relatively recent instances in the Northern Territory where the applicable principles have been discussed. There was a detailed examination of the authorities in Nibbs v Australian Broadcasting Corporation[2] (“Nibbs”) and RTA Pty Ltd & Orsv Brinko Pty Ltd & Ors.[3] In Nibbs, I said that the test to be applied was whether there is a real or serious question to be tried. In Outback Civil Pty Ltd v Francis[4] (“Outback Civil”) the Court of Appeal held that Rule 23.03 will only be enlivened where the plaintiff’s case is “so clearly untenable that it could not possibly succeed”.[5] In the substantive proceedings the Plaintiff claims damages for injury alleged to arise as a result of the negligence of employed staff at Royal Darwin Hospital (“RDH”) for which the Defendant is vicariously liable. The claimed breach of duty is in respect of the treatment given for an ankle injury. The specific allegation in the Plaintiff’s Statement of Claim is that the Defendant failed to diagnose a ligamentous injury, failed to appropriately treat the Plaintiff’s injury, in particular that it failed to appropriately treat an ankle sprain. The background facts are that the Plaintiff attended at RDH on 22 September 2012 after having injured her left ankle. Following examination, the Plaintiff’s leg was immobilised by use of a below the knee back slab and she was discharged for subsequent review on 28 September 2012. Following a number of reviews, and while the immobilisation was maintained by one means or another, an MRI was performed and subsequently, on 5 December 2012, the Plaintiff was diagnosed with complex[6] regional pain syndrome. Success on the claim in negligence requires the Plaintiff to establish firstly that the Defendant owed the Plaintiff a duty of care; secondly, that there was a breach of the duty of care and lastly that the Plaintiff suffered loss as a consequence of the breach.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established